QUESTIONS FOR 12-13

Lowetide
April 15 2012 09:31AM

Last spring we had a lot of questions and the summer, fall and winter delivered answers. The Nuge WAS golden, Smyth's return was wonderful and the team improved but ended up in the same old neighbourhood. What are the questions this summer? More importantly, what are the answers?

We did this last year, asking questions and then following up here and here. Here are this year's questions:

  1. Who will they take #1 overall? Nail Yakupov. It is very interesting to see that Ryan Murray has been invited to join Team Canada's WHC entry and even if it only means some exhibition time there's still a nice chance for the Oilers' brass to observe the prospect. Still, passing on exceptional offensive talent--the best available in this draft season--would take big brass. Oilers make the safe and offensively charged pick and go with the Russian.
  2. Who will coach? Tom Renney. Lots of chatter about Brent Sutter today but I don't see him as a clearly better option and Renney has been onboard with the development process. It would be wise to put together a stronger team with a better defense and then see how far up the standings they can fly. Sutter as a co-coach ala Quinn/Renney might be viable, as the Oilers seemed to like the duo coach approach (Sather-Muckler) a few years ago.
  3. How will they improve the defense? I do believe Steve Tambellini and crew will be very aggressive. Since Bob McKenzie mentioned Edmonton as a possible landing spot for soon to be UFA Justin Schultz Oiler fans have been talking about him. That kind of strategy is brilliant because the club can add to the cluster without using assets. I also think the club will be very aggressive in pursuit of Jason Garrison and adding both to a top 4 of Ladislav Smid, Jeff Petry, Nick Schultz and Ryan Whitney would go a long way to shoring up a position of weakness.
  4. If they trade to upgrade D, who will they trade? Sam Gagner is the obvious choice to my way of thinking. Solid 2line C who scores 40-49 points every year, he's young enough to improve and is a consistent player. Edmonton should be able to cobble together a deal for a quality NHL defenseman to fit the cluster if they are shopping Gagner.
  5. Will they move Hall to center? Jason Gregor and Dennis King both mentioned this awhile back and with the lottery win I thnk it might happen. Oilers up the middle would be much stronger and it allows them to deal Gagner for that defenseman so badly needed.
  6. Do the Oilers continue the DD-NK tandem or look to improve it? This is an area of need but the Oilers appear content to stay the course. Underneath the NHL depth chart, Olivier Roy and Tyler Bunz are showing very well but their ETA is down the road. Edmonton should look at buying out the Russian's final season but it doesn't sound like that is being considered at this time.
  7. Will they make a big splash this summer? An offer sheet to Vancouver's backup goalie would be a plan but one doubts Edmonton makes the call. If they do anything earth shattering it'll be via trade.
  8. What will the top 2 lines look like in the fall? My guess is that RNH, Hall, Eberle, Yakupov, Hemsky and Ryan Smyth line up together. Gagner too if he's still here and of course Smyth isn't signed yet.
  9. How many of their own unrestricted free agents do the Oilers sign this summer? Two. Smyth, Petrell.
  10. Which current NHL player on another roster has the best chance of being an Oiler in the fall? Jason Garrison. I think they send a lot of money and term his way.

 

WHAT DOES IT ALL MEAN?

The last few years, summer has been the most exciting time to be an Oiler fan. It looks like another fun summer is on the way. Stay close to the news.

 

C2a6955161684b5e3189319acfa5ebe4
Lowetide has been one of the Oilogosphere's shining lights for over a century. You can check him out here at OilersNation and at lowetide.ca. He is also the host of Lowdown with Lowetide weekday mornings 10-noon on Team 1260.
Avatar
#1 yawto
April 15 2012, 09:37AM
Trash it!
0
trashes
Cheers
0
cheers

I just hope we see a third fist overall pick to start the season on the lineup.

Avatar
#2 Skidplate
April 15 2012, 09:49AM
Trash it!
0
trashes
Cheers
0
cheers

I don't think the Oilers can buyout Khaby, since he signed his contract after 35 years old. I may be mistaken though.

I believe their only choice is to send him to the minors or loan him to a team overseas. His cap hit would still count though.

Avatar
#3 Smokey
April 15 2012, 09:54AM
Trash it!
0
trashes
Cheers
0
cheers

Can we sign Jagr this summer.

Avatar
#4 -30-
April 15 2012, 09:55AM
Trash it!
0
trashes
Cheers
1
cheers

It makes sense to keep Khabibulin if only to have him help Nail feel at home.

Avatar
#5 Skidplate
April 15 2012, 09:55AM
Trash it!
0
trashes
Cheers
0
cheers

Is Garrison worth big money and long term? It may take that to get him, but he really has had only one big season. If he stays the same as he did this year, he may be worth it, however one must consider the division he plays in. Just imagine what Smid could do in the SE, 10 - 15 goals, 20 - 30 assists ;) http://tsn.ca/nhl/teams/players/bio/?id=6570

Avatar
#7 Skidplate
April 15 2012, 10:01AM
Trash it!
0
trashes
Cheers
0
cheers

Ah, I see. I should know better than to question you :)

Avatar
#9 Starving Student
April 15 2012, 10:02AM
Trash it!
0
trashes
Cheers
0
cheers

I pray we don't throw term at Garrison! Another journey men is not the top 4 d we should be looking for! What about Barret Jackman if he becomes available? Have 3 solid stay at home D-men and allow Whitney, Petry & whoever some more leeway to take chances offensively!

Avatar
#10 rondo
April 15 2012, 10:09AM
Trash it!
0
trashes
Cheers
0
cheers

LT,

What if Vancouver loses the series with LA and Alain Vigneault becomes available would you consider him?

Avatar
#12 rondo
April 15 2012, 10:11AM
Trash it!
0
trashes
Cheers
0
cheers

LT,

Would trading the #1 pick to Columbus for their #2 pick and their #18 pick make any sense?

Avatar
#14 Shane
April 15 2012, 10:18AM
Trash it!
0
trashes
Cheers
0
cheers

LT,

I thought consistency was something that Gagner needed to work on?

Avatar
#15 Time Travelling Sean
April 15 2012, 10:24AM
Trash it!
0
trashes
Cheers
0
cheers

Whenever I think of Bouwmeester I smirk a little, I don't want Flames fans to be able to do the same.

Avatar
#17 Shane
April 15 2012, 10:38AM
Trash it!
0
trashes
Cheers
0
cheers

@Lowetide

I should have read your On The Beach article before posting. I like Gagner too, if he could smooth out the streaks I'd like him a lot more. If we take Yakupov(I hope we do) then we may not see him traded and he'll have those wingers you were talking about

Avatar
#18 Racki
April 15 2012, 10:40AM
Trash it!
0
trashes
Cheers
0
cheers
Lowetide wrote:

He's been a pretty consistent offensive player, 40-49 points. I very much like Gagner as a player as is, would hate to see him traded.

Consistent seasonal totals... not very consistent game to game though (actually iirc, the issue he's a slow starter). I've been a Gagner fan since day one though, and think he could be that player one day. But I don't think consistency and Gagner are too synonymous right now. His game improved this year though, I thought, to a more 2-way game.

I think I've become a lot more accepting of moving Gagner as of recent, but like you too, I probably still would hate to see him go.

Avatar
#19 Oiler AL
April 15 2012, 10:42AM
Trash it!
0
trashes
Cheers
0
cheers

If you are using current roster players to make gains via a trade, I would sooner trade Fly By Hemsky than Gagner... if its a big fish we are chasing,.. trade both of them.{ and their peewee hockey sticks]. Schnieder is not coming to Edmonton . Check out his recent remarks about Edmonton, [ for which he apologized.] Something to be noted about Tambelini's rebuild here. If you are watching todays NHL playoffs, you better come on the ice with some Beef, and everyone on the team better be ready for some " Rollerball Hockey" . Its mean , though and dirty out there. Todays o Oiler line up would get eaten alive.ANOTHER REASON RENNEY IS NOT THE MAN FOR THIS TEAM. He is a passive coach, with the idea of " turning the other cheek" as the way to respond.

Avatar
#20 Lexi
April 15 2012, 10:42AM
Trash it!
0
trashes
Cheers
1
cheers

My answer to some of LT questions;

1. They take Yakupov, but I love that Murray is going to the Worlds. I've got to think seeing him play and practice with NHL players is a better way to evaluate a prospect than watching him lift weights and ride a bike. Murray definitely had the best last two months of the top 5 prospects.

2. At this point my guess would be Sutter with Krueger as co coaches.

3/4/5. I think they move Hall to C, trade Gagner for Gunnerson, trade Omark, second rd pick and D prospect not named Klefbom for Tyutin. I think Schultz goes to Tor as Burke is who drafted him.

8. Top lines: MP-RNH-Ebs. Yak-Hall-Hemsky

I'm sure they will not get Suter and if the bidding for Carle, Wideman, and Garrison goes above $5mill a yr they should bow out.

Avatar
#21 5 Cups
April 15 2012, 10:43AM
Trash it!
0
trashes
Cheers
0
cheers

I will go on record as saying I fully support getting rid of renney and bringing in either sutter or mact.

I think the oil will be a new team next year. Another high pick and a few assets (omark, prv, gags, picks) to try and get some D with. I think the oil take yak in the draft. He is projected to be far and above the best of his class and I doubt that anyone offers anything worthy of taking (and NO flamers fan boumester for the number 1 pick straight up will NOT EVER happen...pull your head out of your @ss)

should be fun to watch next year....looking forward to it......should the CBA get done.

Avatar
#22 justDOit
April 15 2012, 10:46AM
Trash it!
0
trashes
Cheers
0
cheers

@ LT:

I know the reasons behind wanting to move Hall to the middle, but do you really think he has the mentality for the position? It requires some restraint, and is much more difficult to play, positionally.

I don't see these qualities in Hall. He's a thoroughbred, born to race down the wing in a hell-bent lather, pushing the defence back and making room for his line-mates.

What about Ebs to center? I know he doesn't fulfill the size down the middle that the Oilers need, but he's only two inches shorter than Hall but plays much bigger than his stature. He thinks the game on a higher level, sees the ice better and would be more responsible defensively.

Avatar
#23 oilfan in yyc
April 15 2012, 10:50AM
Trash it!
0
trashes
Cheers
1
cheers

Re: Garrison - I thought I read a stat one time that showed point production drops off dramatically for players moving from the SE to the west

Avatar
#24 michael
April 15 2012, 10:51AM
Trash it!
0
trashes
Cheers
0
cheers

Eager and Belanger? Are they in the Oilers longterm plans. I do not see a return of either play to edmonton next season.Square pegs in a round hole sorta thing.

Petrell. Do the Oilers make room for a player with more bang.

Horichuck? Is he a player we need?

Would you sign UFA Semin for 4-5 millon and play him with Yakupov and Hemsky? Keeping in mind that you would trade Gagne and MP for a package,player or another top 10 pick in this years draft.

Is Lander ready to assume a fulltime role on the Oilers? 4th line center?

Would you rather sign Ryan Smyth or Dustin Penner? Or trade for Chris Stewart?

Would you trade Peckham this off season?Or Potter if you sign Shultz and/or Garrison.

Avatar
#25 Racki
April 15 2012, 10:54AM
Trash it!
0
trashes
Cheers
0
cheers

This coaching change talk baffles me... although I'm pretty sure it baffled all the MacT supporters when there was talk of firing him (and really, we're top pick 3 years running, so how baffling can it be, I guess). But I just think for Renney he's got a good connection with our young kids and is getting a lot out of them. Our powerplay and PK have improved drastically.

I think there are definitely issues, but I'd say to just stay the course and be patient, which I definitely understand is hard for most Oilers fans to do given what we've been through.

I also think our GM has never been of the mindset of our team being a winner in the current year for the last few years, thus why he seems to leave the team hanging to dry when the injuries happen or when skids happen. The idea seems to be "if we win without me doing anything, great, but if we don't, well we're getting a good pick and rebuilding." Tambo needs to flick the switch to win-mode before any coach will do well here, if you ask me.

Avatar
#26 michael
April 15 2012, 10:55AM
Trash it!
0
trashes
Cheers
0
cheers

oilfan in yyc that would be an interesting stat to see if one could prove it. I would like to see what the numbers look like in the 1st year and then 3 years after. To see if its a short term or a longterm statistical truism.

Avatar
#27 justDOit
April 15 2012, 11:04AM
Trash it!
0
trashes
Cheers
0
cheers
michael wrote:

oilfan in yyc that would be an interesting stat to see if one could prove it. I would like to see what the numbers look like in the 1st year and then 3 years after. To see if its a short term or a longterm statistical truism.

Bouwmeester comes to mind. His last four seasons in Florida he scored just above 40 points (avg), and his 3 seasons in Calgary he's averaging around 25 points.

I think you could also chalk that up to a more defensive mindset of the Flames vs the Panthers.

Avatar
#28 Quinn the Eskimo
April 15 2012, 11:08AM
Trash it!
0
trashes
Cheers
0
cheers

"If you are watching todays NHL playoffs, you better come on the ice with some Beef, and everyone on the team better be ready for some " Rollerball Hockey" . Its mean , though and dirty out there. Todays Oiler line up would get eaten alive." And Oiler Al brings up my big question for next year: injuries. Watching the playoffs right now you would think there were actually no rules at all regarding the safety of players. (Not sure how the NHLPA puts up with this). If we take and then play Yakupov, the core of our team is extremely young, inexperienced and vulnerable to the despicable headhunting that goes on. I'm worried. So my big question is: do we have 3 or 4 potential Sidney Crosbie situations ahead. Will our superstars survive the murderous style of play in the bigs? shouldn't they condition themselves in junior or the AHL for a year or two longer with some trial call ups throughout the year to the show? All this time wallowing in the basement only to have our first picks concussed into uselessness. And if Hall moves to centre, will he be even more vulnerable to his own mad style of play?

Avatar
#29 PutzStew
April 15 2012, 11:10AM
Trash it!
0
trashes
Cheers
0
cheers

LOL.

If "Worn Out" Smyth and "No Chemistry" Hemsky are the best buyable options for a second line this team is in big trouble next year and I'd plan for another lottery pick.

I far less worried about weakness on Defence and the Goalies then I am with the Second and Third Lines.

Gagner actually has chemistry with Hall and Eberle. If there isn't a better option the use him for now.

Harti needs to be on the top six. Why? Because he actually has elements in his game that aren't found in the top six. Size and physicality. How many high talent, lighter weight guys can you have in your top six and still win? Pick 2-3 (Eberle, RNH,Yakupov) and start phasing the other ones (Gagner, Hemsky)

Also give PRV a chance already. I want to see if he can actually play in the top six with the other guys. Don't put him with Hemsky and Gagner again. That was a fail. I want to see him with Ebs, RNH or Hall. Does he fit? Does he not? Is he going to be a third liner? Seriously...what is this kids capable of.

I do like what you are thinking for the Defence but your top six is weak.

Top six, to start the year, should be Hall, Eberle, RNH, Harti, Gagners, and PVR. Lets see what happens. It sure isn't going to be any worst then having Smyth and Hemsky there.

Avatar
#30 Dutchscooter
April 15 2012, 11:12AM
Trash it!
0
trashes
Cheers
0
cheers

@michael

You can't be serious about Semin.....how many albatross contracts do you want this team to have? At least Hemsky historically puts up numbers.

Avatar
#31 67 penny
April 15 2012, 11:15AM
Trash it!
0
trashes
Cheers
0
cheers
Lexi wrote:

My answer to some of LT questions;

1. They take Yakupov, but I love that Murray is going to the Worlds. I've got to think seeing him play and practice with NHL players is a better way to evaluate a prospect than watching him lift weights and ride a bike. Murray definitely had the best last two months of the top 5 prospects.

2. At this point my guess would be Sutter with Krueger as co coaches.

3/4/5. I think they move Hall to C, trade Gagner for Gunnerson, trade Omark, second rd pick and D prospect not named Klefbom for Tyutin. I think Schultz goes to Tor as Burke is who drafted him.

8. Top lines: MP-RNH-Ebs. Yak-Hall-Hemsky

I'm sure they will not get Suter and if the bidding for Carle, Wideman, and Garrison goes above $5mill a yr they should bow out.

There couldn't be a better time to move Hall to Centre. Don't underestimate Hall's hockey IQ. By moving to centre he would be required to develop more discretion and responsibility in his game and still have ice to wind up and make room for his wingers. I think its a brilliant move that would require a year of development and not just a few games to see what happens. When they drafted Hall I was hoping this day would come. Noe package Gagner up and get us some skilled grit (ala Malone, Clowe, Boyle). Not to mention a hard run at J. Schultz. What a summer to be an Oiler Fan!

Avatar
#32 rondo
April 15 2012, 11:17AM
Trash it!
0
trashes
Cheers
0
cheers

How about this one?

Brent Sutter becomes the coach of the Oilers he decides to trade Sam Gagner for Brandon Sutter.

Avatar
#33 Rama Lama
April 15 2012, 11:22AM
Trash it!
0
trashes
Cheers
0
cheers

LT, your second line of Yakhemsmyth looks very weak on paper and I suspect would be even weaker on the ice. If Yakapov is a Bure type player, then putting him on with Hemsky and Smyth is asking for problems.

Firstly, Hemsky has never shown any chemistry with any living player that I know of. He like to carry the puck until he loses it, and this will frustrate Yakapov to no end. Smyth can move the puck to him but has no shot .......and his foot speed will mean he won't keep up to the play.

This second line will die a natural death and never be able to produce consistently.

The only option in my eyes is to trade Hemsky and Gagner and get a natural center man with size an speed.......maybe Galenuchuyk? Moving players fom their natural positions never seems to work long term so let's stop wasting time and get a natural centre.

Avatar
#34 dw
April 15 2012, 11:23AM
Trash it!
0
trashes
Cheers
0
cheers

I haven't heard much chatter regarding the potential of Vokoun hitting the UFA market this summer. If the Oil were to buy out Khabibulin's contract wouldn't Vokoun be a viable option?

Yakupov, Garrison, Justin Schultz and Vokoun to the roster in one summer without giving up any assets. Realistic, or am I dreaming?

Avatar
#35 Tony_Clifton
April 15 2012, 11:26AM
Trash it!
0
trashes
Cheers
0
cheers

LT, i think the question of adding some size, grit, and experience is just as important. any chance the oilers offer contracts to guys like tootoo, gaustad, or doan?

Avatar
#36 stevezie
April 15 2012, 11:28AM
Trash it!
0
trashes
Cheers
0
cheers

I don't see the appeal of trading Gagner for D, then we'd be (even) weak(er) at center. I guess it's a workable plan B (along with moving Hall to C), but surely plan A is use UFAs, and trading picks, prospects and Omark to get the D we need. That's plan A, right?

I could live with trading Gagner to get a better C, that would make sense to me. Or if not better, one that suits out needs more (our forwards are small and offensive, a little variety might be nice.)

As far as the pick goes, please don't trade our dollar for quaters, even if you can get four of them. Even if you can get five! We are short on dollars. I'm not scout but Murray looks like a fifty cent piece to me, though you can never tell with defenceman. Q.E.D

Avatar
#37 stevezie
April 15 2012, 11:29AM
Trash it!
0
trashes
Cheers
0
cheers
rondo wrote:

How about this one?

Brent Sutter becomes the coach of the Oilers he decides to trade Sam Gagner for Brandon Sutter.

See, that makes perfect sense. For both teams (Jeff Marek is convinced Gagner is perfect for Staal).

Avatar
#38 Sliderule
April 15 2012, 11:35AM
Trash it!
0
trashes
Cheers
0
cheers

It was after the mid season GM meeting that you saw the refs letting everything go.Coincidence!I think not.

Now that we are into the playoffs the players having figured it out and are trying to injure players so that they are out of series or afraid for their life.Dont kid yourself about the word life because it's close to that.

It appears that the players are targeting any player that is decent whether big or small so it doesn't matter about the size.The head of a big man is just as vulnerable as a small man.

It looks like this is the way the NHL likes it so the OIL need to load up a fourth line of goons and cheap shot artists.Eager should have been OK for that but he must have thought he was signed for top nine because he never delivered.

Avatar
#39 @NateInVegas
April 15 2012, 11:40AM
Trash it!
0
trashes
Cheers
1
cheers

Nail Yakupov aka Maxim Afinogenov isn't the solution to Edmonton's problems.

He doesn't play a lick of defense, +/- doesn't tell the full story, but he's only +13 despite putting up 170 points. Scoring goals isn't the Oilers problem, keeping them out is. They've given up 239-269-284 goals the last 3 years.

Yakupov's a late birthday, small, plays the wing, doesn't hit or play defense, and he's Russian...It's simple. When Yakupov doesn't score he doesn't impact the game one bit.

How many red flags do the Oilers need?

It scares the crap out of me to think Edmonton's had 5 top 10 picks in the last 5 years and only managed to get 1 elite player(RNH)and 3 wingers...

SMH!

Avatar
#41 Rama Lama
April 15 2012, 11:51AM
Trash it!
0
trashes
Cheers
0
cheers

@Lowetide

I could think of a couple of PF's that would look good in n Oilers uniform, Lucic, .........at least guys who can skate, bang, and create space for the skilled players.

There has to be someone out there it's Tamby's job to find that player.

Avatar
#42 Oilbridge
April 15 2012, 11:59AM
Trash it!
0
trashes
Cheers
0
cheers

@Lowetide

LT, how about going after Chris Stewart? He had a tough year and it appears that Hitch has soured a bit on him. He would be great for the top 6 for the skill, grit and size. What would the oil have to give up to get him? Hemsky and a pick? Especially if the oil keeps the #1 and take Nail. You might be able to go with a top 6 of: Hartsy-RNH-Ebs Stewart-Hall-Nail. And you would package gagner for a dman. Thoughts?

Avatar
#43 Sox and Oil
April 15 2012, 12:07PM
Trash it!
0
trashes
Cheers
0
cheers

A couple things about the draft....

Edmonton places a huge value on personality and attitude, they want players who want to play and stay in town. For Nail vs Ryan edge goes to Ryan. Nail's most consistent comp (that I keep hearing) is Bure or "Ovechkin lite". Ryan's seems to be Neidermeyer. Again edge to Ryan. Finally KLowe is getting a advanced try out with Ryan and the WC.

I wouldn't be shocked if Ryan Murray pulls a Oildrop over his head in Pittsburgh.

Avatar
#44 PutzStew
April 15 2012, 12:21PM
Trash it!
0
trashes
Cheers
0
cheers
Rama Lama wrote:

LT, your second line of Yakhemsmyth looks very weak on paper and I suspect would be even weaker on the ice. If Yakapov is a Bure type player, then putting him on with Hemsky and Smyth is asking for problems.

Firstly, Hemsky has never shown any chemistry with any living player that I know of. He like to carry the puck until he loses it, and this will frustrate Yakapov to no end. Smyth can move the puck to him but has no shot .......and his foot speed will mean he won't keep up to the play.

This second line will die a natural death and never be able to produce consistently.

The only option in my eyes is to trade Hemsky and Gagner and get a natural center man with size an speed.......maybe Galenuchuyk? Moving players fom their natural positions never seems to work long term so let's stop wasting time and get a natural centre.

I have to disagree with you about Hemsky not showing Chemistry. He showed great Chemistry with Smyth and Horcoff...........6 Years Ago.

Other then that I totally agree with you.

Avatar
#45 2:00AM
April 15 2012, 12:24PM
Trash it!
0
trashes
Cheers
0
cheers

Im likin Matt Carle as a #3/4 d if he can be had at a reasonable price, he plays great in Philly. As for Justin Schultz I think he is a perfect fit. Also is there any way we can pull a Burke and get yak and Murray?

Avatar
#46 Asian on Oilers Nation
April 15 2012, 12:29PM
Trash it!
0
trashes
Cheers
0
cheers

A thought, maybe a crazy one at that...

What about moving PRV to center? (has that been suggested? I'm new here.) I have no doubt in my mind he can play - he just was not given a chance in the top 6 this year to show it. But with the need of "getting bigger down the middle" I think PRV could fit. We are still in the rebuilding process, so trying this out for half of the season wouldn't hurt. (well yes it would, if it costs us a chance to be in the playoff hunt.)

This is considering Gagner and Hemsky are both out of the mix... Highly unlikely though. But if this is the case, my top six would be: Hartikainen - RNH - Ebs, Hall - PRV - Yakupov

This way we have that combination of size and skill, and a little grit with Hartikainen. Now if only PRV can actually learn to play his size and add a little bit more grit to his game, along with everyone else, then I think we would have an excellent top 6.

Avatar
#47 Lexi
April 15 2012, 12:33PM
Trash it!
0
trashes
Cheers
0
cheers

Yesterday might have been the most compelling day of hockey watching I ever remember. It made the first round of the March Madness feel like watching golf. That said the league had better start cracking down on this level of violence or all of it's stars will not ever make it out of a playoff series healthy. My hope is they start next year with bigger suspensions at the start of the year than what they gave this year. (I'm thinking a hit like Keith's on Sedin will be 20 games next year). They better crack down of this or else the Oilers are definitely building the wrong type of team for this style.

I think this is a follow up of last year's Cup champion, being the toughest team in the league for the first time since 1975. Now the team that finally beat the 70s Flyers was one of the most skilled teams in hockey history with a dman who was the best mix of talent and toughness in the 70s named Larry Robinson. The closest player I've seen to Larry in the past 20 years, wears No. 6 for Nashville, is from Western Canada, is only 26 and is a UFA next year. Let's hope Katz's private plane works a little better this time.

Avatar
#48 OilPuck
April 15 2012, 12:37PM
Trash it!
0
trashes
Cheers
0
cheers

Everyone is talking about trading down to get murray. Why not trade for the 2nd pick as well. Tambo did it during the hall/seg year so I don't think its a long shot to happen this year. Since he offered boston an established player (hemsky) and a prospect (ebs), maybe we can throw at CLB Gagner and omark. Maybe a 2nd rounder to sweeten the deal if first proposal is denied.

Avatar
#49 Hallisimo
April 15 2012, 12:41PM
Trash it!
0
trashes
Cheers
0
cheers

How about this....

We trade Hemsky,Omark,Whitney 2nd rd pick 2012, 1st rd pick 2013 to Columbus for 1st rd pick 2012 (2nd overall) and tyutin.

You take the two russians (that way yak has a buddy who speaks the language and will be around for a few years at least together)

Hopefully the CBA agrees to an opt out clause and we can say goodbye to Horcoffs anchor.

Get one of the realistic options on the free agent market as far as defencemen go (hopefully two of Garrison, Carle, Shultz)

Not worriying about goal yet because Tambs is an idiot and doesnt get that Khabby is terrible and is refusing to do anything about it.

Lineup looks like Hall,RNH,Eberle MP,Gregorienko,Yak Smyth,Gagner,Hartakainen Eager,Lander,Jones (petrell,Belanger)

Def Tyutin,Petry Smid,Garrison Schultz,Schultz (Sutton,Potter)

1 Dubby 2 Khabby

Just throwing this out there (sorry if spelling is wrong on some names)

Avatar
#50 Rama Lama
April 15 2012, 12:42PM
Trash it!
0
trashes
Cheers
0
cheers
Asian on Oilers Nation wrote:

A thought, maybe a crazy one at that...

What about moving PRV to center? (has that been suggested? I'm new here.) I have no doubt in my mind he can play - he just was not given a chance in the top 6 this year to show it. But with the need of "getting bigger down the middle" I think PRV could fit. We are still in the rebuilding process, so trying this out for half of the season wouldn't hurt. (well yes it would, if it costs us a chance to be in the playoff hunt.)

This is considering Gagner and Hemsky are both out of the mix... Highly unlikely though. But if this is the case, my top six would be: Hartikainen - RNH - Ebs, Hall - PRV - Yakupov

This way we have that combination of size and skill, and a little grit with Hartikainen. Now if only PRV can actually learn to play his size and add a little bit more grit to his game, along with everyone else, then I think we would have an excellent top 6.

I'm not aware of any situations where moving a player from his natural position has succeeded. Perhaps Big Buff in Winnipeg but not many.

Why not just trade for this type of player? Had we traded Hemsky prior to the deadline we may have gotten a second "first rounder", and could have added a top center man.

What is required for this to happen is a real GM, and you can't draft those!

Comments are closed for this article.