WILL THE OILERS MAKE THE PLAYOFFS?

Jason Gregor
January 18 2013 02:23PM

On the eve of another lockout-shortened season, there are many questions surrounding the Edmonton Oilers. How good will Justin Schultz be in the NHL? Is Devan Dubnyk ready to be an everyday starting goalie? Can Ales Hemsky and Ryan Whitney have bounce back seasons? Who will lead the Oilers in scoring: Jordan Eberle, Taylor Hall or Ryan Nugent-Hopkins? How much of an impact will new head coach Ralph Krueger have?

All great questions, but the most important one is, will the Oilers make the playoffs for the first time in seven seasons?
Predictions can be difficult at the best of times, but in a short season there seems to be even more variables in play.

Will the Oilers capitalize on the perceived advantage of having all of their two top-line forwards in game shape? In theory they should, but with their starting goalie and only two of six defenders (I have Potter #7)in game-shape does that negate that advantage?

Thankfully we will finally see the answers unfold on the ice starting Sunday night in Vancouver.

But before we see some games, we need to look into our crystal ball and find out where the Oilers will finish.

Predictions are in interesting animal, and sometimes they seem to contradict themselves.

Earlier this week TSN submitted a list of the top-50 players in the NHL. The Oilers had three on the list, with Jordan Eberle ranked the highest at 25th. He was ranked 19th amongst forwards, so you'd think when TSN released their projections for the top-300 scoring leaders that he'd be ranked between 15-30.

There is some miscommunication going on at TSN, because Scott Cullen clearly disagrees with the rest of his TSN colleagues and had Eberle finishing 55th overall in scoring, and 54th amongst NHL forwards. 

#  PLAYER  TEAM  POS  GP  G  A  PTS  +/-  PIM  PPP
1 Evgeni Malkin  Pittsburgh  C  43 25 38 63 7 41 19
2 Sidney Crosby  Pittsburgh  C  42 21 40 61 10 26 23
3 Steven Stamkos  Tampa Bay  C  48 32 23 55 2 37 20
4 Henrik Sedin  Vancouver  C  48 11 42 53 15 27 17
5 Alex Ovechkin  Washington  LW  45 25 26 51 7 25 17
6 Joe Thornton  San Jose  C  47 12 37 49 8 23 18
7 Ilya Kovalchuk  New Jersey  LW  46 22 26 48 -7 20 15
8 Claude Giroux  Philadelphia  C  47 15 33 48 5 20 15
9 Daniel Sedin  Vancouver  LW  43 20 27 47 13 21 18
10 Martin St. Louis  Tampa Bay  LW  47 15 30 45 -2 8 17
11 Corey Perry  Anaheim  RW  47 23 21 44 -1 68 15
12 Tyler Seguin  Boston  RW  46 18 25 43 12 15 10
13 Eric Staal  Carolina  C  47 18 25 43 1 34 14
14 John Tavares  N.Y. Islanders  C  47 18 25 43 -6 20 15
15 Brad Richards  N.Y. Rangers  C  46 15 28 43 -1 13 17
16 Nicklas Backstrom  Washington  C  43 12 31 43 10 21 17
17 Phil Kessel  Toronto  RW  47 20 22 42 -8 13 12
18 Jonathan Toews  Chicago  C  41 19 23 42 12 19 12
19 Loui Eriksson  Dallas  LW  47 16 26 42 6 8 9
20 Ryan Getzlaf  Anaheim  C  44 11 31 42 -1 36 14
21 Marian Gaborik  N.Y. Rangers  RW  44 20 21 41 8 20 14
22 Jason Spezza  Ottawa  C  42 16 25 41 2 18 13
23 Pavel Datsyuk  Detroit  C  42 14 27 41 11 10 13
24 Rick Nash  N.Y. Rangers  LW  46 20 20 40 -1 25 13
25 James Neal  Pittsburgh  RW  46 20 20 40 3 44 13
26 Zach Parise  Minnesota  LW  47 19 21 40 6 18 12
27 Patrick Marleau  San Jose  LW  48 19 21 40 4 13 15
28 Henrik Zetterberg  Detroit  LW  47 14 26 40 6 25 13
29 Jarome Iginla  Calgary  RW  48 19 20 39 -3 26 13
30 Teemu Selanne  Anaheim  RW  43 16 23 39 1 21 18
31 Patrick Kane  Chicago  RW  47 14 25 39 5 18 12
32 Logan Couture  San Jose  C  45 19 19 38 4 12 13
33 Thomas Vanek  Buffalo  LW  45 18 20 38 -1 20 14
34 Jamie Benn  Dallas  C  43 16 22 38 4 31 7
35 David Krejci  Boston  C  46 12 26 38 5 16 8
36 Bobby Ryan  Anaheim  LW  47 19 18 37 4 38 8
37 Patrick Sharp  Chicago  LW  44 18 19 37 11 21 11
38 Tomas Plekanec  Montreal  C  47 15 22 37 -2 33 11
39 Mike Ribeiro  Washington  C  44 11 26 37 -1 28 11
40 Dany Heatley  Minnesota  RW  47 16 20 36 4 25 15
41 Joe Pavelski  San Jose  RW  45 15 21 36 7 16 12
42 Jason Pominville  Buffalo  RW  47 15 21 36 -1 9 12
43 Mike Richards  Los Angeles  C  46 14 22 36 4 42 12
44 Marian Hossa  Chicago  RW  41 14 22 36 9 14 11
45 Ryan Nugent-Hopkins  Edmonton  C  43 13 23 36 -2 13 16
46 Patrik Elias  New Jersey  LW  45 12 24 36 -1 11 13
47 PA Parenteau  Colorado  RW  47 11 25 36 -5 42 11
48 Matt Duchene  Colorado  C  43 15 20 35 -5 11 11
49 Gabriel Landeskog  Colorado  LW  47 15 20 35 6 33 8
50 Patrice Bergeron  Boston  C  46 12 23 35 15 14 8
51 Ray Whitney  Dallas  LW  46 12 23 35 -2 15 13
52 Erik Karlsson  Ottawa  D  46 9 26 35 -2 25 13
53 Matt Moulson  N.Y. Islanders  LW  48 19 15 34 -2 8 12
54 Milan Lucic  Boston  LW  44 16 18 34 7 67 7
55 Jordan Eberle  Edmonton  RW  44 15 19 34 -2 8 11
56 Vladimir Tarasenko  St. Louis  RW  44 15 19 34 5 14 6
57 Paul Stastny  Colorado  C  46 12 22 34 -4 26 12
58 Anze Kopitar  Los Angeles  C  37 12 22 34 7 9 12
59 Jakub Voracek  Philadelphia  RW  46 11 23 34 2 18 6
60 Alexander Semin  Carolina  LW  42 17 16 33 7 34 11
61 Alex Burrows  Vancouver  RW  46 17 16 33 14 53 3
62 Scott Hartnell  Philadelphia  LW  48 17 16 33 8 82 9
63 Taylor Hall  Edmonton  LW  43 16 17 33 -4 19 11
64 Jeff Skinner  Carolina  RW  42 15 18 33 -2 30 11
65 David Backes  St. Louis  C  47 15 18 33 11 58 9
66 Damien Brunner  Detroit  RW  44 13 20 33 5 22 7
67 Jaromir Jagr  Dallas  RW  41 12 21 33 4 25 11
68 Max Pacioretty  Montreal  LW  43 16 16 32 -1 30 6
69 Jordan Staal  Carolina  C  41 15 17 32 6 21 7
80 Evander Kane  Winnipeg  LW  43 15 16 31 2 35 5
81 Nail Yakupov  Edmonton  LW  46 15 16 31 2 20 7
122 Justin Schultz  Edmonton  D  46 9 19 28 1 9 8
142 Sam Gagner  Edmonton  C  42 10 16 26 -3 20 7
145 Ales Hemsky  Edmonton  RW  35 9 17 26 -2 15 9
164 Ryan Smyth  Edmonton  LW  46 11 13 24 -1 35 4
250 Shawn Horcoff  Edmonton  C  40 7 12 19 -8 21 6
295 Ryan Whitney  Edmonton  D  30 2 14 16 -2 19 5

It's also interesting to note that he had Eberle dropping from 16th in goals down to 45th. Cullen is evidently in the camp of those who feel Eberle won't be able to produce at a rate similar to last season. I've said before it would be a major accomplishment for Eberle to score 46 points this year, (pro-rated to equal last season), since very few players have back-to-back 76+ point seasons, but I don't expect him to fall as much as Cullen or others do. I see Eberle scoring 40-43 points if he plays the majority of games.

HAVE TO SCORE AT EV

If the Oilers want to make the playoffs they need to score more 5-on-5. The Oilers were 22nd in goals for/goals against ratio. It is no surprise that the excluding a few exceptions, LA and Florida and New Jersey, the teams who made the playoffs scored goals EV than they gave up. 

1 DETROIT 181 126 55
2 BOSTON 193 146 47
3 PITTSBURGH 190 162 28
4 VANCOUVER 160 135 25
5 ST LOUIS 137 102 25
6 PHILADELPHIA 168 149 19
7 NY RANGERS 150 132 18
8 PHOENIX 159 143 16
9 SAN JOSE 147 134 13
10 OTTAWA 166 158 8
11 NASHVILLE 158 150 8
12 BUFFALO 154 150 4
13 CHICAGO 172 170 2
14 WASHINGTON 152 150 2
15 WINNIPEG 158 160 -2
16 DALLAS 149 152 -3
17 LOS ANGELES 118 121 -3
18 MONTREAL 143 150 -7
19 NEW JERSEY 140 150 -10
20 COLORADO 138 149 -11
21 TAMPA BAY 173 186 -13
22 EDMONTON 139 153 -14
23 ANAHEIM 142 157 -15
24 CALGARY 134 151 -17
25 FLORIDA 127 144 -17
26 TORONTO 156 182 -26
27 CAROLINA 140 166 -26
28 COLUMBUS 132 166 -34
29 MINNESOTA 112 148 -36
30 NY ISLANDERS 133 179 -46

Florida is the exception based on a few blowouts, 7-0 and 8-0 losses, but also because they had a whopping 18 OTL. They only won 32 games in regulation last year, yet the made the playoffs. They weren't that good, but when you look at the best and worst teams in the league EV gives you a good indication of where teams stand, with a few exceptions of course.

OILERS PP WILL WIN THEM GAMES

It seems many people feel the Oilers PP will be carry them to the playoffs, but that is only true if they take fewer penalties and their PK improves.

I'm not sure the Oilers PP can get much better.

They had the 3rd best PP, 20.6%, and scored the 5th most PP goals with 54. Their PP was good, and likely should be in the top-7 again this year, but can they be better than 23%?

If they Oilers have as many powerplays as last season, 262, they will have 153 this year. And in order to click at 24% they'd need to score 37 PP goals. It is possible, but if they scored 31 they'd sit at 20.4%, which is almost identical to last season.

If you told Krueger right now that he could have a 20% PP he'd take it in a heartbeat. Last season only 3 teams cracked the 20% mark with the man advantage.

As good as their powerplay was last year, it was basically negated by their penalty kill.

The Oilers were shorthanded 296 times last year, good for 5th most in the NHL. And it's not like the Oilers were an aggressive team, they took too many obstruction and sticking penalties.

The Oilers surrendered 52 goals when down a man last year, so essentially they needed a 20.6% PP just to be +2 on special teams. The Oilers were 14th in PK efficiency at 82.4%, but when you take that many penalties it impacts your ability to win the special teams battle.

The Oilers have a lot of areas to improve on, but if they improve their EV play they will have an excellent shot at making the playoffs.

NATION WRITERS CHIME IN...

I asked fellow Nation contributors, Brownlee, Wayne, Lowetide, Willis and Strudwick to close their eyes and pick give me their informed opinions on who makes it in the western conference, who plays in the Cup final and a brief explanation of why they slotted the Oilers where they did.

BROWNLEE

1. St. Louis

2. Vancouver

3. Los Angeles

4. Chicago

5. San Jose

6. Minnesota

7. Nashville

8. Edmonton

9. Detroit

10. Dallas

11. Colorado

12. Phoenix

13. Calgary

14. Anaheim

15. Columbus

A lot of people think picking the Oilers to make the playoffs is taking a big flyer.

It is, but when I look at Edmonton's top-six forwards and the defense with a full year of Nick Schultz and the additions of Justin Schultz and Mark Fistric, I see a playoff team IF -- isn't there always at least one? -- Devan Dubnyk doesn't implode as the clear-cut No. 1 goaltender and IF Ryan Whitney stays healthy.

Rangers down the Hawks and sip from the Stanley Cup.

WANYE

1. Los Angeles
2. St. Louis
3. Vancouver
4. Minnesota
5. Chicago
6. San Jose
7. Edmonton
8. Detroit
9. Nashville
10. Phoenix
11. Anaheim
12. Colorado
13. Dallas
14. Calgary
15. Columbus

"The Edmonton Oilers are my favourite hockey team and I think they are great and will make the playoffs and I love recess." - Wanye, Age 8

There is only one option for the Cup...Oilers crush Sidney and the Penguins.

LOWETIDE

1.      1. LAK: Continuation of last season, too much talent, very balanced.

2.      2. VAN: Despite the injuries, strong club with depth on defense and quality goaltending.

3.      3. STL: Remind me of LAK of one year ago.

4.      4. CHI: Possibly the strongest line-up in the conference, goaltending puts them here

5.      5. NAS: Amazing hockey club, seem to have a plug and play for every need.

6.      6. PHX: Lots of turnover but similar to Nashville in that they’ll get it done.

7.      7. MIN: Off-season dream additions and young talent carry the day.

8.       8. EDM: There’s just too much offense to keep them from making the second season, and Dubnyk is better than many believe.

9.      9. DET: Retirements and defections heavily outweigh additions.

10.  10. SJS: This is the year they begin to fade.

11.  11. DAL: Some nice things, but a bizarre off-season leaves them outside the playoffs.

12.  12. COL : Strong young team has enough holes and will struggle.

13.  13. ANA: A team in transition.

14.  14. CAL : The bottom falls out.

15.  15. CBJ: Defense and goaltending remain a mess.

Cup finalists will be Vancouver and the Rangers, with Vancouver winning their 1st Stanley. I know. I’m already mad at myself.

WILLIS

1. Los Angeles

2. Vancouver

3. St. Louis

4. Chicago

5. San Jose

6. Detroit

7. Phoenix

8. Colorado

9. Minnesota

10. Edmonton

11. Dallas

12. Nashville

13. Anaheim

14. Calgary

15. Columbus

On Edmonton: For the first time in a long time I see them as a legitimate playoff contender. I think one team besides Vancouver will make the post-season, and Colorado/Minnesota/Edmonton are all neck-and-neck-and-neck at this point. An injury or an unexpected absence - such as Ryan O'Reilly staying in the KHL - could change the balance of power, as could a sharp move by any of the general managers in charge of those clubs. I see the Oilers falling just short but staying in the mix until the bitter end.

Stanley Cup Finals: Pittsburgh over Vancouver.

STRUDWICK

1. St. Louis

2. Minnesota

3. Los Angeles

4. Chicago

5. San Jose

6. Vancouver

7. Detroit

8. Phoenix

9. Nashville

10. Dallas

11. Edmonton

12. Calgary

13. Anaheim

14. Colorado

15. Columbus

The Oilers will improve in the standings, but there are still questions they need to answer before they become a playoff team. 

1. Can the team stay healthy?

2. Can their goaltending become playoff calibre?

3. Are they a hard enough team to play against?

Rangers beat the Kings and win the Cup.

GREGOR

1. St. Louis

2. Los Angeles

3. Minnesota

4. Chicago

5. San Jose

6. Edmonton

7. Vancouver

8. Anaheim

9. Detroit

10. Dallas

11. Columbus

12. Nashville

13. Phoenix

14. Colorado

15. Calgary

My brain says the Oilers won't make the playoffs, I say they actually finish 13th because they aren't that good, but the Nation has never experienced a playoff run and the Oilers luck has to change eventually. Injuries are my main concern, because the Oilers aren't a big team. Many of their skilled players like Hall, Hemsky and Yakupov will get hit often since they don't play on the perimeter.

The Oilers have a mixture of young, hungry players and some veterans in Hemsky, Whitney, Dubnyk and Whitney with lots to prove. Krueger says they won't play a passive game, and the Oilers will be better defensively, but my biggest concern is that this team isn't tough enough. They don't know how to compete hard enough every night, yet. I'm not talking fighting or hitting, because they don't have many bangers, but just being battled tested. If they can learn that this year, I think they have the skill to make a serious run for the playoffs, but I don't expect them to. However, since you had to endure no hockey for four months, I'm going positive and picking them to make the playoffs.

But if the Oilers don't improve, I don't see any reason why GM Steve Tambellini keeps his job. They don't have to make the playoffs, but they need to show significant improvement. If they don't, then ownership has to look at the architect of the team, Tambellini.

I haven't picked them to make the playoffs in six years, so it's time for a change. And speaking of change the Detroit Red Wings won't enjoy life without Nick Lidstrom.

The Rangers defeat the Blues in six to win the Cup.

WHAT SAY YE...

What do you think Nation? Let's see who ends up with the closest prediction on April 27th.

PAY ATTENTION

Bianca Beauchamps just adds to the Positive Friday vibe. At around 12:00 this morning we will unveil the Nation's 2013 hockey draft. First place will win a $5,000 shopping spree. It costs only $20 bucks to enter and a portion of the proceeds will go to charity, because it's the right thing to do. We will have over 100 prizes. It will be awesome.

Do you want to go to the Home Opener on Tuesday?

If you LIKE the Jason Gregor Show fan page you can win. It is the easiest way to track people down. If you don't want to that is fine, just don't complain that I should give tickets away on here. It's a hassle tracking down people. On facebook I can direct message the person right away. It is simple.

I'll give away tickets to the home opener on Monday. Good luck.

RECENTLY BY JASON GREGOR

Ddf3e2ba09069c465299f3c416e43eae
One of Canada's most versatile sports personalities. Jason hosts The Jason Gregor Show, weekdays from 2 to 6 p.m., on TSN 1260, and he writes a column every Monday in the Edmonton Journal. You can follow him on Twitter at twitter.com/JasonGregor
Avatar
#101 Clyde Frog
January 19 2013, 10:34PM
Trash it!
0
trashes
Cheers
0
cheers

OOOOH, Vancouver rocked tonight with the Oiler's sloppy seconds!

I so had to eat my words...

Oh wait I read the score backwards...

Lol can't wait DSF's homerist spin on that one :)

Comments are closed for this article.