Monday Mailbag - May 12th

baggedmilk
May 12 2014 12:30PM

Spam

It's your favourite time of the week! The mailbag is back with the answers to all the questions you've always been wondering about.  If you want to submit a question, just email it to me at baggedmilk@oilersnation.com or hit me up on Twitter.  As a thank you, I'll send everyone that submits a question a sticker package from the Nation.  Questions don't all have to be Oilers related, so be creative.

It's your time to shine, Nation. Enjoy.

Screen Shot 2014-05-12 at 10.04.26 AM

1) @CraigSmallwood1 asks - The Oilers have missed the playoffs for 8 straight seasons.  6 of those have been since Daryl Katz has owned them.  Has the ownership change factored into the teams struggles or is that purely coincidental?

Jonathan Willis

I don't think it's been the deciding factor, but it has certainly been a factor. Katz has the authority to remove Kevin Lowe, and had the authority to remove Steve Tambellini much earlier in the process. He has not in the case of the former and did not in the case of the latter.

Lowetide

In about January 2010, Mr. Katz suggested a rebuild. He's a business man, and so went about the work of looking long term. The problem is that rebuild needs to have an endgame, and Steve Tambellini didn't have the vision to see his role in the process. You can't just collect assets, they need to have form and support. We are here. MacTavish's arrival as GM is late in the game, but I suspect not too late for a successful rebuild.

Jason Strudwick

The owner is the top of the food chain. They get some of the credit or negativity depending on their teams results. I think it is just a coincidence. As a player on the team when he bought it I can say he treated the team very well.

Jason Gregor

He has been a part of it. If he could take his negotiations skills from getting a new rink and put them into negotiating building a winning team that would be great, however, they are very different skill sets.

Brian Sutherby

New ownership allowed the team to spend more money so you would think the on ice product would improve. Poor management choices, poor player development in my opinion and the Yakupov pick (Katz pick) if true, is a scary thing. Maybe they were headed in this direction with or without him but the owner is in charge of putting the right people in place to make these decisions.

baggedmilk

One thing I miss about EIG was their ability to not threaten to move the team to Seattle. That was cool... *remembers*

BrandonDubinsky

2) Taylor Smith asks - To me, Brandon Dubinsky is the ideal player for the Oilers second line centre. Do the Oilers have anything the Jackets would want for Dubinsky? He played first line minutes for CBJ in the playoffs, so it’s probably a pipe dream to see him in Edmonton. Do you think there are any other Dubinsky-types that the Oilers could target for the 2C role?

Jonathan Willis

Everything I've read out of Columbus suggests that Dubinsky is considered a core piece. The Oilers might have better luck with Artem Anisimov if they're shopping for help from the Blue Jackets.

Lowetide

I like your suggestion, and suspect that CBJ will be a target team. Young Willis had something up on this recently. As for other targets, I like Paul Stastny and the Russian Grabovski. 

Jason Strudwick

I always liked Dubinsky as a player. He is very aggressive and just cocky enough to not care who he runs over. I don't think he would be a player they would trade. Could Mike Richards be a guy?

Jason Gregor

What do the Oilers have to offer that they would be willing to trade to acquire Dubinsky? CBJ loves Dubinsky, I don’t see him being moved. There aren’t many players like Dubinsky, so I don’t see a trade happening for a 2C who is physical and skilled. I doubt Kesler would waive NMC to come here.

Brian Sutherby

I agree with you that is the type of player they need in the 2-hole. Guys that play big minutes and have an edge don't grow on trees, often you have to find these guys in the draft.

baggedmilk

I think Brandon Dubinsky would be awesome in an Oilers uni, but there's no way CBJ is giving a guy like that up without costing a fortune.  The problem with talking about hypothetical trades is that we're only setting ourselves up for disappointment.  If anything, I expect the Oilers to back the Brinks truck up for Paul Statsny this summer. Whether he would even sign here is another story.

Yakupov

3) Sevenseven asks - Anton Belov left to go sign in the KHL. More money, less games, and playing in his home country. Do the oilers worry about Yakupov doing the same thing after next season? Should they be working to sign him during the season? Trade him? How can they prevent losing him for nothing?

Jonathan Willis

In his public interviews Yakupov has consistently maintained that his goal is to play in the NHL. If he's saying the same things privately, I don't know that this is really a concern.

Lowetide

Nah. Nail Yakupov's brain doesn't work like that, I expect. A huge tell was Larionov asking for a trade. Yak City isn't wired to run from the problem.

Jason Strudwick

The KHL is a very real competitor for the NHL when is comes to Russian players. The money they make at home is way more then they would make in the NHL and they are at home. As a player who played 3 different times in Europe I can understand how much easier it is to be in your own country. Do I think Yak would leave the Oilers after next year? Anything is possible. The Oilers want to build his game and the entire teams game so that he is excited about the future here in Edmonton. That is true for all players on the team though, except I don't think North Americans look at the KHL the same way as Yakupov might.

Jason Gregor

The KHL is a factor when players don’t have contracts, but Yakupov has said many times he wants to play in the NHL. They would trade him before he goes back to KHL, but I don’t see him going home right away. I suspect he will get a new deal before the end of next season, but there is no major rush. I don’t see him in the same boat at Belov.

Brian Sutherby

Put him in the best possible situations to succeed. The problem is, it may cost you wins and do people want to start winning or to continue the rebuild next year? He doesn't deserve to be on the first line in my opinion and maybe even the second, but because he was rushed to the NHL you have no choice. He's supposed to be an offensive player so he needs to get offensive minutes, even if he doesn't deserve them. You need to coddle this player now and build him back up.

You can't trade him now and get any value, you have to ride him out. To me Yakupov came over in Junior so he could play in the NHL. It's an obvious concern given Kovalchuk recently, but I have to believe he wants to play in the NHL.

baggedmilk

How dare you even suggest my beloved Yakupov would commit such a heinous act?  I think he's in for a bounce back year and all the haters will be scrambling to delete tweets where they wanted him traded.

WhoAmI

4) Jonathan Milroy asks - What team identity do you think will MacT & Eakins are building towards? (ex: 2 way hockey club, or a lunch bucket group, a puck possession minded team, defence first, high flying offence, etc.) Does it look like they even have a plan?

Jonathan Willis

The comments I've heard from both suggest that they see the Oilers evolving into a puck possession team. But I'd also argue that "identity", like "culture" gets overused: the secret here is to have good players and employ them in areas where they can succeed more than it is to have a single defining narrative for the team.

Lowetide

I think they're trying to go in a puck possession route, but remain convinced that enforcers are needed. A possession team needs an enforcer like a fish needs a bicycle.

Jason Strudwick

Mac T has a plan. Look at the players he has brought in during his time. I like all the additions. He is trying to at dependable players that compete. Getting more of these types of players will eliminate the ups and downs we saw from this team.

Jason Gregor

They want to be a possession team that attacks and is built on puck moving D-men. It helps when you have different types of players to play that style. You can’t have all the same size and types of players and expect to win.

Brian Sutherby 

It's obvious they want more grit and character sprinkled throughout the lineup. Other than that I have absolutely no idea. This team has no identity at the moment and until additions this summer, I couldn't even guess at what this teams identity is.

baggedmilk

I think they're going for the "Undo What Tambellini Did" identity.  I almost feel bad for MacT, because he took over a team with so many holes that it's nearly impossible to turn things around in less than another decade.  I look forward to another summer filled with MacT keywords - Grit, Character, Progress

MoMoney

5) BobbyCanuck123 asks - A friend and I are having an argument... He says free agents will be banging down the door to play for the Oilers because of the new arena and our collection of talented budding stars. I say, all free agents care about is one or a combo of the following: Stanley Cup contender/close to family/money... Who is right?

Jonathan Willis

I always get a kick out of people talking about the new arena the way they used to talk about the rebuild or the new CBA. The new arena is going to be a nice place to watch hockey, and it's going to make Daryl Katz piles and piles of money; I doubt very much it has a significant impact on team-building. As to the main thrust of your question: I don't think there's a blanket rule for free agents. Some like hockey markets and a depth chart that affords opportunity and coming back home to play (all of those favour the Oilers). Others like winning hockey games, playing in a major centre and enjoying mild winters (all of those favour other teams). It all depends on the individual.

Lowetide

I try not to talk a lot about the Glory Days, because it's a jerk thing to do in light of what young Oiler fans are experiencing. However, rest assured that when this team was really good, Edmonton had no troubles acquiring veterans (mostly via trade at that time). It'll happen again.

Jason Strudwick 

For top free agents the money will be the same everywhere pretty much, they want to go where they can play and win. For the remaining free agents money does play a part as does opportunity. If they have a family they may like to be closer to home for support. I truly believe ultimately the biggest factor will be opportunity to win.

Jason Gregor

The Oilers need to win, until that happens they won’t get many big name free agents, but very few winning teams are built around free agency. Much of your core has to come through the draft, and then you need to make some good trades, get a bit lucky and sign quality free agents. Look at this year’s free agents and in previous seasons, the best players rarely make it to free agency anymore. Free agents won’t solve the Oilers problems, and a new arena won’t be the reason players sign here. It won’t be in the top-5 of any player’s “must have” list. Winning is what matters, the rest, new rink, is white noise.

Brian Sutherby

No player cares about the rink one bit. If the young Oilers finished on the cusp of the playoffs this year and were trending up, players may want to be apart of that.

You are right here, just look at the Redwings.

baggedmilk

If what Sutherby and Strudwick are saying is true, and that free agents want to sign with a potential winner - we're screwed.  The Oiler are closer to finding Sasquatch than they are at being a contender. *cries*

94ea28cbbd0f9fe4153692bb3e38b40c
Twitter tyrant for @OilersNation - Resident Jackass - Poor vessel for carrying milk. Follow me on twitter (@jsbmbaggedmilk) - Instagram (@himynameisbaggedmilk) or email me at baggedmilk@oilersnation.com.
Avatar
#1 David S
May 12 2014, 12:39PM
Trash it!
6
trashes
Cheers
13
cheers

Baggedmilk's answers sing to me.

BTW BM, keep an eye out for my photoshop contest entry OK?

Avatar
#2 Sketchy
May 12 2014, 12:41PM
Trash it!
15
trashes
Cheers
9
cheers

I have a question for the writers: how hard is it to actually follow and write about this pathetic team? Do you ever wish you could follow a competent team

Avatar
#3 #ThereGoesTheOilers
May 12 2014, 12:41PM
Trash it!
1
trashes
Cheers
18
cheers

On the topic of UFAs and winning, Parise and and Suter signed for different reasons in Minnesota - certainly not a step up in wins over the Devils or Preds before they arrived.

If the wild have a chance, one has to think the Oil does too.

Avatar
#6 #ThereGoesTheOilers
May 12 2014, 12:44PM
Trash it!
0
trashes
Cheers
5
cheers
baggedmilk wrote:

I like your enthusiasm!

God it's hard to conjure up on a Monday.

Avatar
#7 vetinari
May 12 2014, 01:00PM
Trash it!
0
trashes
Cheers
19
cheers

Love the Monday Mailbag segments... keep them coming...

Avatar
#9 EP
May 12 2014, 01:10PM
Trash it!
0
trashes
Cheers
11
cheers

Winning cures all that ails.

Avatar
#11 Next up, is Connor McJesus.
May 12 2014, 01:45PM
Trash it!
20
trashes
Cheers
15
cheers

I can see Larionov using the KHL to separate his client Nail Yakupov from this Edmonton situation. Who would want to waste their time with incompetence so present from top to bottom. Lowe will tar and feather Nail just like he did with Sheldon Souray, and deny management of any responsibility again.

It's what a losing entrenched organization does. Deflect the blame away from the organization.

Avatar
#12 vetinari
May 12 2014, 01:47PM
Trash it!
2
trashes
Cheers
12
cheers
baggedmilk wrote:

I WILL IF YOU GUYS SEND ME MORE QUESTIONS!

Emailed some suggestions to you... such as "which vegetable does each contributor resemble the most?"

Avatar
#13 Really
May 12 2014, 02:22PM
Trash it!
3
trashes
Cheers
7
cheers
baggedmilk wrote:

Did you email it to me yet? I look forward to it!

Are you guys "special" BUDDIES?

Avatar
#15 David S
May 12 2014, 03:31PM
Trash it!
1
trashes
Cheers
2
cheers
Really wrote:

Are you guys "special" BUDDIES?

Nope. Just some good old fashioned contest pre-entry sucking up.

Avatar
#16 bagmilkisawesome
May 12 2014, 03:37PM
Trash it!
0
trashes
Cheers
7
cheers

Thanks guys. These are great reads on a long Monday.

Avatar
#17 David S
May 12 2014, 04:03PM
Trash it!
0
trashes
Cheers
5
cheers

OK, who let Baggedmilk's mom in here?

Avatar
#18 Lofty
May 12 2014, 04:55PM
Trash it!
4
trashes
Cheers
4
cheers

Struds,

Mike Richards on the Oilers? Why the hell would the Oil want to add another 5'11" center? They need more size!

Ben Bishop or reacquiring Dubnyk is the answer... They're both over 6'4". Much bigger than Bennett or Draisaitl. That will make them tougher to play against. END OF SARCASM

#everyoneunder75inchisuseless... they need competitors not inches or lbs.

2003 was a ridiculous draft year.

Avatar
#19 MessyEH
May 12 2014, 05:28PM
Trash it!
0
trashes
Cheers
6
cheers

baggedmilk

"If what Sutherby and Strudwick are saying is true, and that free agents want to sign with a potential winner - we're screwed.  The Oiler are closer to finding Sasquatch than they are at being a contender. *cries*"

If Sasquatch can take a face off, or play Defense. I am all for the Oilers offering him a contract. I'll even lend him my Copperalls.

Avatar
#21 Oiler Al
May 12 2014, 10:06PM
Trash it!
0
trashes
Cheers
5
cheers
baggedmilk wrote:

I like this idea. Sasquatch could be an integral part of this team for years to come!

Why is Penner coming back?

Avatar
#22 Matthew
May 13 2014, 12:25AM
Trash it!
0
trashes
Cheers
3
cheers
baggedmilk wrote:

I like this idea. Sasquatch could be an integral part of this team for years to come!

Hey watch what you say man, my prom date was a Saskwatch and she had a very sweet personality and was one heck of a big game hunter.

Avatar
#23 MessyEH
May 13 2014, 03:56AM
Trash it!
0
trashes
Cheers
0
cheers
Matthew wrote:

Hey watch what you say man, my prom date was a Saskwatch and she had a very sweet personality and was one heck of a big game hunter.

So...

Was she a good dancer? I hear the ice girls are hiring.

Avatar
#24 pelhem grenville
May 13 2014, 04:32AM
Trash it!
2
trashes
Cheers
0
cheers
baggedmilk wrote:

I WILL IF YOU GUYS SEND ME MORE QUESTIONS!

...~I must refuse to partake in this sham edition of Mailbag... bagged...no Brownlee!~

Avatar
#25 pelhem grenville
May 13 2014, 04:35AM
Trash it!
1
trashes
Cheers
0
cheers

...and while I'm on the subject ...how come you get all these new fangled pieces> game wrap-ups and mailbags & sh!t and we STILL HAVEN'T GOT A PHOTO GALLERY!!!!?????????

Comments are closed for this article.