Photo Credit: Kim Klement-USA TODAY Sports

High/Low: The Defencemen

Barring a shocking trade or a minor free agent signing, the Oilers roster we see now will be the same one we see come September. With minimal changes to the roster, it’s clear that the organization is banking on some best-case scenarios from players this year in order to return to the playoffs.

Over the next few weeks, you’ll see me go through every player who should have an impact in the Oilers organization and try to guess what that players “ceiling” is, and also what their “floor” would be performance wise.

In doing this, I’ll be making a few assumptions. The first being that the player stays healthy for the entire season. Obviously, the worst case scenario for any player would be to miss a significant amount of time with injury. The other is that the player will spend the entire season with the Oilers. It would be easy to say that the best case scenario for some names is that they’re traded away from Edmonton.

For the high end of things, I tried to be realistic yet optimistic. Of course, it’s POSSIBLE for someone like Matt Benning to score 20 goals and log 28 minutes per game this year… but c’mon.

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below

Also, if you missed parts one and two of this series, here is “The Centres”, “The Top Six Wingers” & “The Bottom Six Wingers”

Now that I’ve explained my thought process, here is part two of my “Highs & Lows” for the 2018 Oilers: The Defensemen:

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below


CEILING: Injuries and inconsistency plagued Klefbom in 17-18. He appeared lost in his own end and didn’t produce close to the offence the team needed.

I’ll sound like a broken record in this piece, but all you need to do is look at Klefbom’s 16-17 season to see that he has the potential to be an elite offensive producer.

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below

No one knows who will be anchoring the Oiler’s top PP unit, but Klefbom is probably the favourite. In 16-17 he posted 16 powerplay points, and if that unit clicks this year with him as the quarterback, I think 5-20-25 on the powerplay alone is possible.

He doesn’t need to be great in his own end, just survive. Last year, he was on the ice for 59 even strength goals against in 66 games. I want that number to stay the same this year, but over an 82 game season.

FLOOR: What if the powerplay doesn’t return to form? Or what if it does but Andrej Sekera or Matt Benning or Evan Bouchard are anchoring it? There’s one area where Klefbom can provide supreme value to this roster, and if he can’t win that job, and keep it, this season will be tough to call a success.

It’s expected he’ll start on a pairing with Adam Larsson, but what if his inability to cover someone in his own end or make a breakout pass wasn’t because of a nagging injury. If he can’t hold a spot on one of the top two pairings, his $4.1 million will not look like a bargain anymore.


Oct 19, 2017; Chicago, IL, USA; Edmonton Oilers defenseman Adam Larsson (6) takes a shot against the Chicago Blackhawks during a game at United Center. Mandatory Credit: Patrick Gorski-USA TODAY Sports

CEILING: At the age of 25, and with more than 400 games under his belt, we know exactly what Adam Larsson is. He’s a mean defender who can punish opponents in the corner and give you a lot of honest minutes at even strength. On special teams, he won’t give you very much on the powerplay but should be able to make meaningful contributions to the team’s penalty kill.

I’m expecting another solid season, and this will sound boring, but my ceiling for Larsson is simply an expectation for him to consistently play against the oppositions best and make life easy for Cam Talbot while doing so.

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below

FLOOR: This is also going to sound boring but that’s because Adam Larsson is a pretty boring player. I think he’s a very good defender in the sense that he makes life tough on the opposing team. In two years with the Oilers, he’s averaged just 16 points a year. So his floor in terms of production is maybe 10 points?

I’d say the floor for Larsson’s performance has nothing to do with him, but more with whoever he’s paired with. If he’s playing next to the same Oscar Klefbom we saw last year, it could end up reflecting poorly on Larsson.


Mar 17, 2018; Sunrise, FL, USA; Edmonton Oilers center Connor McDavid (97) celebrates his goal against the Florida Panthers with defenseman Darnell Nurse (25) in the third period at BB&T Center. Mandatory Credit: Robert Mayer-USA TODAY Sports

CEILING: Last year we saw Darnell Nurse start to gain confidence with the puck. He was holding onto it and looking to make a play rather than just trying to get rid of it as quick as possible, which we had seen in his earlier years.

He’s about to his the 300 games played mark, which is usually when you know exactly what a d-man is. If he’s going to discover an offensive side to his game, it will be this year.

As I’ve already said, there’s a spot on the top powerplay unit that is wide open. Darnell hasn’t shown that ability thus far, but he could surprise us, and I am trying to establish his ceiling.

Last year he posted 21 even strength points and none on the powerplay. If he can up his even strength numbers and get 28 points (which would put him 20th amongst NHL d-men) and add 12 with some powerplay responsibilities, I’m willing to say Darnell has the potential to be a 40 point man.

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below

Away from the puck, I want to see Darnell continue to carry his own pairing, which he’s more than capable of doing.

FLOOR: I can’t see Darnell taking a massive step back this year, or any step back at all.

My floor for Darnell is exactly what we saw this year. Top four minutes, no powerplay responsibility and around 20 points.


Dec 23, 2017; Edmonton, Alberta, CAN; Edmonton Oilers defensemen Andrej Sekera (2) skates against the Montreal Canadiens at Rogers Place. Mandatory Credit: Perry Nelson-USA TODAY Sports

CEILING: I believe the Sekera we saw in 2016-17 is about as good as it’s going to get. He averaged about 16 minutes a night at even strength and posted 19 points. I’d say that’s his 5v5 ceiling.

I do think he can add a little more offence when it comes to the powerplay. In 16/17 he played 174 powerplay minutes, which was second among Oiler blueliner. In that time, he posted 12 points. If he were to take over the teams top unit this year, 20 points might not be a stretch.

I also expect a healthy Sekera to play a big role in helping the Oilers powerplay rebound from a historically bad season.

Basically, Sekera’s ceiling is being able to anchor a pairing in the teams top four while contributing to both sides of the powerplay.

FLOOR: Again we’re assuming a player stays healthy all year, but even if Sekera stays in the lineup it’s far from a guarantee that he’s the same player we saw in 2016-17. He’s 32 years old and is recovering from major leg surgery. That’s the kind of stuff that sends careers on the decline.

There’s a chance we see Sekera healthy, yet struggling in a league that’s only getting fast. 3-16-19 and no powerplay presence on the power play is his floor.


Oct 28, 2017; Edmonton, Alberta, CAN; Edmonton Oilers defensemen Kris Russell (4) and Washington Capitals forward Alex Chiasson (39) chase a loose puck during the second period at Rogers Place. Mandatory Credit: Perry Nelson-USA TODAY Sports

CEILING: I don’t think Russell will live up to his $4 million deal, and with the amount of hate he gets from the fan base, even if he plays well this year most won’t admit it.

He certainly has his mental lapses, but I don’t think you can deny that Kris Russell is a good third pairing d-man. He can skate well, he plays with no fear (son of a cowboy), and for the most part, can eat a good chunk of minutes.

Benning, Larsson, and Nurse had better GA/60. The team was bad, and Russell wasn’t good, but he was far from the Oilers biggest problem.

It’s tough to put into numbers what we can expect from him, but if he can be a soldier on the penalty kill and find himself on the team’s second pairing, Oilers fans should be more than thrilled.

FLOOR: Well, right now Russell is etched onto the third pairing. If Evan Bouchard or Ethan Bear make this team, someone has to come out of the lineup and it will either be Russell or Benning.

He’s a year older and has another year of tough miles on his body. If he’s lost his foot speed, he might find himself in the press box on a fairly regular basis.

Lots would have to happen for that situation to occur, but it’s possible and that’s what I’ll call his floor.


Nov 9, 2017; Newark, NJ, USA; Edmonton Oilers center Leon Draisaitl (29) celebrates with center Connor McDavid (97) and defenseman Matt Benning (83) after scoring the game winning goal in overtime at Prudential Center. Mandatory Credit: Ed Mulholland-USA TODAY Sports

CEILING: Benning loves to shoot the puck. He’ll fire a wrist shot from far out, he’ll creep into the slot for a quick chance or even wind up for a slapshot from the blueline. If Benning can learn to perfect his shot from the point this year, it could lead to an abundance of opportunities.

Like I said, there’s a spot on the Oiler’s top powerplay unit that is wide open right now and that’s where Benning can make the biggest impact. If he grabs that spot and the power play returns to its 16/17 form, Benning could be a 20 point powerplay guy.

At even strength, I’m not expecting Benning to be more than a third pairing guy, but it’s his third season in the league, maybe he shocks me and proves he’s ready to handle more minutes and tougher matchups.

FLOOR: At this point, I would say Benning is the Oiler’s sixth defenseman and while he could see some time on the team’s second powerplay unit, that time could evaporate if one of Evan Bouchard or Ethan Bear makes the team.

In fact, Benning could be pushed to the teams seventh d-man if that were to happen.

My floor is less than ten points, with less than 41 games played.

Baggedmilk on #theLOCKERROOM: When will the hub cities get announced?


Chris Kelly of the Ottawa Senators is hit from behind by Kevin Gravel of the Los Angeles Kings during first period of NHL action at Canadian Tire Centre in Ottawa, November 11, 2016. Photo by Jean Levac ORG XMIT: 125302

CEILING: He’s played 70 career games and he’s only going to make 700k this year. Add on that there are six NHL d-men ahead of him on the depth chart, Evan Bouchard might make the team, and Ethan Bear would probably be the first option to get playing time if there is an injury… it’s not looking good for Kevin.

My ceiling for Gravel is simply getting into 41 games. That would be bad for the Oilers, but good for the depth defenseman. Maybe he could go to AHL and provide some veteran leadership, which might be a positive as well.

FLOOR: Re-read the first part of his ceiling, and then think about that. I can’t see him playing a lot, so honestly, I’m not even going to give him a floor.

NOTE: Evan Bouchard and Ethan Bear were not listed here because they will appear in another part of the series.

    • Bond

      Davidson stillon the team would be one of life’s little luxuries. It was stupid to trade him the first time, it was REALLY STUPID to do it the second time. If Sekera isn’t back to his old self trading Davidson is really going to bite Chirelli in the ass…deservedly so

  • Bond

    A lot of the individual players success rate will have to do with usage, pairing’s and overall team strategy. Used correctly and with the right pairings and line mates our defence can get by. They all need to be healthy and TM needs to rely on Yawney. I think our schedule is brutal and Todd will be fired by game 10.

  • IPeeOil

    Our D sucks
    Our Wingers suck (except Nuge)
    Our Goaltending suck
    Our pp/pk sucks
    Our dot percentage sucks
    Our Coachs/GM suck
    Shall I go on and point out the OBVIOUS FACTS??
    At least we have an awesome ? fan base. I’d sign in a heartbeat to go play in coldass Edmonton and be taxed almost half my pay. The only plus to the Oilers?? Conner (and Nuge.) Just not enough…

  • Hemmercules

    Klef, Nurse, Sekera and Larsson can be a decent group if all goes well. Talbot will have to help of course. They will all look like a bunch of chumps again if Talbot cant stop the first shot of the game on a regular basis.

    Nurse needs to progress, Klef needs to stay healthy and Reggie needs to shake off the rust from having a major injury. Larsson had a rough time last year due to losing his dad but he should be back to crushing guys and playing shut down again. If they lose one guy for significant time im not sure Russel or Benning can fill in? Chia will be forced into an in-season trade. Too bad they cant afford another guy right now but thats life when you hand out the big bucks to too many players.

  • BringitbacklikeSlats

    Ughhh you guys at ON and fervent belief that Klefbom is this hidden offensive dynamo.
    In one breath you state here that he has the potential of an “elite” offensive defenseman and then in the next conclude that if everything goes right for him he may put up 25 points next season?
    On what planet does 25 points constitute an “elite” offensive defenseman. Never mind the salient fact that he’s duplicitously also a complete sieve in his D zone (also a pretty important facet to his job… just Sayin’).

    Most of the advanced Stats guys (Corsi mongerers) cherry pick that ridiculously flawed analytic, but also ignore real tangible stats like they do at the Cult of Hockey in keeping tabs on Major mistakes that contribute to chances against, and Major plays leading to Goals for. So citing his “glorious” offensive numbers of the 16’/17′ Campaign, while ignoring that he led all in major mistakes leading to goal against us category strikes me as slack jawed.Oh and wouldn’t you know it… guess who led that same category again last season while simultaneously posting bupkis for offence; all the while being given a plethora of PP minutes.

    Give me a break

    • BringitbacklikeSlats

      Forgive me. He was playing hurt with a sore shoulder. And somehow that shoulder pain turns his brain off and makes him do all kinds of stupid things.

      • OriginalPouzar

        No, but the shoulder injury effects the way the player plays, it effects the way he goes to battle for the puck (and his ability to battle), if effects the way he shoots (and the effectiveness of the shot). It also effects the confidence which leads to poor decisions, etc.

        • BringitbacklikeSlats

          It’s a great excuse for his poor reads and defensive play last year. But how does it explain the abysmal defending the previous year?

          People can effect a change, but an injury cannot. An injury only “affects”

          • OriginalPouzar

            You mean the season in which all his metric were positive – possession metrics and goal share at even strength (and a key piece of the best PP in the league during the last third of the season). I’ll take that abysmal defending and positive results every game.

            Thank you for the grammar lesson – it really shows how smart you are.

      • BringitbacklikeSlats

        Yeah but again… you’re just cherry picking Corsi while ignoring that he made over 200 major mistakes that led to goals against in 16/17. That was team leading. And then he did it agin last last year, but didn’t post any offence.
        Good grammar’s the only thing separating us from the Beasts Jaroslav. You’re most welcome??

    • crabman

      “I think 5-20-25 on the powerplay alone is possible”
      that’s the highend prediction. not 25 points total. Add that to the 23 5×5 points he scored 2 years ago would put him at 48 points. That would put him top 20 in defencemen scoring. I’m not sure that qualifies as elite but it would be pretty darn close. That would be a pretty great high.

  • thumz

    That’s an average Blueline at best. And that’s assuming Sekera returns to form, Darnell continues to improve, and no one gets hurt. Hopefully McJesus can get a hatty every night..