More Ales Hemsky Trade Rumours

Jonathan Willis
January 30 2012 11:14AM

The easy way to stop all the Ales Hemsky trade rumours out there would be for him to sign a contract extension. Pending free agent Tim Gleason, regarded as one of the best available defensemen at the NHL trade deadline, signed a four-year extension with Carolina earlier today, instantly putting a halt to a litany of rumours suggesting various destinations for him.

Until Hemsky signs a similar pact, or is traded, the rumours will continue.

Sportsnet’s Gene Principe, a familiar face for Oilers’ fans, got into the discussion today, tweeting the following:

Ales Hemsky-Andy Sutton to Det.for Tomas Jurco and 1st round pick. Hemsky and pick to Nash.for Jonathan Blum and 1st round pick #justrumors

It’s worth remembering that Detroit’s first round pick is probably going to fall in the 25th – 30th range, and that Nashville’s top pick isn’t likely to be a whole lot better. They’re nice pieces to have, but these proposed deals would hinge on the prospects involved.

Tomas Jurco is an interesting prospect – a 6’2” winger the Red Wings added with a second round pick last season. He’s scored 25 times in 36 QMJHL games and added 29 assists. Those are impressive totals but they come with a caveat: Jurco’s team, the Saint John Sea Dogs, are the second-most potent team in the QMJHL. On the roster are last year’s third overall pick, Jonathan Huberdeau, who is averaging a hair under two points per game. Another first rounder from last year, Zack Phillips, leads the team in scoring. 20-year old Danick Gauthier has scored 37 times. So while Jurco is scoring a lot, the question is whether he’s helping drive the bus or whether he’s a beneficiary of his teammates. In last year’s drafts, scouts ranked Huberdeau and Phillips above him.

Still, Jurco’s a very interesting prospect, and despite those cautions I think most NHL teams would love to have him in the system.

Blum’s probably a more interesting piece, however, simply because he’s closer to active duty in the NHL. He’s already played more than 50 games in the world’s best league, and has almost 150 in the AHL. In his AHL time, Blum has proven to be a potent offensive contributor –over an average 82-game segment he produces 11 goals and 35 assists.

He’s still struggling to make the NHL jump, however. His minus-14 rating this season was wholly deserved and indicative of his defensive struggles in the major leagues.  For the Oilers that may not matter – it all depends on what their goals are for next season. If the Oilers are planning on slow improvement, maybe they don’t mind letting Blum learn in a depth role, making mistakes now at the NHL level in exchange for a future payoff.

74b7cedc5d8bfbe88cf071309e98d2c3
Jonathan Willis covers hockey for the Nation Network. He also currently writes for the Edmonton Journal's Cult of Hockey, Grantland, and Hockey Prospectus. His work has appeared at theScore, ESPN and Puck Daddy. He started writing professionally in 2008 as the founder and managing editor of Copper & Blue. Contact him at jonathan (dot) willis (at) live (dot) ca; he's also on Twitter at http://twitter.com/JonathanWillis
Avatar
Reply #101 db7db7db7 January 31 2012, 12:17AM
+1 1 props

I think we need to offer whatever SJ wants (-Hall, Ebs, RNH) for Clowe. He is exactly what we need.

Avatar
Reply #102 Time Travelling Sean January 31 2012, 12:20AM
+1 0 props

To be fair Hemmer ain't getting any younger, so he should try and get as much as he can vis free agency.

Avatar
Reply #103 Devolution January 31 2012, 02:23AM
+1 1 props
db7db7db7 wrote:

I think we need to offer whatever SJ wants (-Hall, Ebs, RNH) for Clowe. He is exactly what we need.

Crazy talk.

Avatar
Reply #104 db7db7db7 January 31 2012, 02:26AM
+1 1 props
Devolution wrote:

Crazy talk.

Notice the minus sign in those brackets.

Avatar
Reply #105 tony January 31 2012, 03:01AM
+1 0 props

Sam gagner for luke schenn

Avatar
Reply #106 stevezie January 31 2012, 05:23AM
+1 1 props

Totally agree on Clowe. Defence is our biggest need, but Clowe is exactly what the forward corps lack, both in style and personality.

Avatar
Reply #108 db7db7db7 January 31 2012, 10:53AM
+1 0 props

@Jonathan Willis

Make him available. Offer more than they can refuse. Hemsky, Gagner, Belanger and Khabby should get it done.

Avatar
Reply #109 Jason January 31 2012, 12:23PM
+1 0 props
Oilcan wrote:

Tambellini: "Ok Ales lets sit down and talk business so we can get that contract signed so you stay here in Edmonton"

Hemsky: "No"

Tambellini: "Ah tough break"

And Hemsky gets traded, I think people need to realize that Tambellini has probably had many conversation with Hemsky and his agent. I will gladly take a prospect who might or might not pan out for a player we lose on July 1st anyway.

Also one that probably signs a 5 year 25 mill contract.

There's been several times where Hemsky has talked about how much he has enjoyed this city and wants to stay here and remain an Oiler.

I've yet to hear any credible media member mention that the Oilers and Hemsky are talking. (Treena's Oil has said they are, and that they're only $500,000 apart on a one-year deal, but take it for what you will).

If there is no communication, I think this falls on the Oilers. And if there is no communication, that is a huge failing on the part of the Oilers management. If Tambellini is dragging his feet, trying to evaluate until the last possible moment... that's a huge red flag for this organization.

Comments are closed for this article.