Photo Credit: © Kim Klement-USA TODAY Sports

WWYDW: All-Star Weekend

We just wrapped up the NHL’s 63rd annual All-Star weekend in Tampa Bay, an event in which the league’s brightest stars come together for a largely apathetic celebration of hockey greatness and fans gather on The Twitter to complain about how boring it all is. What a tradition!

Over the past few years, the league has moved away from the standard East and West All-Stars play a five-on-five game. They experimented with a captains format in which players were drafted to teams, which gave us some hilarious moments, like when Phil Kessel was selected last overall. Despite the fantasy draft itself, the game was pretty boring.

As a result, the league moved to a new format to go along with divisional re-alignment. The league was split into four divisions rather than six, and the All-Star game was ultimately flipped to be played as a three-on-three tournament between the four divisions. In the past, the league also experimented with a North America vs World All-Star game, which could have been interesting this year given the lack of NHL players at the Olympics.

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below

Then there’s the NHL All-Star Skills Competition. The standard events are the fastest skater, hardest shot, and accuracy shooting, but this year, the league added some new events, the goalie save streak, the passing challenge, and a re-designed puck control relay. The save streak was sort of a switch from the shootout we had seen as a staple in previous years, the passing challenge was brand new and was sort of confusing, and the puck control relay was just, uh, bizarre. The relay featured players weaving through an obstacle course and then flipping pucks through these gates for some reason. The event kind of turned into who could best execute the lacrosse-style puck pickup.

This year was also the first year since the Skills Competition’s inception in 1990 that the league didn’t keep track of a SuperSkills conference champion. Instead, the winner of each event got $25,000.

All-Star games are a conundrum in all of the major North American sports leagues aside from the NBA. In baseball, the league made it so that the winner between the National League and the American League got home field advantage in the World Series. That was horrible and it was scrapped this year. The Home Run Derby has been a staple, but there’s skepticism around that event because players worry that participating will goof up their swing. In football, the Pro Bowl is an afterthought. Nobody wants to play in it and its held immediately before the Super Bowl in an event that virtually nobody pays attention to. And like I said, basketball is the only sport with a popular All-Star game. It’s inevitable given the league’s celebration of big personalities that getting everyone together for a no-defence bash will be entertaining.

That brings us to this week’s What Would You Do Wednesday question. What would you do to make All-Star Weekend better? Do you think it’s fine as it is? Could the game format be improved? What about the skills competition?

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below

I like the three-on-three tournament format with the cash prize at the end. I think there’s actual incentive to win and three-on-three is always a good time to watch. That said, I think it would be interesting if the All-Star game was tied into some kind of outdoor classic that better matches the aesthetic of the sport. I don’t know if it’s possible to make the skills competition exciting for anyone other than kids, but maybe that’s what this whole thing is about anyway.


What would you do to be the ultimate fan?  Go to https://www.proamsports.ca for all your officially licensed NHL gear and memorabilia.

  • Kassian's Komrade

    Have the players announce what charity they are going to donate their winnings to. I can’t believe I spent an afternoon watching millionaires competing for money.

    • Nation Dan

      That said, I would bring back the fantasy draft. Go back to standard competitions for some actual continuity in the skills comp and bring back the rookie game.

  • Serious Gord

    1. I would eliminate it altogether and start the season in mid September and end the playoffs before June1.

    2 but assuming that can’t be done because the corporate perk value is too high ( and let’s face it that is largely what it has become) I would make the following changes.

    A) move it to the week before the regular season starts and have the awards banquet the same weekend.

    B) go back to five in five – amazingly three in three is boring when the players don’t try.

    C select first all star – second all star – let’s differentiate like we used to the great from the very good

    D) East vs west. Make it two periods if that helps.

    E) make it an outdoor event??

  • Ryan68

    All-star games are boring. All of them. Because who wants to risk injuring themselves or someone else? Even McDavid seemed to pull up a little on the fastest skater. And if I hear that Running-Start Larkin is the record holder one more time I’m going to find Bettman and send him back to the Shire.

  • Oilerz4life

    3 on 3 gimmicky hockey thing for Americans to bring their kids to watch on the cheap in Florida. Just hold it at Disney next year and come out with a crappy Netflix B-film about it. Yippee.

  • Glencontrolurstik

    Yeah, kids & non-hockey fans…
    Lately it’s been held in “Beach Team” cities and places where they are trying to “grow the game,” as that seems to be the NHL’s motto the last few years. All decisions they make lately have been around “growing the game.”
    Anyway, the “All-Star Break” is my way of filling our freezer with “Winter Chinook” every year… It’s the only way I look forward to it…