Coaches usually are graded on wins and losses. If you win, you’re considered a good coach, if you lose more than you win, eventually you get fired. Of course there are other intangibles, but winning at the NHL level is the most important factor. With a young team like the Oilers, Krueger doesn’t need to win right away, but he will need to make decisions and evaluations that will lead to more wins in the future.

His first good test will be how he handles Ryan Whitney.

Whitney hasn’t been great, and he seems to be the new whipping boy of many fans. Regardless of how you view Whitney, it will be up to Krueger to try and get the most out of him.

Last night in OT, Jaromir Jagr beat Whitney in the corner which led to Jagr’s OT winner. It was great shot and good play by a future Hall of Famer, but when you get beat one-on-one you are open for criticism.

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below

You can see the goal again here. Just click on the blue arrow beside Jagr’s goal.

If you look at the play you will see that it wasn’t so much a lack of footspeed that hurt Whitney, but rather taking a bad angle to the puck. If Whitney attacks Jagr a half a foot to Whitney’s right, then Jagr could have gone underneath him to the corner, rather than to the middle of the circle. If Jagr beats him down low, he doesn’t have a shooting angle like he gained from going above Whitney.

It was a bad angle, and bad decision by Whitney. But getting beat by Jagr doesn’t mean he is awful though. Click here and then click the blue arrow by Jamie Benn’s goal. Watch Jagr fend off and beat Ladislav Smid one-on-one before giving the puck to Benn.

D-men will get beat one-on-one especially if they have to face a beast like Jagr.

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below

The point with Whitney isn’t about whether he made a bad play or not, it is whether he can return to being a consistent defender.

I don’t know the answer, but Krueger can’t afford to have the same mentality that many fans have right now. He can’t just say Whitney sucks, put him in the pressbox and let him rot.

He could do that, but that would diminish any value Whitney has. There are teams interested in his services, but right now they all want to obtain him at a low return to the Oilers.

Maybe Whitney will never be the player he was prior to 2011.

Whitney has had seasons of 38, 59, 40 and 39 points and that incredible run of 27 points in 35 games for the Oilers in 2010/2011. But then he suffered another foot injury, and since then he hasn’t been able to find his game.

It is easy to just write him off, but keep in mind how many Oiler fans, and pundits around the league, were saying the same thing about Ales Hemsky last season. Hemsky tallied 66 points in only 69 games during the 2010 and 2011 seasons, and last year he only picked up 36 points in 69 games.

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below

Many screamed he was disinterested, lazy and useless and his two-year contract extension was an awful decision. Hemsky was healthy enough to dress for those 69 games, but he wasn’t as strong as he had been in the past and he wasn’t confident in his abilities.

Hemsky is finally healthy again, and he’s back to being an incredibly dangerous player.

I’m not saying it is a guarantee Whitney will return to the player he was pre-2011, in fact, because he had foot issues, it is probably a bigger risk, but I’m very curious to see how Krueger handles him.

The combination of footspeed issues and a lack of confidence is a deadly mixture for Whitney. A coach can’t magically give a player confidence, but he will play a factor in helping him try to re-gain it. Krueger is a master motivator, and this will be a great test to see how he handles Whitney.

A player can’t gain confidence sitting in the pressbox or just practicing. Outside of the top 1%, every player has lost their confidence at some point. The good ones find ways to avoid losing it for long periods, while some never find it again. I have no idea which path Whitney will skate down, but if the Oilers want to get any sort of return for him, they’d be better off supporting him, than just kicking him to the pressbox.


How will Krueger balance trying to help Whitney, while also trying to win games? Can he do both?

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below

The reality is the Oilers don’t have many better options. Can we please stop suggesting that Taylor Fedun is a better option. His coach, Todd Nelson, said he isn’t ready for the NHL yet. His footspeed isn’t the same after shattering his leg last year, but he is getting better Nelson said. He also has zero NHL experience, and while he’d be a great feel-good story he is not a better option at this point.

Corey Potter is not a superior player either. The Oilers could play Potter ahead of Whitney, but will they be better long-term? I don’t see how. They will de-value Whitney and then just lose him for nothing in the off-season.

At this point Krueger has to see if Whitney can get close to being the player he was before the last two seasons of serious foot issues. There is no guarantee he’ll ever be that player again, but it might also be too early to just discard him.

Whitney will be Krueger’s first tough decision, and how he handles him will show us a lot of how he thinks and acts as a head coach.


  • The Oilers re-assigned Mark Arcobello to OKC today, because Ryan Nugent-Hopkins will play on Saturday.  Anton Lander will get an MRI this afternoon, and if he can’t go they might recall Chris Vande Velde.
  • Ben Eager is close to returning, and could play as early as Saturday according to Krueger. Where do you play him though? And when you activate him to the roster, who will they send down? Will they finally part ways with Darcy Hordichuk.
  • Magnus Paajarvi and Teemu Hartikainen have been getting better every game. Paajarvi is using his speed more often, he drew a penalty last night, and he is going to the net better. Hartikainen is a load down low, and once he learns to shake off the defender and go to the next more frequently he’ll be a solid contributor.
  • Lennart Petrell is getting better at ES and on the PK and he’s a great shot blocker. No way he comes out with Horcoff and Belanger on the sidelines.
  • Ryan Jones skated with a visor for the first time today. He said he has no set timeline, but he joked, "My feet are coming along great. Hands are what they were before, not great." I suspect he might be ready to play by the 16th. The Oilers play Saturday, Sunday and Tuesday before getting three days off. That gives Jones ten days to get his cardio up to speed.  


  • justDOit

    The faults listed above vis-a-vis Whitney have been discussed to death. Whitney will never have to worry about getting injured blocking shots. He is not likely to make any play that puts him in jeopardy.

    The one thing that disturbs me is Whitney’s attitude. He had the ‘A’ ripped off his sweater before the season started. That was because of attitude. What the coaches know and we can only speculate about is his how his physical conditioning and attitude inter-lock.

    It’s patently unfair to push Whitney’s play and ultimate fate onto Krueger. Whitney looks to me to be uncoachable based his lame effort against Jagr that led to he game-winning goal last ight. That is not a one-of incident and everyone knows it.

  • justDOit

    JW’s right – this is going to be a true test to see if Krueger is ‘The One’. Whitney’s problems just might be coachable to some extent. It figures to reason that when a player is not able to skate the way he could just a short time ago, his angles have to change and his decision-making process has to adapt in plenty. Coachable. Is Ralph our Thomas A. Anderson?

    I just hope that Whitney doesn’t become the next Larry Murphy.

  • Oilers4ever

    Never mind defense… The Oil need to get a centerman that can win faceoffs, and now.

    If the mgmt of this team is actually SERIOUS with their so called words on getting to the playoffs then they need to do something. Sitting on their cans like they have done the last three seasons when injuries have hit will just prove their word means crap. And if that happens shame on them and fire the lot of them.

    Even Tim Connolly would be an improvement, hell even Arnott at a low contract price. Doing nothing just shows mgmt doesn’t give a damn, but then should we be surprised. They haven’t for the last three years when injuries have hit either. Might as well let the players think losing is okay for another season… MORONS…

  • a lg dubl dubl

    Whitney, to me, seems like he’s scared of the puck, scared of taking the body. A bad case of the Salo Syndrom. Can it be coached out of him, I hope so! he can be a hell of a hockey player when he’s on his game.

    Or maybe he really does want out of E-town who knows

    I heard that Krejeci(sp?) might be available, could Whitney and the 1st round pick be enough.

  • justDOit

    If Hordichuk can only play 1-2 minutes a night then he will have 0 impact on the game. I am actually excited for Eager’s return. I really liked his game/role in the season opener. Jones also brings some grit and speed on the wing that we are missing. Krueger will have lots of tough lineup calls as this team continues to get healthy. When Eager and Belanger get back I say put Belanger between Harski and Paajarvi then put Eager on the wing with Smyth at centre and Petrell on the other wing.

  • justDOit

    First if you look at Whitney’s career lifetime he’s a -22. His best ever season? A +13 on the backs of 27 pt/35 g season. This guy is not a defensive shutdown player. He’s not. So why the hell was he out against Benn/Jagr in OT? Was this his test?

    In my mind he was not set of up for success. Bad coaching decision given your choices and worse when you consider the forward pairing. You want to help him with confidence get him better matchups and offensive zone starts. You want better d-coverage match him with your best defensive Fwds.

    Am I wrong here?

  • Bonvie

    @ Slats

    In my mind he was not set of up for success. Bad coaching decision given your choices and worse when you consider the forward pairing. You want to help him with confidence get him better matchups and offensive zone starts. You want better d-coverage match him with your best defensive Fwds.

    Am I wrong here?

    In a word…yes I would say you are wrong regarding Krueger’s decision to put Whitney out in OT against Jagr.

    He had just been benched the game prior for ‘not moving his feet, gap control and defensive play’. So what does our veteran D-man do? He goes into the corner taking neither the man nor his stick, waves his stick at Jagr with one hand and gets pushed out of the way by the forward who goes to the net and scores.

    Clearly the big suck learned nothing from the press box and showed the coaches just what he is or is not made of.

    If he is one of the Oiler’s top four D then lottery pick here we come.