Nail Yakupov to be scratched again


Edmonton Oilers head coach Dallas Eakins announced this morning that Nail Yakupov will be a healthy scratch against the Phoenix Coyotes on Tuesday.

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below

The Player

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below

Nail Yakupov hasn’t been good enough this season.

His stats line shows that (39GP – 6G – 8A – 14PTS, minus-25), and the fact that he’s getting badly outplayed in the most sheltered minutes available is a real problem. The plus/minus exaggerates things (last year at five-on-five Yakupov’s on-ice save percentage was 0.923; this year it’s 0.868, and one would need to be delusional to think those numbers accurately reflect the state of Yakupov’s defensive game in those two seasons) but he’s been getting out-shot and out-chanced despite getting primarily offensive zone time.

He remains a phenomenally talented player, the guy who led both his team and all NHL rookies in goal-scoring last season. He’s fast and aggressive and has a shot that is already one of the best in the game. But he needs to dramatically improve his overall play to be a useful NHL’er.

The Coach

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below

Dallas Eakins, understandably, feels that Yakupov needs to be better if he’s going to earn more ice-time, and that he can’t just keep gifting him with minutes if the results aren’t there.

“You’ve got to earn it,” he says in the video above. “You have to do a number of things on the ice every day. Every day. It can never change. We cannot give things to people. You have to earn them.”

Eakins further said he’d spoken to Yakupov for “40 to 45 minutes” about the scratch, and that he and the player had a “definite plan moving forward.”

Naturally, the coach is going to take some criticism for the scratch, as he took some criticism for sticking Yakupov on the fourth line and slashing the player’s power play role. It’s impossible not to recognize the talent that the Oilers have in that player, and naturally fans want to see him placed in a position to succeed.

Eakins, though, seems clearly focused on the big picture. A scratch here or there isn’t a big deal; Yakupov’s performance this season isn’t even the primary problem. Yakupov is the kind of player who has the talent to play a pivotal role for the Oilers for the next decade or more. The problem Eakins faces is turning him into the best possible player for that next decade, and if that means making unpopular decisions in a season that (like so many others) was lost before the halfway mark, that’s what it means.

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below

Yakupov entered the NHL and had instant chemistry with his first head coach, Ralph Krueger. His enthusiasm was obvious and infectious and a bright point in an otherwise unmemorable season. But it’s worth remembering it for what it was – that despite Yakupov’s point totals, his line was out-shot game-in and game-out, and that all too often he seemed to be floating around on the ice with no clear idea of where he was supposed to be.

Perhaps Krueger would have been able to correct that with time, or perhaps not. Now the responsibility falls to Eakins. Improving Yakupov’s game might be the single most important thing Eakins does this season as Edmonton’s coach, and given that he’s previously compared Yakupov’s problems to the early struggles of people like Steven Stamkos and Joe Thornton it’s a good bet he knows it.

Recently by Jonathan Willis

  • A-Mc

    Since the Oilers are going to miss the playoffs anyway, GF/GA differential is irrelevant. So run thr thoroughbreds out there and entertain the fans. Who cares if you lose 8-3 some nights. You might win a couple along the way, too.
    If I had to pay to watch former No. 1 picks learn to be NHL grinders I’d jump in front of the LRT.
    The world of sports is so vast, so diverse, and often entertaining. Why waste time on a dull, perennially disappointing doormat of a hockey team?

  • bazmagoo

    Eakins is trying to install a MacT brand of hockey into the Oilers, and we all know how effective that was during MacT’s coaching reign. Outside of a lucky trade for Roloson and subsequent cup run, what did MacT ever accomplish with his style? MacT and Eakins – two 4th line grinders trying to teach the current breed of NHL elite talent to play their style of hockey – ridiculous. All you 1st tier fans, please stop going to the games. 2nd tier fans, get your Oilers fix from illegal internet streams. Stop feeding the incompetence!

  • justDOit

    Who has has improved as player during the first half of the season under Eakins? Maybe Perron? +20 players are going backwards or sideways.

    Who improved under Kruger? Hall, Yak, Eberle, N. Schultz, Dubynk, Gagner

    Who improvec under Renney? Hall, Eberle, Potter, Whitney, Dubynk

    Who are we handing on to as the coach?

  • Some of the pro-benching comments on here are quite laughable.

    “He’s not that good! He’s another Tyler Seguin!” 37 points in 36 games and +12, first line NHL centre Tyler Seguin you mean? The Tyler Seguin who had to be traded and given an opportunity to flourish to find that level of production?

    I both hope and fear that Yakupov is another Tyler Seguin.

    I understand the sentiment that, because the season is lost already, thinking long term about Yak’s growth is paramount. That said, I don’t think benching him and only him while his peers also struggle mightily is helping him grow. He needs to be allowed to make mistakes like his teammates before him were, and he needs to be put into a position to succeed. And no, playing with the Gazdics and Landers of the NHL (also, how sad is it that that’s a thing?) doesn’t qualify. I feel for the kid, he’s clearly falling victim to a double standard IMO.