How big a break did the Edmonton Oilers get by winning the lottery for the 2012 NHL Entry Draft and the right to make their third consecutive first overall pick by snatching it from the Columbus Blue Jackets? Very big.

At least that’s what the last 12 years of the Entry Draft tells us when we look at the last dozen players taken first overall compared to the last 12 players taken second, just one selection later, since 2000.

In 2011, the Oilers took Ryan Nugent-Hopkins with the first pick and he didn’t disappoint, scoring 18-34-52 despite missing 20 games with a shoulder injury. That left Nugent-Hopkins tied in scoring with Colorado’s Gabriel Landeskog, who had 22-30-52 in 82 games. Both are Calder Trophy finalists. Who got the better player? Too early to tell.

In 2010, the Oilers claimed two-time Memorial Cup MVP Taylor Hall with the first overall pick. Despite two seasons shortened by injury, the dynamic Hall has scored 49-46-95 in 126 games. Not a lot of argument Hall looks like a franchise cornerstone, if he can stay healthy.

The Boston Bruins, meanwhile, happily took Tyler Seguin with the second overall pick in 2010. After being brought along slowly as a rookie, Seguin completed his second season with 40-49-89 in 155 games. Who’ll have the better career? Again, it’s too early to know.

That said, when you look at the previous 10 years of the Entry Draft, the advantage of picking first overall compared to second is, to understate, significant, at least the way I see it.

While you’d have a great start on building a perennial Stanley Cup contender with either group of players taken with those two picks over the last decade, I know which group I’d go with.


Following are the players taken first overall since 2000 along with games played, goals, assists and points (or GP, career goals-against average and saves percentage for goaltenders).

2009 NYI John Tavares 243 84-118-202

2008 TB Steven Stamkos 325 179-150-329

2007 CHI Patrick Kane 399 126-243-369

2006 STL Erik Johnson 298 27-100-127

2005 PIT Sidney Crosby 434 223-386-609

2004 WSH Alex Ovechkin 553 339-340-679

2003 PIT Marc-Andre Fleury 434 2.68 .909

2002 CBJ Rick Nash 674 289-258-547

2001 ATL Ilya Kovalchuk 779 406-379-785

2000 Rick DiPietro 315 2.86 .903


2009 TB Victor Hedman 214 12-52-69

2008 LA Drew Doughty 316 43-119-162

2007 James VanRiemsdyk 196 47-52-99

2006 PIT Jordan Staal 431 120-128-248

2005 ANA Bobby Ryan 332 136-123-259

2004 PIT Evgeni Malkin 427 208-319-527

2003 CAR Eric Staal 642 250-324-574

2002 ATL Kari Lehtonen 344 2.71 .914

2001 OTT Jason Spezza 606 226-390-616

2000 ATL Dany Heatley 751 349-393-742


— Obviously, injuries, quality of teammates and opportunity factors heavily into the results of the players taken over the past decade, but, as a group, the first overall picks are clearly superior to the second picks 2000-2009, at least by the numbers and the impact they’ve had as NHL players.

— The way I see it, Jordan Staal (2006) and Dany Heatley (2000) are the only second picks who are clearly superior to the players taken first overall in their respective draft years: Johnson (2006) and DiPietro (2000).

— Does the last decade of the draft mean the Oilers will select the player who goes on to have the best career this June with their third consecutive first overall pick? Not necessarily, but probably.

Listen to Robin Brownlee Wednesdays and Thursdays from 3 p.m. to 5 p.m. on the Jason Gregor Show on TEAM 1260.

  • Quicksilver ballet

    The Oilers “Really Like” alot of these kids, just like they did last year and the year before that. Edmonton has shown they’re not ready to buy just yet. They’ll resort to window shopping and kicking tires much like the last two yrs. Tambellini couldn’t find a ride (make a deal to bring in a legitimate #1 or 2 D’man) if he was lost and standing at a bus stop.

    With the seats full for a team with the first overall pick 3 yrs in a row, this rebuild may go on forever. Edmonton likes to show/tell everyone they have a mind of their own (saying they like Dumba and Murray better)but they’ll submit to common sense and take Yakupov, much like they did with Hall and Hopkins.

  • BigE91

    2-4 years from now is when this team is being built to contend, not just for the palyoffs but fro a long playoff run. Perfect for a guy like Murray to break in and get up to speed with the other young kids.

    The Oilers already have trouble attracting free agents, that may improve as the kids mature and the team improves from within, the problem is top flight d-man rarely hit the open market or are even traded anymore. They are just too valuable to their team.

  • @Reuben and Michael

    Since 2000 the #1 has been traded only twice Florida both times I think (?). Hence Robin is again correct all this banter is really interesting but will most likely be useless (fun but useless).

    Just like the arm chair critiiques here – unless you do something very foolish it is really hard to get a deal beacuse everyone over values their players and it’s too hard to get a deal done.

    ST will have many sleepless nights and in the end we will have Nail – then you can make a trade of the other pieces. But maybe the Oilers know this and that’s what you do spend all your time working on the deal after Nail?