Should the Edmonton Oilers claim Adam Hall off waivers?

Jonathan Willis
March 15 2013 11:09AM

Photo: Michael Miller/Wikimedia

On Friday, the Tampa Bay Lightning placed 585-game NHL veteran Adam Hall on waivers. The 6’3”, 213 pound centre is a guy who in a lot of ways would look pretty good centering the Oilers’ fourth line right now. Should the team claim him?

Pros

There are definite positives to adding Hall to the roster.

Faceoffs. Hall has won 56.4% of his faceoffs this season, 59.5% of his faceoffs last season, and 55.0% of his draws the year before that. He’s also a right-handed faceoff man, where both Shawn Horcoff and Eric Belanger are lefties – he would give the Oilers their only reliable right-shooting faceoff taker (right now Sam Gagner’s basically the choice by default in that role, and he’s less than ideal for it).

Penalty killing. Hall has been the Lightning’s most-used penalty-killer in each of the last two seasons, though he’s dropped to second this year. He’s not a guy like Mike Brown, who has been used in the role in the past from time to time – he’s a specialist who gets leaned on heavily in it.

Defensive zone work. Hall’s coaches have not hesitated to use him in his own end of the rink. This year at even-strength, for example, he’s been on the ice for 13 draws in the opposition zone on 5-on-5 – and 98 in his own end. Previous years haven’t been as ludicrous, but they’ve been heavily weighted towards the defensive zone.

Physical game. Hall is big, hits regularly, and drops the gloves once or twice per year.

Versatility. Hall plays both centre and right wing.

Contract. Hall is on a one-year deal that pays him $650,000. He’s dirt cheap, and low-risk.

Cons

There are some negatives, too, some of them associated with the player and some of them associated with the team.

The 50-man list. The Oilers have 51 men under contract, 49 of them on deals that count against the NHL’s 50-contract limit this season. They’re already painfully inflexible, and adding Hall will push them to the limit.

This year’s shot metrics. It’s perhaps unsurprising, given his radically defensive-oriented start, but the Lightning have been getting dominated with Hall on the ice at even-strength. Of interest, here, is the fact that a) in previous years, Hall hasn’t been getting hammered like this and b) it’s a lack of offence, rather than poor defence. Hall’s shots for are very low but his shots against rate is roughly average with the rest of the team. So while this is technically a negative, I’d argue it’s a long way from damning.

Offence. As hinted at in the last point, Hall’s offensive numbers leave much to be desired. He has no goals and four assists in 20 games this season, and had just seven points last year. Interestingly, he has had more success in the past – in a three-year stretch with Nashville he scored he scored 43 goals – but he’s not going to be a guy who drives offensive results.

My Take

Remember back when Shawn Horcoff and Eric Belanger were hurt and the Oilers were running Chris VandeVelde as their fourth line centre? This is the guy the team should have had in the job. Judging by the fact that he’s on waivers now, he couldn’t have been all that expensive – and inserting an honest-to-goodness faceoff guy, penalty killer and useful hockey player into the centre position would have been a very good idea. The team’s refusal to address the problem and instead do things like ‘play Ryan Smyth in the middle’ and was baffling at the time and baffling in retrospect.

In a perfect world, the team would have traded for this guy a month ago, sending away something small – say a fringe prospect like Alex Plante (or for that matter Chris VandeVelde) for the player. Assuming Hall clears, he will earn $650,000 in the AHL. A guy like Plante earns $65,000; VandeVelde $62,500. Maybe Tampa Bay has some elaborate plan to fetch a better return if Hall clears waivers, but it seems unlikely that there’s a long list of teams lining up to pay a guy six figures to be in the minors.

In a less-than-perfect world, the Oilers would have sent out a contract in a trade yesterday, before the Lightning put Hall on waivers. They really need to move a contract if they want to bring this guy in.

Because of the contract limit, I would understand if the Oilers chose not to make a waiver claim. But based on his history, Adam Hall is a better NHL player than Lennart Petrell, and he fits team need in a way that none of the Oilers’ umpteen wingers do: by playing centre. With all due respect to Ryan Smyth, the Oilers are a better team with him on the wing and actual centre at centre on the fourth line.

This is exactly the kind of guy the Oilers could have used as a 13th or 14th forward while they were out signing Darcy Hordichuk and Lennart Petrell to new contracts this summer. He’s exactly the kind of guy who would have been really handy when the great centre plague of 2013 struck the team. Now, he’s arguably less important, given where the Oilers are in the standings, but he would probably still make them a better team.

Recently around the Nation Network

74b7cedc5d8bfbe88cf071309e98d2c3
Jonathan Willis is a freelance writer. He currently works for Oilers Nation, the Edmonton Journal and Bleacher Report. He's co-written three books and worked for myriad websites, including Grantland, ESPN, The Score, and Hockey Prospectus. He was previously the founder and managing editor of Copper & Blue.
Avatar
#101 Walter Sobchak
March 15 2013, 04:38PM
Trash it!
0
trashes
+1
0
props

@Quicksilver ballet

^ This is why the Oilers don't pick up Hall.

This is why we suffer through watching AHL player on an NHL team.

This is why we come to Oilersnation, because our wives and girlfriends can't stand our obsessive bitching anymore.

This is why I think the Oilers might only move a player or two at the deadline, and the player in return wont upgrade the team.

Avatar
#102 Ducey
March 15 2013, 05:00PM
Trash it!
0
trashes
+1
0
props
bdiddy18 wrote:

If Belanger was done for the season then I would see doing this waiver wire pickup.

However Belanger should not be that far away and then he plays 4th Line centre. Smyty goes back to wing.

Exactly.

You have:

Hall-Horc-Hemsky MPS-Gags-Yak Hartikanen (or Jones or Smyth)-Nuge-Ebs Brown- Belanger- (Jones,Smyth, Petrell, Hartikanen)

A. Hall doesn't add much if anything. Certainly not enough to waste your last contract on him.

Avatar
#103 Jasmine
March 15 2013, 05:47PM
Trash it!
0
trashes
+1
0
props
Walter Sobchak wrote:

^ This is why the Oilers don't pick up Hall.

This is why we suffer through watching AHL player on an NHL team.

This is why we come to Oilersnation, because our wives and girlfriends can't stand our obsessive bitching anymore.

This is why I think the Oilers might only move a player or two at the deadline, and the player in return wont upgrade the team.

And this is why Oilers have trouble luring UFAs. They get run out by so-called Oilers fans before they get here. Remember the Brown traded was criticized when the team made the trade.

Avatar
#104 Saytalk
March 15 2013, 06:09PM
Trash it!
0
trashes
+1
0
props

When each team has to operate under a salary cap limit, a roster limit and a contract limit, you can see how a player can quickly go from being an asset to a liability. That's why players clear waivers, that's why players are bought out (even with the cap penalty), and that's why you can't even give some players away.

I like the idea of getting a big checking centre that can win faceoffs, and getting him for free off of waivers makes it even better, but Adam Hall would be a low-value asset on a team over-burdened with too many liabilities (Belanger, Eager, Petrell, Khabibulin, Whitney, Plante, etc.). Looking back, I have to question why management claimed Niko Hovinen off of waivers, but I guess that was before acquiring Brown so the contract situation looked better back then (but still, Hovinen?). With any luck, management can deal one of these guys for a conditional 7th rounder before Hall clears waivers, but I doubt they could find a taker.

Looking longer term, the Oilers should look at signing a guy like Adam Hall next year. When all of the lottery picks start resigning for $6M per year, we'll need to find role players making $600K to stay under the cap.

Avatar
#105 gazmort
March 15 2013, 07:12PM
Trash it!
0
trashes
+1
0
props

@Romulus' Apotheosis

Haha I understand it just fine. It was a double entendre. Literally giving away a future farm team player (ie. Farm) as well as an overpay (lowercase farm).

In any case, I still disagree it was an overpay, but your point about the market value of the picks is fair.

Avatar
#106 Romulus' Apotheosis
March 15 2013, 07:48PM
Trash it!
0
trashes
+1
0
props

@gazmort

no worries. I'd rather argue over whether this move makes sense than if my stupid cliche does anyway :)

to me the move represents the kind of mind rot at work in the org.

first they decide they need toughness on 4th. they sign Petrell, Eager and Hordichuk.

3 not great hockey players.

It takes them way too long to realize 2 of those contracts are worthless. They waive Eager and Hordichuk.

Meanwhile, we have gapping holes at C, D and G.

Instead of helping out there. ST and KL again decide the 4th line needs toughness.

They put in a claim on Volpatti. lose They don't put in a claim on Sestito (who is basically the same player). They give up a 4th for Brown.

reminds one of this:

http://chamberofcomics.blogspot.ca/2010/02/mikes-3-of-15.html

To me this reeks of

1) identifying the wrong problems 2) bungling the very problems they identify

none of it speaks well of mgt.

Comments are closed for this article.