DESPERATION ON DISPLAY

Robin Brownlee
November 09 2013 12:17AM

As the losses have mounted through 17 games, the demand by fans of the Edmonton Oilers that GM Craig MacTavish DO SOMETHING to change the fortunes of the team have grown louder by the day.

MacTavish gave those fans what they wanted Friday, sending hard-nosed and popular but limited defenseman Ladislav Smid and Olivier Roy down Highway 2 to the Calgary Flames for prospects, MacTavish followed that up by signing Ilya Bryzgalov to a one-year contract.

Yes, Ilya Bryzgalov, the goaltender the Philadelphia Flyers just paid $23 million to not play for them two years after signing him to a ridiculous nine-year contract worth $51 million. Ilya Bryzgalov, the oh-so flakey laugh riot, Knob Hockey hero and dressing room distraction represented by Edmonton agent Ritch Winter. That Ilya Bryzgalov.

With the Oilers floundering at 4-11-2 and staring at an eighth straight year out of the playoffs less than two weeks into November during a season in which MacTavish and new coach Dallas Eakins have over-promised and under-delivered, these aren't the bold moves MacTavish talked about when he took over the chair formerly occupied by Steve Tambellini.

This is desperation on display.

AN UPGRADE?

Make no mistake, Devan Dubnyk left the door wide open for MacTavish to make a deal to address his goaltending – forced his hand, actually – with an absolutely abysmal performance so far this season. That's on him.

The last straw, obviously, came in a 4-2 loss to the Tampa Bay Lightning in a game the Oilers played more than well enough to win. That's been the storyline more than once this season, one repeated often enough that the upgrades MacTavish has made to the roster on paper haven’t translated to the standings. How could MacTavish stand pat?

Fair question, even if dealing from a position of weakness almost never turns out well. But Bryzgalov, now 33 and coming off back-to-back seasons with save percentages of .909 in 2011-12 and .900 in 2012-13? Bryzgalov, whose career save percentage of .913 on good, bad an indifferent teams is a wash with the .911 posted by Dubnyk, including his horrid start to this season and a career spent on a bottom-feeder team?

I'd argue, and did on Twitter, shunting Dubnyk aside is like deciding to trade in your old Ford because it isn't reliable enough, then replacing it with a Lada that's six model years older. In terms of actual performance, I don’t see it as a clear upgrade. Then, there's the flake factor with a player who has had dubious chemistry with teammates in the past.

WHAT'S THE PUNCHLINE?

Bryzgalov, to understate, has some quirks. He's out there. He tends to fill the notepads of reporters -- never a bad thing for those who work the beat – and wear on the patience of teammates. Bryzgalov, you might remember, once compared Edmonton to the North Pole when talking about why Anaheim teammate Chris Pronger might have wanted out of Edmonton.

"He (Pronger) maybe tried to leave here because here in November months is a minus-32," Bryzgalov said in an interview with The Score. "Could you imagine? It’s eight months in a year of snow."

Might Bryzgalov push Dubnyk to be better or even displace him as the starter if he can reverse the slide in his performance of the past two seasons? I think it's unlikely, but it's possible, I suppose. Is it a big gamble? Not really, at least in terms of money, reported to be $1.75 million, or term.

Still, it strikes me as an ill-conceived signing brought on by another season off the rails because it wasn't supposed to unfold like this again. It's a just-do-something -- ANYTHING, dammit -- move. A distinct hint of panic over a plan gone wrong. It's desperation on display.

Listen to Robin Brownlee Wednesdays and Thursdays from 3 p.m. to 5 p.m. on the Jason Gregor Show on TEAM 1260.

Aceb4a1816f5fa09879a023b07d1a9b4
A sports writer since 1983, including stints at The Edmonton Journal and The Sun 1989-2007, I happily co-host the Jason Gregor Show on TSN 1260 twice a week and write when so inclined. Have the best damn lawn on the internet. Most important, I am Sam's dad. Follow me on Twitter at Robin_Brownlee. Or don't.
Avatar
#1 27Ginge
November 09 2013, 12:27AM
Trash it!
5
trashes
Cheers
76
cheers

I honestly love the Bryzgalov signing. There is little to no risk in a one year deal. The best case scenario is that he comes in and plays well and raises the level of Dubnyk's game. Duby proved before that he could handle having a veteran Russian backup that wasn't exactly the most polished guy off the ice. Worst case scenario is that the guy is a head case that plays as bad as Labarbera has and gives us all something to laugh at while the Oilers slowly die a thousand deaths for yet another season.

Avatar
#2 druds
November 09 2013, 12:23AM
Trash it!
14
trashes
Cheers
41
cheers

Yes its desperation but what exactly are they supposed to do? wait for DD to "find himself"? and I think Brgy's save percentage is still miles ahead of Labarbera and Dub so where is the hurt? You having a bad night?

Avatar
#3 Eddie Shore
November 09 2013, 12:36AM
Trash it!
4
trashes
Cheers
38
cheers

@27Ginge

Exactly. Whats the risk? The more puzzling move for me is the Smid trade.

Avatar
#4 Fresh Mess
November 09 2013, 08:14AM
Trash it!
20
trashes
Cheers
36
cheers

Just think of the elation this fan base would be experiencing right now if Mactavish had just acquired a tough, physical,experienced young NHL mid pairing D-Man with good character.

Now imaging the cost of this acquisition was merely what amounts to Bunz and Pitlick. ON would be on cloud nine. This is what the Flames fans are celebrating today after fleecing the dullards who run the Oilers.

You want to save some cap and contract space? How about not wasting 1.5 million on freakinGREBESHKOV !!

It's as if Lowe and MacT felt their status as the biggest incompetents in hockey was challenged by Garth Snow after the laughable Vanek trade, and came up with this as a response.

Joke of a trade from an absolutely pathetic franchise.

Avatar
#5 Spydyr
November 09 2013, 08:16AM
Trash it!
13
trashes
Cheers
35
cheers

The Oilers just got easier to play against.They are supposed to be getting harder to play against.They traded what little heart the have to a divisional rival for cap room.They are again flying by the seat of their pants making rash,bad decisions.

Rookie GM says it all.Rookie coach hurts too.Just a badly run NHL team from the owner on down.

Avatar
#6 Jay Gray
November 09 2013, 12:57AM
Trash it!
3
trashes
Cheers
31
cheers

Clearly the price was too high to obtain a #1 goalie by trade. It would've been nice to get Lehner, Gibson, etc, but not at the price I'm sure their gm's are asking. Something had to be done and I'm fine with signing Bryz. 1.75m is a very reasonable, low risk deal.

I've loved Ladi's dedication and sacrifice, but the young guys are knocking at the door, bodies have to move to make room. Was happy to see Brossoit come back in the deal.

Avatar
#7 Retsinnab5
November 09 2013, 01:05AM
Trash it!
5
trashes
Cheers
31
cheers

Laurent Brossoit has Played 127min in the ECHL this year and hasn't let in a goal. Maybe we win this trade in the long term?

Avatar
#8 @Oilanderp
November 09 2013, 03:50AM
Trash it!
6
trashes
Cheers
31
cheers

The Oilers better do something! Anything! But if they do anything they better not! I'll be so pissed if they do! See this cake? I am eating it too!

For some, whining is autonomic, like breathing.

Avatar
#9 Soccer Steve
November 09 2013, 08:21AM
Trash it!
13
trashes
Cheers
31
cheers

The most surprising thing about this trade is how truly over-rated Smid was.

He wasn't very good on a very bad team. Call it what it is - salary dump - and move on.

Avatar
#10 Spydyr
November 09 2013, 08:25AM
Trash it!
9
trashes
Cheers
31
cheers
Soccer Steve wrote:

The most surprising thing about this trade is how truly over-rated Smid was.

He wasn't very good on a very bad team. Call it what it is - salary dump - and move on.

Smid was one of the few player here with any heart.One of the few defencman who cleared the front of the net.he made more saves then the teams goalies.To top it off they trade him to Calgary.

Avatar
#11 Chris.
November 09 2013, 12:21AM
Trash it!
5
trashes
Cheers
30
cheers

I'm waiting on another move... *sigh*

...always waiting...

Avatar
#12 Rob
November 09 2013, 08:21AM
Trash it!
4
trashes
Cheers
30
cheers

The real mistake was when the Oilers actively pursued Labarbera over the summer. My first reaction, that guy is still in the league? Mediocre at best. Bryzgalov is better than him, Dubnyk? Who knows. The best part of this is if the season is lost already anyways. If Bryzgalov is a problem or plays horribly, easy solution : Oilers don't resign him. In the off chance he somehow rediscovers some of his past glory we've stumbled on to a guy who can get us to our next goalie and MacT looks like a genius. It's win-win. Only problem, this should have been done weeks ago.

Avatar
#13 Sevenseven
November 09 2013, 12:34AM
Trash it!
8
trashes
Cheers
29
cheers

Maybe after getting bought out, a newly humbled Ilya Bryzgalov comes in and challanges Dubnyk to play better, and he responds. Our season can't get any worse, and signing a player to a one year contract means if it's a failed experiment, just walk away. I liked smid, but he's not the top pairing defenseman we need. IMHO I think we are deep at defense, the ahl call ups have been pretty good. Iit's just too bad they are all 4,5,6 guys. Mac t at least tried here to address the goalie problem, and although this may not be a top 10 NHL goalie, he didn't really give up anything to make it happen.

Avatar
#14 reaperfunkss (2nd tier fan)
November 09 2013, 12:38AM
Trash it!
4
trashes
Cheers
26
cheers
Johnny Larue wrote:

Better than a kick in the ass

I believe this is a kick in the ass

Avatar
#15 moneygoalie31
November 09 2013, 08:34AM
Trash it!
8
trashes
Cheers
26
cheers

Larson and Fedun have showed well so far. Grebs is a terrible signing, Belov is a gem and only gonna get better. Laddy was gonna be moved eventually, we have to get to a point where our 5-6 d make less then 3.5 million. He was a top four guy for us but should he be??? I still think Mac T is doing a good job, Eakins is gonna be fine. The blame here goes on management and coaches all the time, It is well past time for the million dollar players to cowboy up and play some f#@%ing hockey.

Avatar
#16 stubblejumper99
November 09 2013, 01:13AM
Trash it!
10
trashes
Cheers
23
cheers

Rock bottom is giving players away to the Flames

Avatar
#17 jonny94
November 09 2013, 06:45AM
Trash it!
5
trashes
Cheers
23
cheers

I love how MacT is just getting criticized by everyone and their dog about Bryzgalov. If I recall correctly everyone in OilersNation including myself was up in arms about our goaltending and how we needed a change,. The Oilers went as far as bringing in Bachman to steal the spotlight between the pipes and nothing worked.

If you want to call this "desperation on display" fine. But if you ask me it would have been A LOT more desperate to overpay another team like Anaheim or Toronto to bring in a goalie and possibly weaken this team more then it already is.

At least MacT did something.... And that something was more then Tambellini ever did.

Btw Bryzgalov is a low risk high reward. If Bryzgalov sucks then see you later we didn't lose anyone over him (unless you consider Smid a salary dump to bring him in but I don't believe that true) if Bryzgalov plays well and wins the Oilers hockey games well I hope all you critics give credit where credit is deserved.

Avatar
#18 Fresh Mess
November 09 2013, 08:27AM
Trash it!
11
trashes
Cheers
22
cheers

So after the dust settles....DD is still the team's best goalie and their most physical D-man was given away for a couple of long shots to even make the NHL years from now. Unreal.

Avatar
#19 watkinator
November 09 2013, 01:27AM
Trash it!
3
trashes
Cheers
21
cheers

I like that karma has come back to bite Bryz in the backside and I respect the crow he's eating right now for it. Hope he turns things around for his sake and the Oilers.

Avatar
#20 Oilcruzer
November 09 2013, 06:52AM
Trash it!
2
trashes
Cheers
21
cheers

Nobody's given Bryz the starting job. Nobody has signed him to a long term deal.

Making two goalie moves in one day? A definite wake up call that takes the pressure off the skaters.

Face it. If the Oil would get that one big save a game, heck, any game this year, it could have changed the course of that game, etc.

NO TEAM can play well if they aren't confident in the goalie.

Seen it / coached it way too many times. There's nothing in hockey that changes a team's confidence like good / poor goaltending.

Avatar
#21 Cynic
November 09 2013, 01:38AM
Trash it!
14
trashes
Cheers
20
cheers

Wasn't Smid the only Oiler defender with at least a passing familiarity with actually playing D? Which of the organization's score of 5s, 7s and 9s will fill that hole?

Avatar
#22 mlcselli
November 09 2013, 02:15AM
Trash it!
3
trashes
Cheers
19
cheers

I guess the only thing to do is welcome Bryz, and hope like hell he can win us some games. I hate to see Smid go (especially down the road), but I bid him a farewell. This team left the way it is, with no defensive replacement for Smid is worse than it was Friday morning. MacT can't be finished--something must but be in the works.

Avatar
#23 DigDeepNBleedBlue
November 09 2013, 05:01AM
Trash it!
7
trashes
Cheers
19
cheers

Trade:

Salary cap dump.

Smid was signed for too much loot. His game was rough, but lacked skill. At 2mil a season he would have been a good addition. Alas, he was not.

I liked your will, sir.

What you pyhsically get, from someone with cap space in a rebuild, is a respectable goalie prospect. A need in the org.

Horack for Roy. Oilers drop a goalie (cause the math) prospect and the flames dump a small F prospect. Both RFAs at the end of their ECLs. 50 man list. One year commitment…

Brossoit will determine the winner. Have a seat, grab a beer and enjoy the ride.

In addition, we snatch up Bryz. Colourful. Enigmatic. Blah, blah, blah. What? The goaltending sucks ass right now. What does it hurt? Nothing. Send him down to Cali. Cosmonaut in Cali.... This can only have an on ice up.

I want more….

Avatar
#25 Naky
November 09 2013, 12:28AM
Trash it!
39
trashes
Cheers
18
cheers

Bryzgalov couldn't handle the fans or the media pressure in Philly, you think he can handle it here? How about living in the North Pole now? This guy's a joke and a clown who made his career and money off successful defensive systems of superior teams and has proven that when those systems fail, he can't do any better than Dubnyk is faring right now. I've been linking that stupid video for ages and the fact that we actually signed him just lowered MacT several notches in my 'capable' category.

For the love of this team and what it used to be, I honestly hope the signing works out because if it doesn't it'll just be another domino in the chain of events that's making this organization a true mockery.

Avatar
#26 Pouzar99
November 09 2013, 02:06AM
Trash it!
2
trashes
Cheers
18
cheers

With the Oilers goalies posting a league-worst .874 save percentage, down from last year's .917, something had to be done. How many more games can we bear to watch where our goaltending costs us points? The boys have raised their battle level on the road trip and are cutting down on the still too frequent giveaways, but they will never turn this around until they get at least average NHL goaltending, in the .912-.913 range. Bryz will have to start in OKC and should be ready to play in a week or two, which gives Dubnyk time to get his act together.

Avatar
#28 Johe
November 09 2013, 08:40AM
Trash it!
2
trashes
Cheers
17
cheers

At this point, I have to think Bryz is probably capable of stopping a beach ball. So... improvement in our goaltending looks likely.

And maybe with other Russians on the team he'll fit in a bit better. I don't know, this move is worth a shot.

Avatar
#29 Naky
November 09 2013, 01:08AM
Trash it!
35
trashes
Cheers
16
cheers

I'm honestly perplexed by the amount of people who think that this was a decent signing.

2m for a goaltender whose statistics are literally awful barring a couple of decent years (equivalent to Dubnyk's usual numbers!!!) in a highly defensive oriented system implemented by Tippett.

2m for a goaltender a goaltender that has expressed his honest and heartfelt feelings, not to mention disrespect, towards Edmonton and its fans just a few years ago - a sentiment that likely didn't change until he was bought out and started to feel that desperation as the summer went on and realized nobody wanted him.

2m for a goaltender who has previously and publicly thrown his teammates under the bus when he feels they were the real reasons why he let in so many goals.

2m for a goaltender that will make a 3 headed monster of our goaltending situation made even worse if he can't play well. What happens if he sucks, as his previous numbers show that he does? Do we waive him? How many games do we give him if he is sucking? How many does he get as a free pass or is LaBarbera the odd duck out here no matter what?

2m for a goaltender that forced one of our better veteran defensive defenders off to our rivals to the south. We just got smaller, weaker, and easier to play against to make room for him. Hope he can make up for the loss as Smid was one of like two defenders willing to make space for our goaltenders in our crease.

This makes no sense and especially not at that price. If Bryzgalov wanted to prove himself so badly he should have been willing to sign for 1m. We overpaid, we lost a good asset to make room for him, and we can't even say we got an upgrade on LBB much less DD.

How are you guys not perplexed with me.

Avatar
#30 Greg the Hammer Valentine
November 09 2013, 06:26AM
Trash it!
7
trashes
Cheers
16
cheers

Any truth to the rumor Tambellini challenged MacT to get more first overall picks in a row than him?

Avatar
#31 stubblejumper99
November 09 2013, 01:10AM
Trash it!
3
trashes
Cheers
15
cheers

At least it wasn't Ebs....have said so many

Avatar
#32 The real minnow
November 09 2013, 02:30AM
Trash it!
4
trashes
Cheers
15
cheers

Why do people constantly clamour over the financials of a signing? Right now the oilers suck the hind banana whether this deal was for 750k or 45m. Who gives a damn. We won't make the playoffs this season, this move is prolly just to evaluate what we have moving forward. It's the middle of November and we can say with almost absolute certainty that this team doesn't stand a chance this season. Enjoy the winter months :)

Avatar
#33 albertaboy19
November 09 2013, 08:13AM
Trash it!
6
trashes
Cheers
14
cheers

So who is actually going to play defense now? Gave away our only dman who really hits? Our defense has gone from soft as butter to soft as baby sh*t

Avatar
#34 Hemmercules
November 09 2013, 08:57AM
Trash it!
3
trashes
Cheers
14
cheers

Smid to Calgary sucks. Getting not much for him sucks even more. I have to think there is another deal in the works. I'm waiting a few days before judging the trade to see if anything else happens.

Brysgalov is a total wild card. Nobody knows how he will play. I Imagine he's been a bit humbled by being bought out and not signed until November. Lets hope he comes in with a clear head and with something to prove.

As usual we wait to see how this plays out over the next month. History tells me it will be a disaster. I'm getting tired of complaining about every move this team makes. I'll buy a little hope for now and see how this 6 ring circus plays out.

Avatar
#35 Mychew
November 09 2013, 02:09AM
Trash it!
16
trashes
Cheers
13
cheers

Why didn't we trade glengross?... Oh never mind we gave him away.

Avatar
#36 Andrew
November 09 2013, 02:17AM
Trash it!
3
trashes
Cheers
13
cheers

The desperation of the situation is exceeded only by the fans' impatience (mine included).

For Mact's part in all this, he has been official GM for six months or so and in the weeds waiting for a year before that. He unfortunately inherited a schmoozle in the dressing room and those problems can't be fixed overnight. I give a pass to him to that extent. The axe needs to fall higher up but that is getting to be a stale issue.

The same group that have been clamouring for him to make a move, seem to have become experts in critiquing the latest move. If Eakins gets more of a full and healthy line-up then I think more moves will be less likely right now. If the team starts to show continual improvement then I don't expect to see much player movement until the trade deadline.

I think more improvements need to be made but doing so from a position of relative strength would likely increase the chances of it being successful. I'm more interested in seeing what the team performs like with all hands on deck.

Avatar
#37 GTL
November 09 2013, 05:42AM
Trash it!
3
trashes
Cheers
13
cheers
Retsinnab5 wrote:

Too bad Bryzgalov's five hole is Humongous Big!

And also his pie hole...

Avatar
#38 Soccer Steve
November 09 2013, 08:37AM
Trash it!
8
trashes
Cheers
13
cheers

@Spydyr

Quantify "heart".

All I see is that he was one of our mainstays while missing the playoffs all these years.

For some reason everyone clamors for changes yet when it happens it's pure criticism.

I repeat, he was consistently a 4/5th D-man on the worst team in the league. Move on.

Avatar
#39 Rheal1
November 09 2013, 08:49AM
Trash it!
4
trashes
Cheers
13
cheers

Smid for two prospects................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................. Sigh......................................................................................................................Someone wake me up when one of three things happen: When MacT triggers a real bold move, KLowe has been dismissed (never?) or we draft 5th overall in June.

Avatar
#40 TeddyTurnbuckle
November 09 2013, 05:16AM
Trash it!
8
trashes
Cheers
12
cheers

Personally I think Smid is no better than a number 6 defenceman with a big contract so I don't mind the deal. He does block a lot of shots but his transition game is horrible which is why Eakins probably gave the green light to get rid of him. Bad contract by tambo. As far as brzgalov, Is this guy in game shape?

Avatar
#41 Rheal1
November 09 2013, 08:57AM
Trash it!
2
trashes
Cheers
12
cheers

On Bryz:

The Flyers must have seen something potential wise when they gave Bryzgalov the keys to that Brinks truck. Last season Bryz was very average for a bona fide NHL netminder. However, the three previous seasons he averaged 65 games played, 2.42GAA, .914 and had a total of 21 shutouts. If we get that player back, MacT is brilliant (fingers crossed)If Bryz can play on his head following his AHL conditioning fit, watch out!!! I will closely monitor his AHL play.

Avatar
#42 reaperfunkss (2nd tier fan)
November 09 2013, 12:37AM
Trash it!
1
trashes
Cheers
11
cheers

Can we make a Nero Rome burning reference? Someone call Katz in Vancouver and ask.

Avatar
#43 Saytalk
November 09 2013, 01:34AM
Trash it!
17
trashes
Cheers
11
cheers

Bad trade. Not only did MacT give Smid away just to make cap room, but he gave Smid away to a division rival. On top of that, the Oilers' 50 man roster gets further cluttered with mediocre prospects who are highly unlikely to amount to anything. Trading Nick Schultz for a seventh round draft pick would have been a better deal than this one (assuming someone who have taken the other side).

Avatar
#44 Gordie Wayne
November 09 2013, 08:14AM
Trash it!
5
trashes
Cheers
11
cheers

How about a crazy trade rumour first thing Saturday morning...

Dubnyk, Hemsky, Omark for Simmonds, Meszaros, and Mason.

Will make the Philly game more interesting today.

Avatar
#45 Spydyr
November 09 2013, 08:43AM
Trash it!
9
trashes
Cheers
11
cheers
Soccer Steve wrote:

Quantify "heart".

All I see is that he was one of our mainstays while missing the playoffs all these years.

For some reason everyone clamors for changes yet when it happens it's pure criticism.

I repeat, he was consistently a 4/5th D-man on the worst team in the league. Move on.

If you don't know or cannot see heart in a hockey player.I'm not going to waste my time explaining it to you.Move on.

Avatar
#47 Johnny Larue
November 09 2013, 12:33AM
Trash it!
14
trashes
Cheers
10
cheers

Better than a kick in the ass

Avatar
#48 BingBong
November 09 2013, 05:21AM
Trash it!
6
trashes
Cheers
10
cheers

The trade is nothing more than a salary dump. I liked Smid's effort, but he was weak last year and has been worse this year. He'd be a 7th d-man on a good team. We have enough depth to cover it for this year, and it makes room for Klefbom next year.

The Bryz signing definitely comes off as desperate, but when you have the worst goaltending in the league I guess you gotta do something. It's only 1 year so it's low risk. He can't be worse than Dubnyk's been. At lease his interviews will be entertaining.

Avatar
#49 Serious Gord
November 09 2013, 06:59AM
Trash it!
3
trashes
Cheers
10
cheers

Judging by most of the posts above MacT/Lowe/Katz aren't the only ones feeling desperate.

The quest is the cup. How do these moves advance that pursuit?

Avatar
#50 Chaz
November 09 2013, 07:30AM
Trash it!
4
trashes
Cheers
9
cheers

Another obvious example of terrible upper management in Edmonton. Not only did they not adequately address the goal tending issue in the summer but then they do risky signings like Grebs which leaves them no room to sign a G during the year. Should not have had to of traded one of your regular D to bring in a G no one else would touch with a 10 foot pole. I know it's not spring, but please Katz time to clean house. The embarrassment continues! They've been trying to lose for so long to get top picks, that this all they know how to do now. At least Pocklington held people accountable. What a mess!

Comments are closed for this article.