Decisions > Assessment

Jonathan Willis
July 01 2010 01:36AM

ANAHEIM, CA - FEBRUARY 10: Ethan Moreau #18 of the Edmonton Oilers celebrates after scoring a shorthanded goal in the second period against the Anaheim Ducks at the Honda Center on February 10, 2010 in Anaheim, California. The Ducks defeated the Oilers 3-2. (Photo by Jeff Gross/Getty Images)

While I’m not euphoric over the recent moves made by Oilers general manager Steve Tambellini, they do show a certain willingness on his part to get his hands dirty and do what needs to be done, and as a result the Oilers approach July 1 in a better position than might have been expected only a few short weeks ago.

Now, a lot has happened over the last week that I haven’t had a chance to comment on, so I’m going to go through some of the changes in rapid-fire succession without lingering over any of them. It’s important to do so now, before free agency hits and more action comes.

- First, on the removal of Pat Quinn and the instalment of Tom Renney as head coach: I think it needed to be done. From the tidbits the beat writers pass along and from the way the bench was managed this year, a change needed to be made and I’m glad it was. It seems likely Kelly Buchberger will remain on the staff given his survival of the previous year’s purge, but while I’m agnostic on that count I hope the team continues to employ Wayne Fleming, who I’ll stubbornly insist helped with the power play.

- The qualification offers to both Devan Dubnyk and Jeff Deslauriers, as well as the fact both remained Oilers property through the Entry Draft surprised me, and I’m not quite sure how to take it. It’s possible the Oilers wish to retain an insurance option until they’re sure whether Nikolai Khabibulin will be available to start the year, and it’s also possible the market for whichever one they wanted to move was decidedly limited.

- Speaking of surprising qualification offers, the continued employment of Jean-Francois Jacques, Liam Reddox and Ryan O’Marra surprised me. Jacques had his name mentioned by Tambellini in his end of season press conference, so he’s perhaps the least surprising, but despite his physical attributes the combination of chronic health issues and lacklustre offensive/defensive play had me wondering if he’d get the axe. Reddox was a pleasant surprise; he’s a good AHL depth guy who can play NHL minutes if he needs to. Meanwhile, the organization still sees enough in O’Marra to keep him around, presumably in a similar role to Reddox after his (career-best) 18-point AHL season. Given how high his NHL salary is if he’s called up, I’d half expected the Oilers to pass on qualifying him and try to negotiate his price down a bit on a two-way deal.

- The departures of Ryan Potulny and Marc Pouliot also caught me a bit by surprise, and while I’m saddened to see them go I’ll admit the odds are fairly decent the Oilers aren’t going to be regretting the decision for years to come. Potulny’s a good depth option who just got caught with a somewhat redundant skill-set for this team, and I hope he does well elsewhere. I was more surprised that Pouliot was cut loose; to my eye he played excellent hockey after coming back from injury mid-season, with some offence and a greater willingness to battle and handle checking duties. I think he could have helped the team in a depth role, and that it was a (possibly negligible) mistake to let him leave.

- That said, the guy who seems likely to replace Pouliot – newly acquired Colin Fraser – is a player who at first glance looks like a very nice addition. He brings the grit that this team wants to acquire, but he can play the game too and he’s spent a lot of time on the penalty kill the last few years. His faceoff numbers are not so hot (less than 50.0% both of the last two years) but given the number of PK draws he’s taken he’s probably at least an average faceoff man (as a player is less likely to win a PK faceoff).

- I wasn’t a fan of the Ethan Moreau buyout, simply because I’d have preferred to see his salary eaten in one year rather than stretched out down the road when the Oilers should be moving towards respectability, so seeing Columbus pick him up on waivers was very nice. I’m sure Scott Howson is thinking back to 2005-06 Moreau rather than the edition from this past season, and I don’t see how this move is going to work out for the Blue Jackets (who don’t have all kinds of dollars to overpay depth players like Moreau) but it was nice for the Oilers, and helps a guy who has done a lot for the city he plays in look a little better at the same time.

- I was on board with the Nilsson/O’Sullivan buyouts, and on the whole I like the trade of O’Sullivan for Jim Vandermeer. Vandermeer’s overpaid relative to his skill level (keep in mind the Coyotes planned to pay him to go away) but his particular skill-set is needed on the Oilers, and he’s a legitimate NHL defenceman. Besides, if things go really badly, his contract expires at the end of the year. Both Steve Tambellini and Don Maloney fared well on this deal.

- The departure of Riley Nash on draft day was not a surprise, and probably will work out best for both parties. For all the talk about Nash’s lack of interest in the Oilers (and more specifically, their AHL franchise), the Oilers never seemed to have a handle on the player. It’s interesting that Carolina was willing to gamble on him; they had problems with another player who liked the college life who they eventually dealt (Jack Johnson) after being unable to get him signed and one would think they’d prefer to avoid that scenario here. That said, Carolina’s farm team last year (Albany) was a strong one despite a less than impressive depth chart at centre, so perhaps it’s a more attractive option for Nash.

- All in all, a pretty good week for the Oilers. I’ve been as critical of Tambellini as anyone, but while I don’t think he’s been perfect he deserves credit for making some tough decisions and making it clear that he does have a plan (whatever that plan may be). If he can follow up this ground work with some solid depth free agents and a successful resolution to the Sheldon Souray issue (more on that here), we’ll have some reason for genuine excitement.

- I can’t help but make some comments on 630 CHED’s coverage of the second day of the NHL draft. I listened to the entire program, and I had to laugh when Bob Stauffer suggested Carolina might acquire Nash, Dan Tencer shot him down, and the Canes promptly made the trade. There’s no question about Stauffer’s access, so I couldn’t quite get a handle on why Tencer was so adamant. It wasn’t a great day for Tencer (side point: I’ve had both positive and negative encounters with him, and have no particular axe to grind here) who had no clue who Martin Marincin or Curtis Hamilton were, suggested that Ken Hitchcock might be forced to accept an assistant coaching job if he wants to stay in the game, and said that a Steve Ott-type player was a disappointing turnout for a late first-round pick. In the first case, if one is covering the NHL Draft, he should take the time to flip through one of the prospect magazines – I recommend McKeen’s, but THN’s product is reasonable too – where both of those players were listed. Both players were consensus second round guys who didn’t exactly come out of nowhere to get selected. As for Hitchcock, yes he’s been fired but he’s also a Stanley Cup-winning coach with an impeccable junior record who guided Philadelphia well prior to their 2006-07 collapse and who was the man behind the Blue Jacket’s only post-season appearance. He won’t be forced into anything. Finally, the disparaging of Ott just shows a gross lack of knowledge about the average career of a late first round pick – as a quick glance at the bottom third of (almost) any draft’s first round shows. It was the kind of day that an hour or two of research the week before would have made a lot more bearable.

- Finally, I’d be remiss if I didn’t comment on Wanye’s big announcement one article down. Lowetide was the first guy I ever read in the blogosphere, a place to get an Oilers fix when nobody else was talking about them. But he’s more than that: he’s relentlessly sane in a hyperbole-rich environment, he’s good natured in a place where there’s a rush to take offence, he’s got tradition and history on his side but also a willingness to explore new ideas. I wouldn’t have ever started a blog if I hadn’t had his example to start from.

- Oh, and very last: I’ll be back on the Nation starting regularly this month; not every day as I have been in the past, but multiple times per week every week. Well, for as long as Wanye puts up with me, anyway.

74b7cedc5d8bfbe88cf071309e98d2c3
Jonathan Willis is a freelance writer. He currently works for Oilers Nation, the Edmonton Journal and Bleacher Report. He's co-written three books and worked for myriad websites, including Grantland, ESPN, The Score, and Hockey Prospectus. He was previously the founder and managing editor of Copper & Blue.
Avatar
#1 Maggie the Monkey
July 01 2010, 01:56AM
Trash it!
0
trashes
+1
0
props

This very good week for Oilers fans has been made even better by your return to the Nation, Mr. Willis. While I also enjoy your writing on the Score's site, it's great to find out that you'll be contributing regularly here again. Welcome back!

Avatar
#2 Suntory Hanzo
July 01 2010, 02:15AM
Trash it!
0
trashes
+1
0
props

Welcome Back JW! You have been missed.

Avatar
#3 Eric Johnson
July 01 2010, 02:18AM
Trash it!
0
trashes
+1
0
props

OMG OMG WILLIS IS BACK!!!!!!! He shouteth to thy heavens that WILLIS IS BACK!!!!!

*ahem*

Welcome back sir

Avatar
#4 Hemmertime
July 01 2010, 02:34AM
Trash it!
0
trashes
+1
0
props

Willis back, Lowetide aboard. A great day for ON

Avatar
#5 David S
July 01 2010, 03:15AM
Trash it!
0
trashes
+1
0
props

Jonathan - you sir have been missed.

--David

Avatar
#6 The Towel Boy
July 01 2010, 07:21AM
Trash it!
0
trashes
+1
0
props

Good to read you again J-Dub.

Avatar
#7 Chris.
July 01 2010, 07:23AM
Trash it!
0
trashes
+1
0
props

Good to hear from you Willis. It's been too long; I felt like I had lost a friend... (Or at least an interesting, though occasionally annoying aquaintance)

Avatar
#8 Skidplate
July 01 2010, 07:32AM
Trash it!
0
trashes
+1
0
props

As above JW, good to see you back on ON. This site keeps getting stronger and stronger.

Wanye, you have to find a way to keep the IT folks at the various companies we work at from finding out how much time we spend on here or you may have a rush of resumes coming your way.

Happy days ahead :)

Avatar
#9 Ducey
July 01 2010, 07:32AM
Trash it!
0
trashes
+1
0
props

I see Ethan Moreau did not go quitely into the night.

As reported in the Journal this a.m. he says that Howson built the 2006 cup team and that it wasn't a coincidence things fell apart after Howson left.

I'm sure he will find things so much more successful in Columbus

Avatar
#10 RossCreekNation
July 01 2010, 07:47AM
Trash it!
0
trashes
+1
0
props

On O'Marra: "Given how high his NHL salary is if he’s called up, I’d half expected the Oilers to pass on qualifying him and try to negotiate his price down a bit on a two-way deal."

His base salary last year was only 765k. Sure, he should probably be at league minimum, but 765+ raise isn't that high of a cost for a guy that likely won't see more than 5-10 days up in the bigs (if any), is it? And where did you hear it wouldn't be a 2-way deal?

Oh... and we missed you Jonathan ;-)

Avatar
#11 Bookie
July 01 2010, 08:12AM
Trash it!
0
trashes
+1
0
props
Ducey wrote:

I see Ethan Moreau did not go quitely into the night.

As reported in the Journal this a.m. he says that Howson built the 2006 cup team and that it wasn't a coincidence things fell apart after Howson left.

I'm sure he will find things so much more successful in Columbus

I think one of the biggest mistakes was the selection of their captain.

Avatar
#12 madjam
July 01 2010, 08:14AM
Trash it!
0
trashes
+1
0
props
Ducey wrote:

I see Ethan Moreau did not go quitely into the night.

As reported in the Journal this a.m. he says that Howson built the 2006 cup team and that it wasn't a coincidence things fell apart after Howson left.

I'm sure he will find things so much more successful in Columbus

MOREAU TAKES HATCHET TO UPPER MANAGEMENT ! After Souray makes tactful initial incision , Moreau takes hatchet and bitterly drives into heart of Oilers problems !! How many more are this bitter towards our upper management operandi , and how far out to rest of players in the NHL does this sentiment linger ? A REAL EYE OPENER the caustic comments Moreau leaves under .

To think the same ones that were paramount in the disaster , and should have been most accountable , is a bigger concern now than ever . They are now also in the process of making the decisions to fix the very problems and toxic product/environment they produced amongst the players, etc. sending us into the basement. Players and a lot of fans felt this way all along .

Realistically and optimisticaslly , how can we move successfully forward with such bitterness shown by the players towards the job upper management has been doing since the departure of Howson ?

I think Moreau's comments are indicative of many . Just how effective might the rebuild be now is in much doubt considering the "airing of dirty laundry " coming out of bitter departing players !

Avatar
#13 SirFozz
July 01 2010, 08:35AM
Trash it!
0
trashes
+1
0
props

Yay, J-Dubs back too! What glorious days in the nation.

Avatar
#14 misfit
July 01 2010, 08:38AM
Trash it!
0
trashes
+1
0
props

I'm always amazed at how often I read the word hyperbole, but never hear people use it when they're speaking.

I often find myself wondering if it's because people have a hard time spelling exaggerate.

I pretty much feel the same was as JW on all of these issues, though I was ok with the Moreau buyout.

It's kind of funny that we traded Staios for a player who probably won't be back, but we then when on to trade for a bottom pairing defensive defenseman making pretty much the same money. It seems as though both moves kind of cancel each other out (though I guess it did save us from having to buyout O'Sullivan).

Avatar
#15 Chris.
July 01 2010, 08:54AM
Trash it!
0
trashes
+1
0
props
Ducey wrote:

I see Ethan Moreau did not go quitely into the night.

As reported in the Journal this a.m. he says that Howson built the 2006 cup team and that it wasn't a coincidence things fell apart after Howson left.

I'm sure he will find things so much more successful in Columbus

Souray and Moreau were close and often carpooled to practice and such... it seems they arrived at some sort of negative consensus opinion of management. Doesn't mean the rest of the team is on board with that train of thought.

Avatar
#16 Senator Theo
July 01 2010, 09:09AM
Trash it!
0
trashes
+1
0
props
Ducey wrote:

I see Ethan Moreau did not go quitely into the night.

As reported in the Journal this a.m. he says that Howson built the 2006 cup team and that it wasn't a coincidence things fell apart after Howson left.

I'm sure he will find things so much more successful in Columbus

Talk about a Lowe blow on your way out*

*recycled from my twitter cooments last night

Nice to have you back JW - this is a great thing for the Nation and it's readers.

Avatar
#17 Dave
July 01 2010, 09:12AM
Trash it!
0
trashes
+1
0
props

I can not understand why a team would value O'Sullivan more than Robert Nilson...

Avatar
#18 yegCopywriter
July 01 2010, 09:43AM
Trash it!
0
trashes
+1
0
props
Dave wrote:

I can not understand why a team would value O'Sullivan more than Robert Nilson...

If you are referring to Phoenix, they actually bought O'Sullivan out. It was cheaper for them to buy him out than Vandermeer.

Avatar
#19 Manfly
July 01 2010, 09:53AM
Trash it!
0
trashes
+1
0
props

seems every player that is dumped off the Oilers has a negative thing to say. guess the Oilers were right to get rid of as many of the cup run players of '06 as they can. i'm sure Moreau will lead the Jackets to the cup finals again.

Avatar
#20 Archaeologuy
July 01 2010, 10:03AM
Trash it!
0
trashes
+1
0
props

Welcome back!

Avatar
#21 freeze
July 01 2010, 10:18AM
Trash it!
0
trashes
+1
0
props

Welcome back, JW!! You've been missed around these parts.

Avatar
#22 Dan the Man
July 01 2010, 10:27AM
Trash it!
0
trashes
+1
0
props
Ducey wrote:

I see Ethan Moreau did not go quitely into the night.

As reported in the Journal this a.m. he says that Howson built the 2006 cup team and that it wasn't a coincidence things fell apart after Howson left.

I'm sure he will find things so much more successful in Columbus

Does Moreau follow the NHL? Does he know how Columbus did last year?

P.S. Welcome back Willis!!!!

Avatar
#23 Jeff
July 01 2010, 02:21PM
Trash it!
0
trashes
+1
0
props

I hate to be redundant, but it needs to be said: It's nice to have you back Jon, you've been missed.

Comments are closed for this article.