BRYZGALOV AND SCRIVENS: TANDEM?

Robin Brownlee
February 04 2014 06:18PM

The Edmonton Oilers could start next season with Ben Scrivens and Ilya Bryzgalov as their goaltenders. They could wind up with neither of them. Split it down the middle, and they'll end up with one or the other.

The uncertainty in the goal crease, of course, is because Scrivens and Bryzgalov are pending unrestricted free agents and will be free to sign wherever they choose after considering their options (or lack of same) on the UFA checklist – money, an opportunity to play, the chance to win, lifestyle.

It's a dicey situation for GM Craig MacTavish because of the uncertainty that comes with the UFA wildcard and because he's dealing with two distinctly different players at different points in their careers, not to mention a whole bunch of questions regarding both of them.

Big-name hunting via trade or free agency notwithstanding -- and not having to figure out the answers to those questions from the comfort of my armchair -- I wouldn't mind seeing both of them back in 2014-15.

ABOUT BEN . . .

At 27, Scrivens is at a point in his career where he has to establish himself as a bonafide NHL starter or risk fading into the ranks of career back-ups, who don't get the money or the marquee time starters do. He's getting that chance now after stops in Toronto and Los Angeles and has so far made the most of it.

In five games behind the NHL's most porous defensive corps, Scrivens has fashioned a .944 saves-percentage and a 2.21 goals-against average, including a record 59-save shutout. He's likely already got MacTavish and boss Kevin Lowe bouncing contract numbers off each other. What would it take?

Unless the wheels fall right off, Scrivens is looking at a substantial raise from the $625,000 he'll earn this season. How much of a raise and how much term is the question. Another question, will Scrivens want to earn that money and get that term here or elsewhere? What's out there?

Even if Scrivens falls off that gaudy .944, which is likely, he and agent Jay Fee will have options. While it's likely Scrivens will command an overpay here because the Oilers are devoid of blue-chip goaltending prospects, what about opportunity to win, what about lifestyle?

THEN, THERE'S BRYZ

I wasn't big on signing Bryzgalov – I think I called him a kook – but he's looked decent through 18 appearances behind that horrid Edmonton defensive group for a guy whose phone didn’t ring until the Oilers came calling. He's .907 with a 3.15 GAA.

If Bryzgalov, 33, has been any kind of distraction around the dressing room, which was a knock on him in Philadelphia, where the Flyers paid him millions to just go away, I haven’t read or heard anything about it.

Bryzgalov has made more than $35 million playing goal in the NHL during his career, but if he wants to keep playing, at least in this league, he can't afford any missteps. He's got more hockey behind him than in front of him. Stop pucks. Be a good teammate. Keep bizarre in check. So far, so good.

I don’t think there's another GM out there who sees Bryzgalov as a starter moving forward. Can he be happy taking a marginal pay cut on his $2 million salary as a back-up? If the answer is yes, will he and agent Ritch Winter be willing to talk about plying his trade here in that role for the team that saved him from a scrap heap?

IS IT A FIT?

Scrivens has just 56 career NHL games in the books, so there's risk when it comes to paying him like a proven starter. Of course, that applies to other GMs who might be interested as well. Even if he gets the bulk of the work the rest of the way, Scrivens will have played less than 75 NHL games when it's time to talk money.

The high-water mark for Scrivens in terms of games played in a season as a pro is 51 (he played 39 with the AHL Marlies and 12 with the Maple Leafs in 2011-12). I'm not saying he can't play more than that, only that he hasn't.

That's where I see a fit as back-up for Bryzgalov, who looks more capable of playing 20-25 games a season than Nikolai Khabibulin was when he arrived in town older and injury-prone -- with a sweet four-year deal from Steve Tambellini in his back pocket.

We'll hear bigger names than Scrivens or Bryzgalov thrown around as potential targets for MacTavish this off-season, and that's understandable, but I think they could work as a tandem. The caveat, of course, is that MacTavish does something about the defensive group playing in front of whoever is tending the twine.

That's an item that's already been written countless times and will be again.

Listen to Robin Brownlee Wednesdays and Thursdays from 3 p.m. to 5 p.m. on the Jason Gregor Show on TEAM 1260.

Aceb4a1816f5fa09879a023b07d1a9b4
A sports writer since 1983, including stints at The Edmonton Journal and The Sun 1989-2007, I happily co-host the Jason Gregor Show on TSN 1260 twice a week and write when so inclined. Have the best damn lawn on the internet. Most important, I am Sam's dad. Follow me on Twitter at Robin_Brownlee. Or don't.
Avatar
#51 Oasis
February 05 2014, 09:53AM
Trash it!
1
trashes
Cheers
1
cheers
slats wrote:

On the first question would the Oilers be fine with BryzScrivens? On Scrivens I say the answer is yes 2.50 GAA and 920 SV% for his NHL body of work. Albeit some portion with the stingy Kings but also big piece with the shot-happy Leafs.

Bryz? I think he will or should be traded at deadline. Why because someone will need depth and they will lose one goalie to injury and he is leaving Edmonton is my guess regardless. I also think he does not add anything. Room guy? All we say is I hope he doesn't go "whacko". Mentor? Maybe but there are better.

Second question though is the tough one - How much? Scrivens has only 124 nhl games! To me that spells short term deal, otherwise we are rewarding a UFA with no substance and a 1 game 59 shot SO. We already overpaid one of our forwards for a 1 game performance let's not do it again.

Lets not forget that we also overpaid a bunch of players after the Cup run too. I wouldn't be the least surprised if the Oilers did it again.

Avatar
#52 Robin Brownlee
February 05 2014, 10:13AM
Trash it!
1
trashes
Cheers
18
cheers
Darrell wrote:

Robin, This site reminds me of the sh!tshow Oiler organization that owns our hockey hearts. Oiler hater DSF dicks around this site pissing me and other Oilers fans off and we beg for a ban. I now read you're picking on Gino's so called buddies who is an Oilers fan because he hurt your feelings. Ever been a coach or GM as you have all the right traits to take this gong show to a new level ....

"Hurt my feelings?" No.

Did you read the posts that got "Josh Oiler" blocked? No, you didn't as they were removed within minutes of being posted.

Nobody, including "Josh Oiler" gets to make homophobic remarks here or suggest that anybody who calls him out for stupid remarks -- as one poster did -- is "licking Brownlee's balls."

If DSF or anybody else does that they're gone, and gone for good, too -- if that's OK with you.

Avatar
#53 Sal-Sational
February 05 2014, 10:19AM
Trash it!
1
trashes
Cheers
0
cheers

Agreed.. Sign em both!!

Avatar
#54 Tikkanese
February 05 2014, 12:28PM
Trash it!
1
trashes
Cheers
0
cheers

.

Avatar
#55 Air on Egg blood
February 04 2014, 10:27PM
Trash it!
0
trashes
Cheers
23
cheers

I wonder what our season would've looked like if MacT had signed Khudobin instead of Labarbera last summer. He was younger and had been groomed in the Bruins organisation, one of the best. And he signed for dirt cheap too. Just sayin'.

Avatar
#56 slats
February 04 2014, 10:57PM
Trash it!
0
trashes
Cheers
10
cheers

On the first question would the Oilers be fine with BryzScrivens? On Scrivens I say the answer is yes 2.50 GAA and 920 SV% for his NHL body of work. Albeit some portion with the stingy Kings but also big piece with the shot-happy Leafs.

Bryz? I think he will or should be traded at deadline. Why because someone will need depth and they will lose one goalie to injury and he is leaving Edmonton is my guess regardless. I also think he does not add anything. Room guy? All we say is I hope he doesn't go "whacko". Mentor? Maybe but there are better.

Second question though is the tough one - How much? Scrivens has only 124 nhl games! To me that spells short term deal, otherwise we are rewarding a UFA with no substance and a 1 game 59 shot SO. We already overpaid one of our forwards for a 1 game performance let's not do it again.

Avatar
#57 dougtheslug
February 04 2014, 11:18PM
Trash it!
0
trashes
Cheers
6
cheers
srelio wrote:

Anyone know what happened to ty rimmer? During the preseason he looked good and i havent heard much about him since then, not even in prospect articles. I think he signed an AHL contract here but its hard to tell since no one ever mentions him.

Playing for the Quad City Mallards of the Central Hockey League. 9-9-4 record, 2.79 GGA, ).912 save percentage

Avatar
#58 james_dean
February 04 2014, 11:30PM
Trash it!
0
trashes
Cheers
2
cheers
Rod from Viking wrote:

Josh, do you have the "Kenny Powers" like doo that Geno is trying to sport now as well? If you are his friend please tell him to get a new pun writer and a hair cut. Also see if he can have a cab driver run over Harry & Lloyd(Louie&Kevin) on the next road trip.

Louie debrusk vs 4 men and a taxi = Win

Avatar
#59 dougtheslug
February 04 2014, 11:31PM
Trash it!
0
trashes
Cheers
38
cheers

Here's an interesting thing to consider. Assume Scrivens and Bryz had been playing for the Oil from the beginning of the season, and hypothetically, had been playing as well as they have played over the time they have been the Oilers tandem.

Assume, then, they win the 5 or 6 games that Duby and Labarbera alone cost them. Assume, as well that they win by themselves 4 or 5 more games (which isn't a stretch, seeing as how they have arguably won 3 or 4 already by themselves).

That's an 18-22 point swing in the standings, which would put the Oil squarely in the playoff race.

Now here is the problem. Would that have papered over the horrific problems in all aspects of the Oilers game, and convinced management they were on the right track?

I'm hearing Stauffer crowing that the Oilers have won 4 of 5. But does any sane Oiler fan believe the ship is righted? Amazing what a mirage good goaltending can create.

Avatar
#60 Westcoastoil
February 05 2014, 12:22AM
Trash it!
0
trashes
Cheers
24
cheers
Serious Gord wrote:

It's being reported that he is waiving his NTC.

I have no strong opinion either way. He's not cheap. In light of his injury prone ness he's been terrible value for the canes. If they would eat some if his contract or they would take one of the oilers loser contracts (gagner?) back perhaps it would make sense. As I understand it however the goalie market should be pretty good this summer.

I'd be terrified of bringing in Cam Ward - I think he's ridden the Conn Smyth and a weak division for years. It would be be Khabby v.2.0

Scrivens is a much better bet.

Avatar
#61 Mason Storm
February 05 2014, 01:06AM
Trash it!
0
trashes
Cheers
7
cheers
dougtheslug wrote:

Here's an interesting thing to consider. Assume Scrivens and Bryz had been playing for the Oil from the beginning of the season, and hypothetically, had been playing as well as they have played over the time they have been the Oilers tandem.

Assume, then, they win the 5 or 6 games that Duby and Labarbera alone cost them. Assume, as well that they win by themselves 4 or 5 more games (which isn't a stretch, seeing as how they have arguably won 3 or 4 already by themselves).

That's an 18-22 point swing in the standings, which would put the Oil squarely in the playoff race.

Now here is the problem. Would that have papered over the horrific problems in all aspects of the Oilers game, and convinced management they were on the right track?

I'm hearing Stauffer crowing that the Oilers have won 4 of 5. But does any sane Oiler fan believe the ship is righted? Amazing what a mirage good goaltending can create.

If we are not careful. We'll start sounding like Leafs fans. They've had poor shot differential and puck possession numbers for years, but a great save percentage and they are planning a parade with every 3-4 game win streak.

Avatar
#62 Fresh Mess
February 05 2014, 07:27AM
Trash it!
0
trashes
Cheers
6
cheers
Mason Storm wrote:

If we are not careful. We'll start sounding like Leafs fans. They've had poor shot differential and puck possession numbers for years, but a great save percentage and they are planning a parade with every 3-4 game win streak.

Too late. Hit that point a couple years ago.

Avatar
#63 K_Mart
February 05 2014, 07:29AM
Trash it!
0
trashes
Cheers
2
cheers
Josh Oiler wrote:

Besides.. If in Craig McTavish (best GM I the NHL) I would wait till Scrivens has a bad game.. Get Dallas Eakins to pull his ass out I the net.. Next day give him an offer of $990,000per at maybe 2 years and call it a day.

And if "The Professor" and his so called entourage reject it.. Let the man walk in the off season.

He's a career backup. Plain and simple!

Let's call a spade a spade!

Anything more than that and I will personally call for Mac Ts head!

Nobody knows what Scrivens is. All throughout his time in the NHL he's put up numbers that are equal to that of the top 15 starters in the league. The only reason he hasn't solidified himself as a starter is his number of games played. It's not easy to take a gamble on a guy who's only played a total of what 55+ games in the nhl?

Let's wait and see...

Avatar
#64 S cottV
February 05 2014, 08:29AM
Trash it!
0
trashes
Cheers
5
cheers

If somehow MacT can come up with 2 vet d men for the first rotations and a 2C, then go for a home run on an unquestioned top goaltender.

Otherwise - if we have to wait for development on the d corps, don't waste the money and go with Scrivens, at more reasonable cost.

If we can get Bryz - as well at 1b money, go for it.

Anyone that can deliver better than .905 with Oiler systems, can play the position.

Avatar
#65 Dave
February 05 2014, 08:37AM
Trash it!
0
trashes
Cheers
16
cheers

"where the Flyers paid him millions to just go away"

A lot of people have been remembering the Bryzgalov story this way, but I feel like that is kind of a spin that was put on it after the fact. The way I remember it Philly was a team that liked to be in on every single big deal and grossly overpaid for a goalie that was benefiting from a solid Dave Tippet defense in Phoenix. He didn't solve all of Philly's problems instantly like they hoped (Philly is tough on goalies) and then they had a huge contract they had to dump. All of this stuff like "He was a distraction" still seems like garbage. As far as goalies go he's almost normal.

Avatar
#66 Oasis
February 05 2014, 10:08AM
Trash it!
0
trashes
Cheers
2
cheers
camdog wrote:

I can't see Bryzgalof sticking around in E-town as a back up. He wants to be a starter, if he's going to stick around as a back up it won't be here.

As for Scrivens he's a UFA. I hope he's not a Brian Burke guy, some players have a sense of loyalty towards Burkie, they need a goalie as well. If DD signed for 3.5 a few years back, can't see Scrivens getting less than 4.

His time as a starter has come and gone. The only was he is starting anywhere is by default (injury). If he thinks he is signing anywhere to be a starter then he really is crazy.

Avatar
#67 S cottV
February 05 2014, 10:11AM
Trash it!
0
trashes
Cheers
1
cheers
Sisyphus wrote:

What makes you think Scrivens will be willing to sign in Edmonton for a "reasonable cost"? If he keeps playing like he has been, he'll have other offers. Its going to take more than being the starter to keep him here. Oilers will either have to overpay to keep him here (and even that might not be enough to get him to stay behind this mess), or they'll have to hope he starts to tank, making him more affordable and more likely to stay here (at which point--do you really want to sign him anyways)?

Scrivens is not an unquestioned #1, so I would assume the price point to acquire him would be a step down and represent reasonable cost and less term.

Still expensive and a risk but MacT better have someone between the pipes nailed down.

Without the d corp ready to deliver, don't jump in at unquestioned #1 money and term.

Avatar
#68 tileguy
February 05 2014, 10:28AM
Trash it!
0
trashes
Cheers
0
cheers
Sal-Sational wrote:

Agreed.. Sign em both!!

Yes we can sign them both on one year contracts but it will cost us, I bet in the neighborhood of $5.5 mil.

Avatar
#69 camdog
February 05 2014, 10:40AM
Trash it!
0
trashes
Cheers
0
cheers
Oasis wrote:

His time as a starter has come and gone. The only was he is starting anywhere is by default (injury). If he thinks he is signing anywhere to be a starter then he really is crazy.

I think we are saying the same thing. He came to Edmonton to be the default starter as DD played so bad to start the season. He didn't come here to be a back up. If he's going to be a back up goalie, it isn't going to be in Edmonton.

Avatar
#70 Tikkanese
February 05 2014, 11:28AM
Trash it!
0
trashes
Cheers
0
cheers
Air on Egg blood wrote:

I wonder what our season would've looked like if MacT had signed Khudobin instead of Labarbera last summer. He was younger and had been groomed in the Bruins organisation, one of the best. And he signed for dirt cheap too. Just sayin'.

I and many others said Khudobin should have been the prime target for the Oilers.

But if that happened, we would have missed MacT's only bold move of signing Bryz. It may or may not have worked out, but it was pretty bold given his off ice history.

Avatar
#71 yegCopywriter
February 05 2014, 11:35AM
Trash it!
0
trashes
Cheers
2
cheers

Surprised people are comparing Scrivens' upcoming contract to Dubnyk's last one.

Dubnyk had transitioned into a #1 goalie with a .500 record on a bad team and stats that put him at the middle of the pack of NHL starters. At the time, most people were guessing around $3M/year for 3 years and he got $3.5M/year for 2 years.

While Scrivens' stats are excellent in a small sample size this year, he has yet to be a starter. He could probably seek out "1B" money and term—something like $2M/year for 3 years—a very healthy raise over $625,000/year.

Avatar
#72 Tikkanese
February 05 2014, 11:56AM
Trash it!
0
trashes
Cheers
1
cheers

I'm seeing some hate for Debrusk on this board. Am I the only one that likes him? It might be the stink of Kevin Quinn that taints Debrusk somewhat to you guys. Compared to Peplinski and all the other horrible color guys we've had in the past, Debrusk is great.

It could be worse though guys. Think Rob Kerr and Charlie Simmer.

The dream team would be if we could steal Mike Emrick from NBC and Ray Ferraro from TSN for Oiler broadcasts. Make that happen, Katz.

Avatar
#73 camdog
February 05 2014, 12:43PM
Trash it!
0
trashes
Cheers
0
cheers
yegCopywriter wrote:

Surprised people are comparing Scrivens' upcoming contract to Dubnyk's last one.

Dubnyk had transitioned into a #1 goalie with a .500 record on a bad team and stats that put him at the middle of the pack of NHL starters. At the time, most people were guessing around $3M/year for 3 years and he got $3.5M/year for 2 years.

While Scrivens' stats are excellent in a small sample size this year, he has yet to be a starter. He could probably seek out "1B" money and term—something like $2M/year for 3 years—a very healthy raise over $625,000/year.

Ya you might be right on that. My thinking was that the cap had just gone up. Seeing as the Oilers gave DD about 1 million per season more than he was worth at the time and our contracts division hasn't changed in a number of years, I'm sort of expecting an over pay.

Avatar
#74 loweblows
February 05 2014, 01:53PM
Trash it!
0
trashes
Cheers
2
cheers

In the spirit of Robins latest post regarding Josh Oiler, to be less offensive I will furthermore be known as Bi Poiler. And I still don't like Eakins regardless of name.

Avatar
#75 Taylor Gang
February 05 2014, 02:02PM
Trash it!
0
trashes
Cheers
1
cheers
Tikkanese wrote:

I'm seeing some hate for Debrusk on this board. Am I the only one that likes him? It might be the stink of Kevin Quinn that taints Debrusk somewhat to you guys. Compared to Peplinski and all the other horrible color guys we've had in the past, Debrusk is great.

It could be worse though guys. Think Rob Kerr and Charlie Simmer.

The dream team would be if we could steal Mike Emrick from NBC and Ray Ferraro from TSN for Oiler broadcasts. Make that happen, Katz.

Ferraro used to work for SN with Kevin.

Avatar
#76 MessyEH
February 05 2014, 03:48PM
Trash it!
0
trashes
Cheers
0
cheers
loweblows wrote:

In the spirit of Robins latest post regarding Josh Oiler, to be less offensive I will furthermore be known as Bi Poiler. And I still don't like Eakins regardless of name.

BiPoiler is an awesome name. Ups and downs. Mostly down. .

.

.

. ..

.

.

.

.

.Way Down.

Avatar
#77 Spydyr
February 05 2014, 07:27PM
Trash it!
0
trashes
Cheers
0
cheers

So what will it cost to sign Scrivens three million for him ,two million for his wife to stay?

Avatar
#78 Darrell
February 06 2014, 04:44AM
Trash it!
0
trashes
Cheers
0
cheers
Robin Brownlee wrote:

"Hurt my feelings?" No.

Did you read the posts that got "Josh Oiler" blocked? No, you didn't as they were removed within minutes of being posted.

Nobody, including "Josh Oiler" gets to make homophobic remarks here or suggest that anybody who calls him out for stupid remarks -- as one poster did -- is "licking Brownlee's balls."

If DSF or anybody else does that they're gone, and gone for good, too -- if that's OK with you.

I apologize as there was more to the story - Keep up the good work and don't put up with any anti-Oiler sh!t from DSF if you don't mind me asking.

Avatar
#79 Spydyr
February 06 2014, 04:49AM
Trash it!
0
trashes
Cheers
0
cheers

Everyone has their own views. Some will differ from yours.That does not make them as you so elegantly put it $hit.

Chill and enjoy the discussion.

Avatar
#80 YakSaitl
February 06 2014, 09:37AM
Trash it!
0
trashes
Cheers
1
cheers

I would rather like a tandem with Scrivens and one of Anaheims goalies! They have 4 (!!!) very good goalies in Hiller, Andersen, Fasth and Gibson.

Comments are closed for this article.