Photo Credit: © Stephen R. Sylvanie-USA TODAY Sports

Offseason Moves: Oilers vs. the Pacific

Last week, I asked if the Oilers really improved this offseason. They signed Kyle Brodziak, Tobias Rieder, and Kevin Gravel (Mikko Koskinen earlier, too), but most of those players simply replace players sent away at the trade deadline. If the Oilers are going to move up the standings it will be based off internal development and players bouncing back.

But what about the rest of the Pacific? The Oilers finished fifth in the division last season, but a few teams have gone out and added to their teams, and others, like the Oilers, haven’t done a whole lot.

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below

Vegas Golden Knights

2017-18 record: 51-24-7 109 points

Notable subtractions: David Perron, James Neal, Luca Sbisa.

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below

Notable additions: Paul Stastny, Nick Holden, Daniel Carr, Curtis Mackenzie.

Vegas’ place in the standings next season is anyone’s guess. After a huge inaugural season, no one would be surprised if numerous players regressed and fell back to earth. They lost David Perron and James Neal in free agency, but signed Paul Stastny to replace some of that scoring going out the door.

Stasnty is a nice signing at a good price ($6.5 million per for three years). He’ll provide some cover if either William Karlsson or Erik Haula can’t replicate their 2017-18 seasons. Losing Perron and Neal hurts, but they were probably wise to stay away from Neal at that price. Perron signed a fair deal with St. Louis, but he seems to love it there and might not have been asking the same of Vegas. Daniel Carr and Curtis Mackenzie both feel like Vegas players who could surprise with an expanded role.

Vegas’ first round picks in 2017 all had great seasons in junior and overseas. Cody Glass and Nick Suzuki could push for an NHL job next season. And they’re still poking around an Erik Karlsson trade.

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below

Verdict: They’ve made some reasonable bets in free agency and are still looking to improve. A lot depends on Marc-Andre Fleury and whether he can deliver another excellent season or not.

Anaheim Ducks

2017-18 record: 44-25-13 101 points

Notable subtractions: Derek Grant, Kevin Bieksa, Antoine Vermette. Ryan Kesler (?).

Notable additions: Brian Gibbons, Luke Schenn, Andrej Sustr, Carter Rowney.

The Ducks have been quiet this season. The biggest news is Ryan Kesler possibly sitting out next season in an attempt to get healthy and prolong his career. That would be a considerable loss, but Kesler’s 2017-18 season saw him score 14 points in 44 games, averaging 18 minutes a game. It might be best for both the Ducks and Kesler if he sat out and tried to get healthy. He won’t be as useful if he plays like last season.

Anaheim always stays near the top of the Pacific. Last season, Ryan Getzlaf, Kesler, and Rakell all missed games and players like Derek Grant played huge roles at times. They still finished with 101 points. John Gibson covers a lot of faults, he just has to stay healthy. Ryan Miller was excellent in a backup role.

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below

Ondrej Kase could see an increased role. Their excellent drafting has given them a steady stream of prospects ready to graduate to the NHL. Troy Terry, Jacob Larsson, Marcus Pettersson, and Kalle Kossila are NHL options for the Ducks next season.

Verdict: Anaheim hasn’t done much. They’ve added a few depth guys but their drafting always puts them in a good position. A core of Getzlaf, Rickard Rakell, Josh Manson, and Hampus Lindholm always has them in the hunt.

San Jose Sharks

2017-18 record: 45-27-10 100 points

Notable subtractions: Mikkel Boedker, Joel Ward, Jannik Hansen.

Notable additions: Evander Kane.

The Sharks cleared a lot of salary when they got involved in the Mike Hoffman trade and then flipped him to Florida. San Jose got rid of Boedker’s salary and bought out the remaining year on Paul Martin’s contract. They were well-positioned to take a run at John Tavares, but he ultimately chose to head home and sign with the Maple Leafs instead. They re-signed Evander Kane and Joe Thornton, but haven’t added anyone significant this summer. They signed Logan Couture to a long-term extension, too.

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below
Edmonton Oilers training camp roster features no big surprises

Verdict: The Sharks opened up a bunch of cap space but didn’t use it. They were in on Tavares and Ryan O’Reilly, but couldn’t land either player. It still feels like there’s a move coming. But it’s also mid-July and history suggests there’s not a lot of impact players moved from now until the season starts, but hey, Max Pacioretty is available and could be a fit in San Jose. It sounds a lot like Artemi Panarin is kindly letting Columbus know he won’t be signing with them. Everyone is expecting Carolina to move Jeff Skinner (and Justin Faulk). The Sharks have been connected to just about every big name available. It’s still possible they make a big add, but that feels less likely as the season approaches.

Los Angeles Kings

2017-18 record: 45-29-8 98 points

Notable subtractions: Christian Folin.

Notable additions: Ilya Kovalchuk, Peter Budaj.

Los Angeles’ big move was Ilya Kovalchuk. They gave him the third year to seal the deal, while other teams wouldn’t. But Kovalchuk is 35 now. It’s unclear how much offence he’ll bring back from the KHL, where he scored 285 points in 262 games. Using NHLE, Kovalchuk’s last season projects to 39 goals and 78 points in the NHL. Kovalchuk scored at a 68-point pace in his last season in the NHL, but he also averaged over 24 minutes a game.

Verdict: Signing Kovalchuk to a three-year contract might be one year too long, but he should provide top-six scoring for the next couple years. The Kings also signed Drew Doughty to a mammoth extension, avoiding an Erik Karlsson-like situation. Kovalchuk should help, and maybe Budaj recovers some of the magic he had with them in 2016-17, but it’s still be a relatively quiet off-season for Los Angeles.

Mar 31, 2018; Calgary, Alberta, CAN; Edmonton Oilers center Leon Draisaitl (29) controls the puck against the Calgary Flames during the first period at Scotiabank Saddledome. Mandatory Credit: Sergei Belski-USA TODAY Sports

Calgary Flames

2017-18 record: 37-35-10 84 points

Notable subtractions: Dougie Hamilton, Michael Ferland, Matt Stajan.

Notable additions: Noah Hanifin, Elias Lindholm, James Neal, Derek Ryan, Austin Czarnik.

The Flames missed the playoffs and clearly weren’t happy with it. They made a lot of moves to improve their depth up front, but also sent away Dougie Hamilton in one of the only blockbuster trades this summer. Noah Hanifin had a sort of standout season last year and Elias Lindholm has always been an intriguing player, but Hamilton was part of one of the league’s best pairings. A return to Mark Giordano and T.J. Brodie on the top pairing is a downgrade and for all the talk about how much right-handed defenceman are worth, it feels they sold low on Hamilton.

They definitely improved at forward. James Neal and Elias Lindholm can play in their top six, while Derek Ryan is a nice middle-six option. Austin Czarnik is a wildcard that could provide depth scoring or more.

Verdict: Calgary is better at forward, but their defence is more of a question mark now that T.J. Brodie will play more. Hamonic needs a rebound season, but the Flames have so many young defence prospects it might not matter. It’s possible one of Rasmus Andersson, Oliver Kylington, or Juuso Valimaki makes the team and is ready to play meaningful minutes. Hanifin isn’t Hamilton, but he’s still a bonafide top-four defenceman. I’m a little surprised they didn’t do more in net, so a lot of next season rests on Mike Smith.

Edmonton Oilers

2017-18 record: 36-40-6 78 points

Notable subtractions: Mike Cammalleri, Patrick Maroon, Mark Letestu.

Notable additions: Tobias Rieder, Kyle Brodizak, Kevin Gravel, Mikko Koskinen.

The Oilers had a wildly disappointing season after they were a few goals away from the Western Conference Finals in 2016-17. They took a step back and most expected changes beyond a few depth players. Tobias Rieder and Kyle Brodziak are fine players, but they aren’t moves that’ll catapult a team back in the playoffs.

Report: Jesse Puljujarvi hasn't negotiated new contract with Finnish team

Edmonton is counting on some bounce-back seasons and internal development, but it’s also another bet on the 2016-17 team that made the playoffs, which is starting to feel almost mythical at this point. That was a good team, but a lot of players had career seasons and the Oilers should be continually adding and improving instead of relying on a team that won one round in 2017. The depth on the wings is poor, especially on the right side.

Verdict: Bob Nicholson appeared on Hockey Night in Canada early in March and said that fans will buy-in if they understand the plan once they make changes. The changes included some new assistant coaches and a few depth players, which leaves too many question marks and things to go right for the Oilers to return to the playoffs. It’s hard to argue the Oilers are much better than last season.

Vancouver Canucks

2017-18 record: 31-40-11 73 points

Notable subtractions: Henrik Sedin, Daniel Sedin.

Notable additions: Jay Beagle, Antoine Roussel, Tim Schaller, Tanner Kero.

The Canucks had another poor season and decided to sign a give a bunch of depth players term and money in free agency. Jay Beagle, Antoine Roussel, and Tim Schaller are useful players, but unlike Schaller’s deal the Beagle and Roussel contracts are insane. Neither player scored more than 22 points last season, but will make three million for the next four years.

These moves are eerily similar to the Edmotnon’s off-season moves of 2011, when they signed Eric Belanger, Ben Eager, and Darcy Hordichuk. Sure, Beagle, Roussel, and Schaller are more useful than the three Edmonton signed, but also come at a higher price and term.

Vancouver had the opportunity to weaponize their cap space and take big-money contracts from cap-strapped teams for assets, but chose to use their cap space against themselves.

Verdict: The biggest addition will come from their 2017 first-round pick, Elias Pettersson, coming to North America. Otherwise, the Canucks haven’t improved much at all. A lack of third and fourth-liners wasn’t what ailed the Canucks.

Arizona Coyotes

2017-18 record: 29-41-12 70 points

Notable subtractions: Max Domi, Luke Schenn, Zac Rinaldo, Jordan Martinook, Tobias Rieder.

Notable additions: Alex Galchenyuk, Michael Grabner, Vinnie Hinostroza, Jordan Oesterle.

Arizona swapped playmaking Max Domi for goalscoring Alex Galchenyuk, who may finally get the chance to play center full time. Michael Grabner is a solid middle-six option and Vinnie Hinostroza was a surprisingly effective scorer for Chicago last season.

They won’t miss Luke Schenn or Zac Rinaldo. Martinook when Rieder both took a step back last season.

Jordan Oesterle played a lot in Chicago and could be effective in a reduced role for the Coyotes, while making almost nothing on a one-year contract.

Verdict: The Coyotes finished the season with a 17-9-3 record. If Antti Raanta stays healthy and performs like last year, they can distance themselves from the bottom of the standings.

Jun 22, 2018; Dallas, TX, USA; Evan Bouchard poses for a photo with team representatives after being selected as the number ten overall pick to the Edmonton Oilers in the first round of the 2018 NHL Draft at American Airlines Center. Mandatory Credit: Jerome Miron-USA TODAY Sports

Arizona, Calgary, and Vegas made the most moves out of the Pacific teams. Have the Oilers done enough to keep up in the division? Rieder and Brodziak effectively replace Maroon and Letestu in my eyes. Their right wing is still far too inexperienced and their defence relies on one of Kris Russell or Matt Benning performing in the top four. Cam Talbot should recover from a disappointing 2017-18 campaign, but Koskinen is both unknown and expensive. A lot of Pacific Division teams are staking a lot on their goaltenders performing well in 2018-19

Still, Edmonton’s off-season isn’t that different of other Pacific Division teams, even if it feels like they lacked a move or two. Help on defence or the wing would have inspired confidence, but as of now the Oilers are once again relying on too many things to go right next season.

  • Dapper Dan 3099

    This is the reason I’m skeptical of the Oilers this upcoming season…. much of the Pacific has added depth and improved, while the Oilers made some lateral moves at best… their biggest areas of concern remain what they were last year and everyone is hoping for bounce back years and minimal injuries…. the only positive is that we have the best player in the NHL and with him on the roster, I guess anything can happen. I just don’t like our odds at this time.

  • 18% body fat

    Oilers fans will buy in once they see the plan. Move forward with Lucic Russel and caggulia. Good plan! The only good plan is if these 3 are under 10 minutes a night with no special teams play.

    How about clearing them out and than sekera next year. Save 15.5 million.

    • AlexTheOilersFanSince2006

      Or we could I don’t know, SUPPORT THEM! Yeah that’s something this fan base tends to not do around here. As soon as someone has a bad season, “oh well guess they’re trash now. Time to get rid of them!”

  • ed from edmonton

    One of the most interesting stories this coming season will be can a 35 year old Kovalchuk returning after a five year vacation in the KHL be an asset.

  • TKB2677

    The Knights let Neal 25 goals, 44 pts and Perron 16 goals, 66 pts just walk away. That’s 41 goals and 110 pts just gone. No way Perron duplicates his year but he probably could have got 40 pts. Neal is a lock for over 20 goals. Stastny is an OK second line center. He had 16 goals 50pts last year. That is his best season in 4 years. So he can replace some of the offense but not all of it. If you go down the lineup, the huge majority of Vegas forwards all had career years. Plus Fluery posted career highs in numbers. So Vegas will take a step back.

    The Sharks added Kane, that’s it. The rest of their core is 1 yr older. Except for Kane, the guys who are the main stays for the Sharks are close to 30. Some are mid to high 30’s. They gave Thornton who’s 39 coming off 2 years of major knee surgery 5 mill.

    Ducks. Kesler probably won’t play. They still have Getlaf and Perry who are all over 30.

    Kings just signed a 35 yr old in Kovalchuk who could be OK but maybe not. Being out of the NHL that long has to affect you. The rest of their core is over 30.

    Canucks just paid 10 mill for their 4th line and they have to replace the Sedins which will be a massive hole both for points and leadership.

    Arizona who knows. They still don’t have a star just a bunch of OK forwards.

    Flames revamped their team. Gio is 1 yr older. They traded away a 16 goal, 50 pt, right shot, pp running dman because he didn’t hang out with the team much. Maybe Hanifin is a better all around dman eventually but they lost offense. Hamonic can maybe be better but all he is, is a right shooting defensive dman. Brode probably plays better because he will be with Gio but the last 2 seasons show he’s not that good. They paid 3 mill for a 4th line center and their center depth isn’t that good in the top 6. Backlund is a 45 pt center. That’s a pretty weak second line center. Neal is a nice addition. They also have a 36 yr old starter who gets hurt every year.

    The Oilers didn’t do much but first of all they couldn’t thanks to the salary but second, they didn’t need to do much. Most of their core players are 25 and under. They would just be coming into their primes. Their 2 best players – McDavid and Leon- haven’t hit their primes yet. Most of their top 4 dmen was hurt or had family tragedy. Their goalie had his worst year professionally and the rest of their team for the most part had down years. So I would counter by saying I think it would be foolish to blow up their team. People want to complain about Lucic and Russell. I am not a fan of Russell but he played fine last year and his game is not something that changes much and at 31, he can duplicate it. I am not a fan of the Lucic contract either but there is a good change he bounces back and even if he doesn’t, he’s 1 guy.

      • Gordoil

        Agree with much of what you say, and would like to add – what team in the top ten in standings isn’t relying on career years from most of there team. When they get it from there core players it snowballs through out the rest of the team much like 2016-17. The same can happen the other way as in 2017-18
        Every team is hoping for a good start and a snowball effect. Look at Colorado last year, mostly the same team that crapped the bed the year before.

  • Rob...

    What makes you think Calgary had one of the best defensive pairs in the league? Looking at least season there were over 140 defensemen in the list of best +/- before you hit a Calgary d-man! It truly boggles the mind as to how you and others still think they’re so damn good.

    • Ol_OneNut

      I agree. Year after year we’d hear how the flamers had one of the best d corps in the league. I didn’t buy into it then and I don’t believe it now. There D is mediocre at best. People trash the Oilers D but I’d take them over Calgarys any day of the week

  • Ty Guy

    it feels like it has been an arms race in the pacific with every team* making or attempting a big move….more than any other division it seems..at least in magnitude.
    *every team but the oilers

    • Rob...

      Tough position for a GM. Too many players had horrible years, which doesn’t exactly put you in a good position for trades. If even half of those players (must include Talbot) have average years and McDavid is healthy, we’ll improve by 8 wins.

      • a lg dubl dubl

        I agree, those 8 wins put the oilers in playoff contention. If the special teams can steal a few games then there shouldn’t be a problem getting in the playoffs as long as the top 6 and Talbot stay healthy all year

  • Abagofpucks

    I think its easy to point fingers at the oilers and say that they arent a playoff team. But half the defence was either playing hurt or had some terrible thing happen in there personel lives . And of course talbot had a bad season which i believe he can bounce back from . So based on those problems being fixed for this up comming season they should be much better .

  • chezzychez

    It’s not thaaat hard to argue that the oilers got better this offseason. PK will improve with Yawney and Brodziak, Sekera is back to start the year and we’re quicker than last year. Those were some stand-out problems from last year.

  • TKB2677

    I looked up the Oilers stats.
    In the 16-17 season they scored 247 goals. That is with Eberle and his 20 and Maroon scoring 27, and a top 5 PP.
    In the 17-18 season they scored 234 goals. That was without Eberle. Maroon played 57 games but had 14 goals. He only ended up with 17 this season. So he was going to be quite a bit down from goals. Their PP was dead last in the league.

    SO they were down by 13 goals. In the 16-17 season, Klefbom with his bad shoulder scored 12 goals. In 17-18, with the same bad shoulder, he scored 5. In 16-17, Sekera scored 8 goals. In 17-18, in his brief time, he had zero. So between those 2, that’s 15 less goals. There is your difference from last year to this year. With a completely healthy shoulder, Klebom probably scores more than 5. You know Sekera will score more than zero goals. Can Rieder replace Maroon’s 14 goals as an Oiler? Most likely. He had 12 in a “bad year”. Puljujarvi had 12 goals in 65 games while he figured out the league. I would put money that he could improve on that at least slightly. Is Lucic going to go 38 games without scoring? I would put money he scores more than 10. Nuge had 24 goals in 62 games. If he plays a full season, he will score more than that. I have a hard time believing that the Oilers PP with McDavid will be dead last again.

    So is the offense really that bad? If the Oilers equaled what they scored in 16-17 last season, no one would be complaining. Nothing of what I said involves any Oilers player having an amazing season.

  • Opi

    Have to love Oiler Homer Nation … when the Oil were interested in James Neal we all saw this headline on here … “UFA Profile: James Neal is the perfect fit the Oilers can’t afford…” and now that he is a Flame we see comments like the one above … ” Losing Perron and Neal hurts, but they were probably wise to stay away from Neal at that price.”

    lol …