HISTORY OF TRADING #1 OVERALL PICKS

Jason Gregor
October 21 2013 12:01PM

I still believe that sometime in the future, not right away, but within two years, the Oilers should deal one of their four young offensive stars. Many don't like the idea, which I understand, but I was perplexed why some felt that suggesting the Oilers will deal one of them meant I felt the players weren't any good.

That isn't the case. The reason I would trade one of them, likely Nail Yakupov, is because he is damn good, and if the deal were done properly the Oilers would be able to fill a few other key holes on the team.

Again, I'm not suggesting it will happen right away, but if it does, I believe it would be the right move. Let me explain.

The Oilers currently have too many similar forwards. Young, skilled, not overly aggressive and none who are defensively sound, at least not yet. I'm certain that Ryan Nugent-Hopkins will become an excellent two-way player, and likely so too with Jordan Eberle. I doubt Taylor Hall or Nail Yakupov will ever be in the running for the Selke trophy, but that isn't a bad thing.

The league has many great players who will never be Selke candidates. Patrick Kane is never going to be one, and that is why he and Jonathan Toews complement one another so well. Kane is the cold-blooded sniper, while Toews is an offensive threat with a great defensive conscience.

I'm sure Hall and Nugent-Hopkins could fill those roles nicely as they mature.

Great teams have skill guys who can beat you in different ways. Chicago's top-four forwards are a mixture of pure offensive skill, Kane, solid two-way players in Toews and Patrick Sharp, while Hossa has elite skill, and he's a heavy forward. Hossa is extremely hard to knock off the puck, and he's one of the best skaters in the game.

The Bruins top-six is a combination of skill, size, nastiness and a solid two-way game. They don't have any elite scorers. Last year Brad Marchand led them in goals, 18, and points, 36. When they won the Cup in 2011, Milan Lucic and David Krejci tied for the team lead with 62 points. But they had incredible balance in their top-six and down the lineup.

Krejci and Patrice Bergeron are solid two-way players. Lucic and Marchand can score, hit and fight. Tyler Seguin had 67 points his 2nd season, while Nathan Horton had skill and size. They dealt Seguin, but added Loui Eriksson and Jarome Iginla.

The Detroit Red Wings went to back-to-back Stanley Cup finals with two great offensive players in Pavel Datsyuk and Henrik Zetterberg. They were surrounded by solid complementary players in Johan Franzen, Tomas Holmstrom, Jiri Hudler, Dan Cleary or Mikael Samuelsson. Again, we saw a combination of great skill and two-way play, size, grit and experience.

All of those teams were built a bit differently, but the one thing they shared in common was their top-two lines had players who contained different size and skill sets; they all weren't pure offensive stars.

The other main ingredient those teams possessed was they had an elite defenceman; Zdeno Chara, Nick Lidstrom and Duncan Keith. On top of finding more balance amongst their top-six the Oilers need to find a true top-pairing D-man.

That is the main reason why I would consider moving one of the skilled wingers. I believe they are attractive enough to garner a solid return.

MOVING # OVERALL PICKS

Teams have traded first overall picks before. I'm sure the St. Louis Blues wish they would have drafted Jordan Staal or Jonathan Toews instead of Erik Johnson first overall in 2006, but they didn't.

They did, however, make a very good trade when they dealt him, Jay McClement and a first round pick (11th overall, Duncan Siemens) to Colorado for Kevin Shattenkirk, Chris Stewart and conditional 2nd round pick (Ty Rattie).

I think it is safe to say the Blues clearly won that trade. One of the main reasons they were able to deal Johnson was because they drafted Alex Pietrangelo in 2008. They had a legit #1 D-man, and while they knew Johnson wasn't going to be a #1 D-man, Colorado clearly felt they could mold him into one.

That is the advantage of dealing a #1 overall pick. He has value. Most opposing teams consider him as a first overall selection.

The only other #1 pick to be traded in the salary cap era was Joe Thornton.

Thornton was dealt to San Jose at the quarter point of his 8th season in Boston. Mike O'Connell was the GM at the time and made a horrible trade. He didn't allow teams to get into a bidding war for the 26-year-old Thornton. Instead he moved him to the San Jose Sharks for Brad Stuart, Marco Sturm and Wayne Primeau.

It was a brutal deal for the Bruins. Thornton went on to win the Hart Trophy that year, while O'Connell was fired later that season on March 25th, 2006. I'm sure Oilers fans remember that 16 days before being fired O'Connell sent the 8th overall pick from Thornton's 1997 draft class, Sergei Samsonov, to Edmonton for Marty Reasoner, Yan Stastny and a 2nd round pick. O'Connell wasn't around that summer when the Bruins took Lucic 50th overall.

The Bruins were a team in transition when they dealt Thornton. They had finished 2nd in the east in 2004, but they lost in seven games in the first round. Thornton didn't have one point in seven games.

Then the lockout came, and when the NHL returned the Bruins lost Michael Nylander, Brian Rolston, Mike Knuble, Sean O'Donnell and Sergei Gonchar to free agency. The Bruins were ten points out of the playoffs on November 30th, 2005 so O'Connell decided to move Thornton. I have no idea why he accepted such a minimal return, but it cost him his job, but then Peter Chiarelli was hired and the Bruins built their team around free agent defenceman Zdeno Chara.

MacTavish must ensure that if he contemplates moving Yakupov, me has to contact every other GM in the league, something O'Connell failed to do.

COMPARISONS

The other only team in NHL history who had three consecutive first overall selections was the Quebec Nordiques, and strangely enough, the Nordiques/Avalanc;e traded all three players within five years of drafting them.

The Nordiques used the first pick to select Mats Sundin in 1989, Owen Nolan in 1990 and Eric Lindros in 1991.

LINDROS TRADE

Lindros never played a game in Quebec. He held out for a year before he was traded to Philadelphia on June 30th, 1992.

The Nordiques received: Peter Forsberg (6th pick in 1991), Mike Ricci (he had been drafted 4th overall 14 days before the trade), Steve Duchene, Ron Hextall, Kerry Huffman, Chris Simon, two additional first round picks and $15 million in cash.  Of course this type of deal would never happen today due to the salary cap, and the fact you can't trade cash only cap space, but it was a good deal for both teams.

The Flyers gained a dominant player, but the Nordiques got one hell of a return.

Forsberg became a superstar; Ricci was a solid contributor, 17 points in 22 games during the 1996 Stanley Cup run while Chris Simon was a role player in their Cup victory. The rest of the players were traded away for other assets.

SUNDIN TRADE

At the 1994 NHL draft the Nordiques and Maple Leafs made a major trade. After playing four seasons with the Nordiques, Sundin was dealt to the Maple Leafs along with Garth Butcher, Todd Warriner and the 10th overall pick (Nolan Baumgartner) in exchange for Wendel Clark Clark (1st overall pick in 1985), Sylvain Lefebvre, Landon Wilson and the 22nd pick (Jeff Kealty).

The Leafs clearly won this trade. Sundin went on to a Hall of Fame career with the Leafs.

Lefebvre was a steady #4 D-man for the Avs, and he was an alternate captain, but he was not close to Sundin in talent. He played 48 games in Quebec due to the lockout shortened 1994/1995 season, and then won a Cup in Colorado the next season.

Clark played the 1994/1995 season with the Nordiques, but then he got into a contract dispute with the Avalanche, and was dealt to the Islanders as part of a three-way deal. Clark went to NYI, Steve Thomas went to New Jersey and Claude Lemieux went to Colorado.

While they didn't come close to winning the Sundin trade, at least the Avs salvaged some dignity by acquiring Lemieux for Clark.

The Nordiques traded Sundin because they wanted to make room for Peter Forsberg. Forsberg made his debut in the 1994/1995 season and picked up 50 points in 47 games. The Nordiques had Joe Sakic, Sundin and Ricci, and they felt they couldn't use all of them down the middle when Forsberg arrived, so they moved Sundin.

They gave up the best player in the deal, but they had the luxury of slotting in Forsberg to replace him.

NOLAN TRADE

Nolan was traded nine games into the 1995/1996 season. He was dealt to the San Jose Sharks for Sandis Ozolinsh.

After the trade the Avalanche still had Sakic, Forsberg, Ricci, Lemieux, Valeri Kamensky, Scott Young, Adam Deadmarsh, Andrei Kovalenko and Martin Rucinsky in their top-nine, but the most offensive oriented D-man they had prior to acquiring Ozolinsh was Craig Wolanin.

Ozolinsh gave them an elite puck moving D-man, while the Sharks got a 30-goal scorer.

I'd give the Avs the edge in this deal. They filled a major hole on their blueline, and Ozolinsh gave them a different element in their offensive attack. He could get the puck up to their elite offensive players quickly.

Avalanche GM Pierre Lacroix wasn't afraid to make moves. His best deal came two months after the Ozolinsh/Nolan deal, when he acquired Patrick Roy and Mike Keane for Kovalenko, Rucinsky and Jocelyn Thibault.

Canadiens GM Rejean Houle was on the job for six weeks before Lacroix fleeced him in the Roy deal.

It should be noted the Avalanche's payroll was the 11th highest in 1996, and it wasn't until after the Avs won that they started spending like crazy. Lacroix had the luxury of a rich owner to keep the team together, but he should get credit for making some very good trades to build a Stanley Cup winning team in 1996.

OTHER TRADES INVOLVING #1 PICKS...

In the last 30 years, many first overall picks have been traded, and surprisingly most of those that were dealt, were traded before completing their 5th NHL season. Players like Dale Hawerchuk, Wendel Clark, Joe Thornton, Ilya Kovalchuk and Rick Nash were dealt after playing 7-9 years with their teams.

Here are the #1 picks who were traded before the end of their 5th NHL season.

1980: Doug Wichenheiser. He'll always been known as the player the Canadiens drafted instead of picking Denis Savard. The Habs is that they weren't the only team to bypass Savard. The Winnipeg Jets selected Dave Babych 2nd overall, before the Blackhawks happily took Savard.

Midway through his 4th season with the Habs Wickenheiser along with Gilbert Delhorme and Greg Paslawski were traded to the St.Louis Blues for Perry Turnbull. Wickenheiser scored 23 goals in 68 games with the Blues that year, but he never scored more than 13 after that. Turnbull was a major bust for the Habs. He scored 13 points in 40 games before they traded him to Winnipeg for Lucien Deblois after the 1983 season.

1986: Joe Murphy. Murphy spent his first two seasons splitting time between the Detroit Red Wings and their AHL affiliate. Nine games into his 3rd NHL season Murphy was dealt to the Edmonton Oilers along with Adam Graves, Petr Klima and Jeff Sharples for Jimmy Carson, Kevin McClelland and a 5th round pick.

Carson was the 2nd pick in 1986, and had scored 55 and 49 goals prior to the trade, but the Oilers easily won the deal. Murphy, Graves and Klima were key contributors to the Oilers 1990 Stanley Cup victory, while Sharples was traded to New Jersey later that year for Reijo Ruotsalainen, who scored 13 points in 22 playoff games in 1990.

1987: Pierre Turgeon. On October 25th, 1991 Turgeon was eight games into his 5th NHL season when the Sabres traded him along with Uwe Krupp, Benoit Hogue and Dave McLlwain to the New York Islanders for Pat LaFontaine, Randy Wood, Randy Hillier and a 4th round pick.

At the time of the trade Turgeon had 323 points in 322 games. He finished his career with 1327 points in 1294 games. He had four solid seasons in NYI before he was moved to Montreal. Lafontaine had two incredible seasons in Buffalo. He scored 93 points in 57 games in 1991/92 and then had a ridiculous 148 points in 84 games the following season. He was plagued by concussion issues the next two seasons before rebounding with 91 points in 76 games in 1995/1996. The Sabres and Islander didn't improve much as a team due to the trade.

1989-1991: Sundin, Lindros and Nolan deals were outlined above.

1992: Roman Hamrlik. On December 30th, 1997 in the middle of this 5th NHL season, Hamrlik was deal to the Edmonton Oilers for Steve Kelly, Jason Bonsignore and Bryan Marchment. Oilers fans are well aware that Bonsignore (4th overall in 1994) and Kelly (6th overall in 1995) turned out to be busts. Marchment played 22 games in Tampa before he was moved to San Jose for Andrei Nazarov.

Hamrlik was a top-pairing D-man in Edmonton for three years before he was dealt to the Islanders for Eric Brewer, Josh Green and Brad Winchester.

1993: Alexandre Daigle. After 4 1/2 seasons in Ottawa Daigle was dealt to Philadelphia for Pat Falloon (2nd overall pick in 1991) and Vinny Prospal. Prospal was a 3rd round pick in 1993, but he ended up being the best player in the deal playing over 1108 games. He is currently a UFA, but teams have expressed interest in signing him.

Daigle played 616 games, but never lived up to his draft position.  Falloon played 575 games.

1994: Ed Jovanovski. Jovanovski made his NHL debut in 1995 and played 3 1/2 years in Florida before being moved to Vancouver with Dave Gagner, Kevin Weekes, Mike Brown and a 1st round pick for Pavel Bure, Brad Ference, Bret Hedican and a 3rd round pick.

Bure was clearly the best player in the deal, and he scored 58 and 69 goals his first two full seasons in Florida. If he doesn't get injured, the deal would have been even more lopsided. Jovanovski played 6 1/2 years with the Canucks before signing a huge free agent deal with Phoenix.

1995: Bryan Berard. Berard told the Senators he wouldn't report and he was traded six months later, before playing a game in the NHL. The Senators dealt Berard, Don Beaupre and Martin Straka to the Islanders for Wade Redden and Damien Rhodes.

Berard won the Calder trophy in 1997, but he was traded after only 2 1/2 season on Long Island to the Leafs for Felix Potvin. Fourteen months later Berard suffered a horrible eye injury when he was hit by Marian Hossa's stick.

Redden played 11 solid seasons in Ottawa before signing a huge UFA deal with the Rangers.

2006: Erik Johnson. Outlined above.

WHAT DOES IT MEAN?

 Would there be a risk in moving Yakupov? You bet, a significant one, but there is also the possibility of a significant return.

The Nordiques made great trades involving Lindros and Nolan.

St.Louis has benefitted nicely from dealing Johnson to Colorado.

Ottawa won the Daigle and Berard deals.

I'd say the Sabres won the Turgeon/LaFontaine deal. Despite being injured, Lafontaine scored 385 points in 268 games over six seasons in Buffalo. Turgeon had 195 points in 255 games with NYI, before he was dealt to Montreal.

On the other hand....

Quebec clearly lost the Sundin deal, it wasn't close. At least the Avs managed to make a solid secondary move acquiring Lemieux for Clark.

Detroit lost the Joe Murphy trade, and so did Tampa Bay moving Hamrlik. Both times the Oilers were the beneficiary.

Middle ground...

The Wickenheiser deal had no impact for either team.

Florida won the Bure deal right away, but his injuries evened it out for the Canucks.

PARTING SHOTS...

  • Taylor Hall will have an MRI today. The last thing the Oilers need is bad news regarding Hall's knee. For his sake and the team's you hope he's only out a few weeks.
     
  • Tyler Pitlick has been recalled and he could make his NHL debut tomorrow if Ryan Smyth or Jordan Eberle are unable to play. Both Smyth and Eberle are day-to-day according to Eakins.
     
  • Is this the cure for the Oilers injury woes? Maybe not. It depends what you believe in.
     
  • Make sure you take the time and go vote today. Good luck to all of those with a name on the ballot.  

RECENTLY BY JASON GREGOR 

Ddf3e2ba09069c465299f3c416e43eae
One of Canada's most versatile sports personalities. Jason hosts The Jason Gregor Show, weekdays from 2 to 6 p.m., on TSN 1260, and he writes a column every Monday in the Edmonton Journal. You can follow him on Twitter at twitter.com/JasonGregor
Avatar
#51 Mikey
October 21 2013, 02:04PM
Trash it!
0
trashes
Cheers
3
cheers
K_Mart wrote:

Good research, good article, and good points.

With the injuries this team seems to always suffer, I'd have to disagree, and say that we need the depth, and believe we can get the versatility in player types through either drafting or FA's.

Trading Yak or Ebs isn't completely off the table, but if a solidified #1 d man under the age of 30, with term, isn't coming back, than I would never support the trade.

One of the following d men would HAVE to be coming our way, some are too old, some too good, but when I look at these names I just can't think of a possible trade that could occur that would result in being a reasonable trade for both sides...

PK Subban, Kristopher Letang, Ryan Suter, Cody Franson, Dustin Byfuglien, Niklas Kronwall, Shea Weber, Dion Phaneuf, Keith Yandle, Brian Campbell, Mike Green, Duncan Keith, Alex Pietrangelo, Oliver Ekman-Larsson, Vyacheslav Voynov, Jay Bouwmeester, Alexander Edler, Kevin Shattenkirk, Drew Doughty, Brent Seabrook, Fedor Tyutin, Zdeno Chara, Jack Johnson, Tobias Enström, Erik Karlsson , Kimmo Timonen, Dion Phaneuf,

Some of your names are sketchy. Kimmo Timonen? For Yak? Dion Phaneuf? No thanks.

Avatar
#52 SLURVE
October 21 2013, 03:22PM
Trash it!
0
trashes
Cheers
3
cheers

Lets not get too reactionary here. We are less than 10 games into the season with a new coach and system, lets not pull a New York Islander type of move. Jason, when you stated space clearing in one of your article, I did not know it involved trading first overall picks, can't they build a bigger dressing room instead?

Avatar
#53 Spydyr
October 21 2013, 04:24PM
Trash it!
1
trashes
Cheers
3
cheers

Seems as though someone is trying to poach may handle.Sadly they can not spell it right.

Can't fight stupid.

Avatar
#54 Mac962
October 21 2013, 05:18PM
Trash it!
10
trashes
Cheers
3
cheers
Smokey wrote:

I don't understand why we are talking bout trading Yak when we don't know details about Hall. Frankly with Hall possibly out for awhile why don't we see what force feeding time to see what he will bring. We watched Taylor Hall turn over pucks for 3 years and be defensively irresponsible, lets see what we got in this young Russian.

There's room for Yak.

When you have the puck most of the time it is quite obvious you may have more turnovers than others who rarely posses it. Thus Mr Yak. i dont see him with the puck that often. If you dont make mistakes, you are not trying. Right Nail ? Not saying you are not trying but to me you are beginning to show signs of ....i want the big bucks and see you later. I would take Hall on one leg and all heart before you with mediocre heart and a open wallet. Too early to pass judgement on you, this is just my gut feel. I would vote you off the island as soon as you show some of that highly touted skill and heart. Have you watched Sean Monahan Nail ? You can have all the personality you want, produce, drive, skate , hit, both ends of the ice. Just Sayin... Right Igor ?

Avatar
#55 The Real SpYDR
October 21 2013, 06:03PM
Trash it!
3
trashes
Cheers
3
cheers
Spydyr wrote:

You might not mind an intellectual half wit posing as you that's cool

I don't appreciate one posing as me.Just letting the regulars here know whats up.

Huh!

Avatar
#56 Spydyr
October 21 2013, 06:12PM
Trash it!
6
trashes
Cheers
3
cheers
DonDon wrote:

Injuries, injuries, injuries, when will they end?

Even though the Oilers beat the Senators in Ottawa, we witnessed what a big, tough team can inflict on the smaller Oilers. Following the game, Hall and now Smyth out with injuries.

The team hasn't faced other teams with big and tough players, e.g., San Jose, Los Angeles, Anaheim, St. Louis, Chicago, Even Winnipeg and Calgary are bigger and tougher than the Oil. All in the Western Conference. Ouch!

When will the brass learn skill combined with size and toughness will almost always beat skill?

Especially now that Calgary called up 6'7 D Enforcer Chris Breen! Hartley loves toughness Oilers love midgets!u

Avatar
#57 Shredder
October 21 2013, 06:17PM
Trash it!
3
trashes
Cheers
3
cheers

I suggest everyone on the team is tradeable including hall. I used to be his biggest supporter but he's not learning quick enough how to orotect himself. If I were going to keep any 2 of the players it'd be nuge and eberle...they are at least smart about being of lesser size and have shown how to use their heads to win battles. Hall would be great on a team with a strict structure to teach him how to play the game properly. Yak too. Just get value in return. Better than the thornton trade but 3 for 1 sounds right.

Avatar
#58 Citizen David
October 21 2013, 06:29PM
Trash it!
2
trashes
Cheers
3
cheers

And what would trading Yak do to our Russian pipeline?

This trade if indeed it happens needs to be years away. Still don't know what we have in those players or in our prospects like Nurse, Kharia, Klefbom, Marincin, Chase, Roy, Moroz etc.

Avatar
#59 Butters
October 21 2013, 08:06PM
Trash it!
0
trashes
Cheers
3
cheers

Did I miss the point? I see no compelling evidence to suggest trading a number one is a good idea. The best example was the Lindros trade and Quebec was forced to do that one.

Also, what is the template for having the right mix of players to win the cup? It seems to change every year.

Avatar
#60 Oilcruzer
October 21 2013, 09:37PM
Trash it!
3
trashes
Cheers
3
cheers
Next up, is Connor McJesus. wrote:

The Oil don't even have cap room for players such as this. They're so mismanaged their only option is to plug in AHL'ers all over the bottom 6 roster spots. This Kevin Lowe inspired Infinibuild has started to take hold.

#keepinitreal

You DO realize he has 6 rings that justify his every move, don't you?

Avatar
#61 Shaun Doe
October 21 2013, 09:49PM
Trash it!
1
trashes
Cheers
3
cheers

@Anonymous

You mean like soul crushingly big like the Gretzky trade? We can only hope!

Avatar
#62 Winger
October 21 2013, 10:02PM
Trash it!
10
trashes
Cheers
3
cheers

CMON MAC T. You just traded one of our only guys who competes hard,.,,.Skates...hits...fights!!! You forgot the Golden Rules of Enforcers:

1.NEVER TRADE AN ENFORCER,

2. NEVER FORGET RULE #1.

You better be bringing in a BEAST!!!

Avatar
#63 Mo Playoffs Mo Problems
October 21 2013, 12:33PM
Trash it!
9
trashes
Cheers
2
cheers

@ Jason Gregor

Great article. I agree that Yakupov likely has very high trade value based on elite scoring potential and time remaining on his ELC.

If flipping Yak into a young, established, gritty winger/d-man brings some balance to the team, then I think everyone in Oilers Nation would learn to love the trade.

My question is: if management's seriously considering dealing Yakupov, how does that affect contract talks with Hemsky? My feeling going into the season is that Hemsky would be moved for something before the deadline. Do you think they'd prefer to hang on to him if they send Yak out? I'd hate to see Ales walk as a free agent AND have Yak moved out of town.

Avatar
#64 K_Mart
October 21 2013, 12:34PM
Trash it!
8
trashes
Cheers
2
cheers

Good research, good article, and good points.

With the injuries this team seems to always suffer, I'd have to disagree, and say that we need the depth, and believe we can get the versatility in player types through either drafting or FA's.

Trading Yak or Ebs isn't completely off the table, but if a solidified #1 d man under the age of 30, with term, isn't coming back, than I would never support the trade.

One of the following d men would HAVE to be coming our way, some are too old, some too good, but when I look at these names I just can't think of a possible trade that could occur that would result in being a reasonable trade for both sides...

PK Subban, Kristopher Letang, Ryan Suter, Cody Franson, Dustin Byfuglien, Niklas Kronwall, Shea Weber, Dion Phaneuf, Keith Yandle, Brian Campbell, Mike Green, Duncan Keith, Alex Pietrangelo, Oliver Ekman-Larsson, Vyacheslav Voynov, Jay Bouwmeester, Alexander Edler, Kevin Shattenkirk, Drew Doughty, Brent Seabrook, Fedor Tyutin, Zdeno Chara, Jack Johnson, Tobias Enström, Erik Karlsson , Kimmo Timonen, Dion Phaneuf,

Avatar
#65 Will
October 21 2013, 12:37PM
Trash it!
5
trashes
Cheers
2
cheers

As long as the trade makes the team better, there's no reason any player shouldn't be traded. If we lost Yak for an elite goalie and a legit top two (maybe not a stud D man like Chara, Subban, or Weber but a legit top two), then I'd be okay with that. The problem is that our legit top two guy is already kind of on the way in Nurse. I look at our prospect pool this year and at every position but goalie, there are some very good players, and all types no less from the coke machine that can play with skill, to the big centerman that mucks it up, to the D man that can do it all. Before I ever traded Yak, I would look at what a combination of some of our prospects and draft picks might net instead.

Avatar
#66 Paq Twinn
October 21 2013, 12:41PM
Trash it!
8
trashes
Cheers
2
cheers

So the big thing I got from this was we traded a yet to be drafted Lucic with Reasoner and Y.Stastny for Samsonov. That hurts, what with Samsonov falling off the face of the earth following that Cup run, along with everything and everyone else.

Avatar
#68 Anonymous
October 21 2013, 01:45PM
Trash it!
11
trashes
Cheers
2
cheers
OilCanFan wrote:

I don't know why Nashville would trade either of those players, I'd think they're going to be there for a while. It seems right now that they are one of the few teams in a position with 2 pretty darn good defenders, but like the poster @pkam says, I'm not sure they'd make that trade.

I also don't know why Edmonton would trade Yakupov, I can't see any realistic trades that would benefit them.

What players are legitimate #1 defenders that would be considered for a trade by their current team?

Weber would love to play for the Oilers....ask him yourself ... so would Tootoo in Detroit..... fucntional toughness could be on the way soon...very soon .... don't tell Wonger...ssshhhh.....!!!!!!!!!

Avatar
#69 oilabroad
October 21 2013, 02:04PM
Trash it!
9
trashes
Cheers
2
cheers

I dont understand all the yak love here, it is apparent we have so many holes to fill on this roster, trading a one dimensional scorer seems like a no brainer with all the talent we already have... I bet Phoenix would do Samuelson plus for Yak, it would be a trade that fills a need for both teams

Avatar
#70 Wonger
October 21 2013, 02:36PM
Trash it!
8
trashes
Cheers
2
cheers
Spydr wrote:

Oil should hire Wonger for Director of Enforcer and Functional Toughness Personel!

I would work for the Oil for Free... I've already ade my millions!!!!

Avatar
#71 MessyEH!
October 21 2013, 02:36PM
Trash it!
3
trashes
Cheers
2
cheers
K_Mart wrote:

Good research, good article, and good points.

With the injuries this team seems to always suffer, I'd have to disagree, and say that we need the depth, and believe we can get the versatility in player types through either drafting or FA's.

Trading Yak or Ebs isn't completely off the table, but if a solidified #1 d man under the age of 30, with term, isn't coming back, than I would never support the trade.

One of the following d men would HAVE to be coming our way, some are too old, some too good, but when I look at these names I just can't think of a possible trade that could occur that would result in being a reasonable trade for both sides...

PK Subban, Kristopher Letang, Ryan Suter, Cody Franson, Dustin Byfuglien, Niklas Kronwall, Shea Weber, Dion Phaneuf, Keith Yandle, Brian Campbell, Mike Green, Duncan Keith, Alex Pietrangelo, Oliver Ekman-Larsson, Vyacheslav Voynov, Jay Bouwmeester, Alexander Edler, Kevin Shattenkirk, Drew Doughty, Brent Seabrook, Fedor Tyutin, Zdeno Chara, Jack Johnson, Tobias Enström, Erik Karlsson , Kimmo Timonen, Dion Phaneuf,

Dion Phaneuf so nice you named him twice.

If I was to make the trade that would send a fab fiver flying. It would be Eberle. Biggest return with the least to lose. Eberle would get you Phaneuf. Eberle and Gagner + picks might get you Webber.

Avatar
#72 Allycatx
October 21 2013, 02:41PM
Trash it!
0
trashes
Cheers
2
cheers

Yak is a talent when he has the puck but u have to play away from the puck nowadays and right now he does not know how , lots of poke checks and flybys around the boards. Granted he may become a stud in the NHL at some point but we are years away unt he really gets it. I say trade bait for the future now to upgrade team , also no more talk about dybbuk he can do the job folks just need a little patience , it's all coming together just not pace a lot of fans want it too

Avatar
#73 DonDon
October 21 2013, 06:07PM
Trash it!
1
trashes
Cheers
2
cheers

Injuries, injuries, injuries, when will they end?

Even though the Oilers beat the Senators in Ottawa, we witnessed what a big, tough team can inflict on the smaller Oilers. Following the game, Hall and now Smyth out with injuries.

The team hasn't faced other teams with big and tough players, e.g., San Jose, Los Angeles, Anaheim, St. Louis, Chicago, Even Winnipeg and Calgary are bigger and tougher than the Oil. All in the Western Conference. Ouch!

When will the brass learn skill combined with size and toughness will almost always beat skill?

Avatar
#74 oilers2k10
October 21 2013, 06:23PM
Trash it!
0
trashes
Cheers
2
cheers
DSF wrote:

Of course Kane and Toews won the Stanley Cup when Kane was Hall's age.

That team had Hossa, Brouwer, Bfugulien, Dave Bolland and others.

The Oilers don't have equivalencies for those types of players.

And this is the reason why the Oilers need to start surrounding these kids with some real veterans..Hemsky doesn't do it as a vet, Boyd Gordon has been good but Oilers need more. Don't trade the skill for grinders..just get some damn quality grinders already..it's been 4 years, and all they got to show for it is Boyd Gordon and Andrew Ference..step it up Oil Management.. Trade this and next years first round picks or somethin, but don't trade away that hard earned first overall talent.

Avatar
#75 DSF
October 21 2013, 06:49PM
Trash it!
4
trashes
Cheers
2
cheers
pkam wrote:

And I forgot to mention that it is a salary dump for the Blues, they need the cap space to sign Oshie and Pietrangelo.

So the Blues managed to sign both Oshie and Pietrangelo, and get MPS and a 2nd rounder for Perron. Not bad at all for the Blues.

They also had to re-sign Chris Stewart.

Perron was a salary dump.

Avatar
#76 Soccer Steve
October 21 2013, 07:17PM
Trash it!
2
trashes
Cheers
2
cheers

@pkam

Apologies for forgetting the second rounder. However, I wasn't arguing who won the trade but since you bring it up, MacT crushed it. Crushed. It absolutely does not matter what the Blues did with the freed up money to the Oil. That has nothing to do with the trade. The Blues would reverse this trade in an instant if they could.

Avatar
#77 DSF
October 21 2013, 07:21PM
Trash it!
4
trashes
Cheers
2
cheers
Soccer Steve wrote:

Apologies for forgetting the second rounder. However, I wasn't arguing who won the trade but since you bring it up, MacT crushed it. Crushed. It absolutely does not matter what the Blues did with the freed up money to the Oil. That has nothing to do with the trade. The Blues would reverse this trade in an instant if they could.

No they wouldn't.

Avatar
#78 Wonger
October 21 2013, 09:43PM
Trash it!
7
trashes
Cheers
2
cheers

Brown to San Jose for a 4th. Something big is coming! BIG TRADE COMING TOMORROW AM!

Avatar
#79 Zarny
October 22 2013, 09:13AM
Trash it!
1
trashes
Cheers
2
cheers

Gregor is 100% correct.

The current top 6 F for the Oilers are too much of the same. They'll make the playoffs but will never win the Cup. It's puzzling some don't see it. All it takes is one look at the teams who actually do win the Cup.

I don't think the Oilers "have" to trade one of Hall, Nuge, Eberle and Yakupov.

2 of the top 6 F however, will have to swapped out for what the Oilers currently lack: size, strength, puck possession and defensive abilities.

I'm all for those two being Perron and Gagner. Why not keep the best? And when you look at the big C in the west like Getzlaf, Carter, Thornton, Toews etc it becomes very difficult for the Oilers to compete with Nuge and Gagner.

The problem is trading Perron and Gagner straight up or with picks/prospects for the F the Oilers need are very difficult trades. And the Oilers will still need a legit shutdown Dman. It's not a coincidence the Oilers last Cup appearance was with Chris Pronger.

And this season has only reinforced my belief that Dubnyk is good enough to make the playoffs but not to win the Cup. So the Oilers are going to have to upgrade in net too.

I think some fans need to wrap their head around how difficult it is to win the Stanley Cup. How deep and versatile your team needs to be.

There probably is a reality where MacT can make the required changes without trading one of the "fab four". But the options are very limited.

The key to this article is these aren't trades that need to be made this year or even next. The Oilers don't have a hope of being legit Cup contenders for at least 2 more years and the current roster has a decent shot at making the playoffs. Patience is the key. The Oilers don't need 'a' trade they need the right trade.

Avatar
#80 Zarny
October 22 2013, 09:29AM
Trash it!
0
trashes
Cheers
2
cheers
Wayne wrote:

It was no secret they already had a glut of small skill when they won the lottery in 2012. Since it was the third year in a row, why not draft for need instead of "the best player available?" Galchenyuk is a big, natural centre cutting his teeth on the wing before moving back to the middle and Ryan Murray is the potential top pairing dman type they desperately need. Question is why not take a small risk and draft what you need more than what you have when getting a gift like that?

Yakupov is and will be a very good player, but in Edmonton he's one of many of the same. For the same reason, I was a but baffled by Perron trade. Good player but more need at centre and defence were bigger priorities.

The idea of drafting the best player available is that you can always trade an asset.

And while scouting has reduced draft busts it's still a crap-shoot which 1st rounders will develop into stars including Galchenyuk and Murray.

The Oilers could have drafted Adam Larsson or Eric Gudbranson for team need too instead of Nuge or Hall; but look how that would have turned out so far. Maybe Larsson and Gudbranson turn into all-star D but so far taking the best player in the draft was the way to go.

Avatar
#81 Dubs-nik
October 21 2013, 12:12PM
Trash it!
8
trashes
Cheers
1
cheers

Syst!

Avatar
#82 Anonymous
October 21 2013, 01:33PM
Trash it!
15
trashes
Cheers
1
cheers
WONGER TO MAC T wrote:

STAUBITZ on waivers! Pick him up now!!!! TOUGH, CAN PLAY, A BETTER HORDICHUK!!! You still need more toughness, especially CRAZY TOUGHNESS up front!!! This is your man!!! Oh yeah, trade fpr ENGELLAND for 6-7 D spot. Can play and VERY, VERY TOUGH!!!!! GO MAC T!!!! THE WONGER NEVER STEERS YOU WONG!!! HAHA!!!! REMEMBER, I TIPPED YOU OFF ON MAC going on waivers, and GAZDIC!!!!! OTTAWA game looked liked MEN vs BOYS even though you won. Hall and Eberle banged up!!!! Let's get BIGGER and TOUGHER!!!!!!!! YOU CAN DO IT MAC T!!!!!!!!!!!!

Relax Wonger! The Oil are very close to two deals - a big one and a little one- and you are going to be very happy with who we bring in! My sources are way better than..... you'll see!!!!! ssssshhhhhhh.......!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Avatar
#83 Acumen
October 21 2013, 01:34PM
Trash it!
5
trashes
Cheers
1
cheers

@Dan 1919

I've been screaming Yakupov for Jones/one of the picks that would net Jones since before the draft.

It sucks that he went to Nashville as they would probably be a little more sour on Russians than anyone who isn't Columbus, but I think a Yakupov for Jones deal makes perfect sense for both sides. Nashville has Weber and is already stacked with young D, and they've needed offensive firepower since... 1998?

Nurse-Jones down the road would be devastating.

Avatar
#84 beloch
October 21 2013, 02:12PM
Trash it!
0
trashes
Cheers
1
cheers

"If I could touch them with my om forks, I could help get their fluid flowing through their spinal cord and up to their brain. They would feel good and it would bring in good energy"

I seriously never expected to read something like that in a link posted to a hockey blog. I didn't even know what an om fork was until I googled it! So... uh... Thanks?

Om forks ftw!

Avatar
#85 Anonymous
October 21 2013, 02:28PM
Trash it!
8
trashes
Cheers
1
cheers

Hiller, Etem or Maroon to Oilers soon!!!!!!!!!!! Plus Brian Allen!!!!!!!

Avatar
#86 Wonger
October 21 2013, 02:30PM
Trash it!
4
trashes
Cheers
1
cheers
Anonymous wrote:

Hiller, Etem or Maroon to Oilers soon!!!!!!!!!!! Plus Brian Allen!!!!!!!

I hope its Maroon, and I hope its soon(Rhymes....Wonger Rap!!!)

Avatar
#87 Spydr
October 21 2013, 02:34PM
Trash it!
2
trashes
Cheers
1
cheers
Wonger wrote:

I hope its Maroon, and I hope its soon(Rhymes....Wonger Rap!!!)

Oil should hire Wonger for Director of Enforcer and Functional Toughness Personel!

Avatar
#88 Next up, is Connor McJesus.
October 21 2013, 02:48PM
Trash it!
7
trashes
Cheers
1
cheers

@MessyEH!

[Eberle and Gagner + picks might get you Webber.]

With the change we have leftover from that deal. We could also bring in Couturier.

Avatar
#89 DFT
October 21 2013, 05:49PM
Trash it!
3
trashes
Cheers
1
cheers

Oil need way more size and grit! Smyth injured! Will this ever end? Are we gonna get Connor McDavid next June? Seriously, what do you guys think? Are we gonna tank another season? Please tell me no!

Avatar
#90 Spydyr
October 21 2013, 05:55PM
Trash it!
3
trashes
Cheers
1
cheers
Big Boy wrote:

Quit whining you little babies! Grow a set! Stick to the topic- hockey! Yakupov,etc. not somebody poached my handle.... Waaaaaaahhh!!!

You might not mind an intellectual half wit posing as you that's cool

I don't appreciate one posing as me.Just letting the regulars here know whats up.

Avatar
#91 Spadr
October 21 2013, 06:01PM
Trash it!
7
trashes
Cheers
1
cheers
DFT wrote:

Oil need way more size and grit! Smyth injured! Will this ever end? Are we gonna get Connor McDavid next June? Seriously, what do you guys think? Are we gonna tank another season? Please tell me no!

I believe Eakins and MACT will fix this! I love them. They are two hockey geniuses! In the mean time I will cheer for the Flames! Nobody screws around with these guys cause nobody wants to have to answer to McGrattan, Jackman et. al!

Avatar
#92 Reality Check to the head
October 21 2013, 06:03PM
Trash it!
1
trashes
Cheers
1
cheers

Risk is the part of the definition of a Bold Move.

I know everyone is looking at Yak as trade bait. His time has been less with the oilers and however fair, he is russian and their seems to be a stigma attached to it.

Anyone one of our Top forwards is a risk to trade away. I agree, I think that at some point the Oilers will have to make a move, but I wonder at what point in time? Is the move to push the oilers over the top in an attempt to make the playoffs?

Or, do we wait a little longer, fill in a few holes via free agency and development. Then try and fill a few holes with a trade a little later in an attempt to win the west and get another chance at the cup?

What will our defence look like in 2 years, Darnell Nurse, Oscar Klefbom etc getting older and NHL ready. Only time will tell.

Avatar
#93 DnDon
October 21 2013, 06:18PM
Trash it!
1
trashes
Cheers
1
cheers
Spadr wrote:

I believe Eakins and MACT will fix this! I love them. They are two hockey geniuses! In the mean time I will cheer for the Flames! Nobody screws around with these guys cause nobody wants to have to answer to McGrattan, Jackman et. al!

By cheering for the Flames, you must be a Flames fan.

If by "...Eakins and MACT will fix this" means the Oilers staying in the cellar, no wonder you love Eakins and MacT, who are not faring very well yet with this new version of the Oilers.

Avatar
#94 Next up, is Connor McJesus.
October 21 2013, 08:06PM
Trash it!
4
trashes
Cheers
1
cheers
DSF wrote:

Can't disagree with a word of that.

I hear Grebeshkov is playing #2 LW tomorrow.

Jeebus.

I'd consider it a another moral victory if they can keep the Habs to under a touchdown tomorrow.

Avatar
#95 Next up, is Connor McJesus.
October 21 2013, 08:21PM
Trash it!
3
trashes
Cheers
1
cheers

@DSF

Are we sure our all hat, no cattle coach is going to dress him?

Avatar
#96 Spydyr
October 21 2013, 08:40PM
Trash it!
3
trashes
Cheers
1
cheers

I hear the Oilers are close to a 6 for 3 trade with Nashville- we get Weber, Rinnie and Gaustad ...just saw it on a Nasville station! Gotta go! Mom said its beddiby time!

Avatar
#97 DSF
October 21 2013, 08:47PM
Trash it!
3
trashes
Cheers
1
cheers
Spydyr wrote:

I hear the Oilers are close to a 6 for 3 trade with Nashville- we get Weber, Rinnie and Gaustad ...just saw it on a Nasville station! Gotta go! Mom said its beddiby time!

Me too! Gonna have some cookie with my milk, crush the toilet then nittynight for me as well! Goodnight buddy! Hope we get Webber too!

Avatar
#98 Steve
October 21 2013, 08:48PM
Trash it!
0
trashes
Cheers
1
cheers

I find it highly unlikely that we could acquire a true #1 defenceman even for someone like yakupov. GM's are way too smart to fall for that nowadays. If MacT came up to you and offered yakupov for subban or e Larsson or doughty or Pietrangelo or anyone else along those lines you'd probably laugh.

The Oilers can keep the big 4 (hall, RNH, Eberle, yakupov) and win a cup in the future... they just need to be patient and make it their mission to find a big 2way second line centre over they next 3 years while all their top defensive prospects develop (nurse, klefbom, marincin, gernat, etc).

Seriously, how different would the team look if we had a big 2way centre to play on the second line and one of our defensive prospects devolop into a legit top pairing guy?

If I were in charge, I would trade gagner and Perron at some point over the next 3 years before their contracts expire for above average gritty bottom six forwards... While making it my #1 priority over the next 3 years to draft quality 2way centres with some size while my defensive prospects develop.

Avatar
#99 DSF
October 21 2013, 08:53PM
Trash it!
2
trashes
Cheers
1
cheers
Steve wrote:

I find it highly unlikely that we could acquire a true #1 defenceman even for someone like yakupov. GM's are way too smart to fall for that nowadays. If MacT came up to you and offered yakupov for subban or e Larsson or doughty or Pietrangelo or anyone else along those lines you'd probably laugh.

The Oilers can keep the big 4 (hall, RNH, Eberle, yakupov) and win a cup in the future... they just need to be patient and make it their mission to find a big 2way second line centre over they next 3 years while all their top defensive prospects develop (nurse, klefbom, marincin, gernat, etc).

Seriously, how different would the team look if we had a big 2way centre to play on the second line and one of our defensive prospects devolop into a legit top pairing guy?

If I were in charge, I would trade gagner and Perron at some point over the next 3 years before their contracts expire for above average gritty bottom six forwards... While making it my #1 priority over the next 3 years to draft quality 2way centres with some size while my defensive prospects develop.

You mean a big 2 way centre like Galchenyuk?

Or Seguin?

Oh, the humanity!

Avatar
#100 DSF
October 21 2013, 09:21PM
Trash it!
1
trashes
Cheers
1
cheers
Next up, is Connor McJesus. wrote:

Are we sure our all hat, no cattle coach is going to dress him?

I don't appreciate you referring to our coach as big hat, no cattle.... You Jerk!

Comments are closed for this article.