Damage has been done, but quality pieces still remain in place

When Peter Chiarelli was hired as general manager of the Oilers on April 15, 2015, he inherited an idiot-proof situation. The Oilers, who had spent the past half-decade loading up with high-quality talent from the draft, won the golden ticket.

It was a slam dunk. There was already a wealth of quality players in Taylor Hall, Leon Draisaitl, Ryan Nugent-Hopkins, Oscar Klefbom, Darnell Nurse, and Jordan Eberle, and then a generational talent in Connor McDavid got added on top. There was also a mid-first and an early second round pick after McDavid in a deep draft and a wealth of cap room to make some moves in free agency. It was any general manager’s dream.

Now, three-and-a-half years later, the Oilers are somehow in worse shape than they were when he inherited the team.

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below

It began with inexplicably trading a first- and second-round pick for Griffin Reinhart, who was already well on his way to bust territory. It continued when Taylor Hall needed to be dealt to fill the void on the blueline that wasn’t with the Reinhart deal. As time went along, Chiarelli routinely got fleeced in trades, spilling the value the Oilers had acquired through that Decade of Darkness down the drain. He also backed himself into the corner with bad free agent contracts, making it virtually impossible to make edits to the deeply flawed roster he had assembled.

Nobody in 2015 imagined that this is where the Oilers would be four years into McDavid’s career. Nobody. Even when people said “the Oilers will find a way to screw this up”, they didn’t envision the colossal failure that Chiarelli managed to put together. You might have thought the Oilers were the laughingstock of the league during the Decade of Darkness, but Chiarelli wasting the early career of the league’s best player ushered in a whole new level of comedy.

But this is a dead horse now. We don’t need to argue about Hall for Larsson or Eberle for Strome or Milan Lucic’s deal or Kris Russell’s deal. It’s time to look ahead.

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below

Chiarelli’s tenure is over. The Oilers decided to pull the plug half-way through the season, which is pretty uncommon when it comes to executives, mostly because they didn’t believe he could clean up his own mess. He got a vote of confidence just over a month ago from CEO Bob Nicholson, who stated Chiarelli’s job was safe if the team made the playoffs. Given the way things went, the organization ultimately felt Chiarelli could only do more harm than good if he was kept around.

Throwback Thursday: Today in 1984, Edmonton Oilers Wayne Gretzky wins Hart and Art Ross Trophies

As I said earlier, the situation is worse now than it was at the draft in 2015. The team doesn’t have as much high-quality talent, the cap situation is murky, and the fans have reached an all-time boiling point in frustration. Still, despite the challenges, there are pieces in place here to turn this thing around.

The good: 

  • Connor McDavid, the league’s best player, is here and he’s signed for seven more years after this one. Leon Draisaitl, Ryan Nugent-Hopkins, Darnell Nurse, and Oscar Klefbom behind McDavid represents a formidable core.
  • There’s a wave of good prospects on the way. Evan Bouchard looked good during his cup of coffee at the NHL level and fellow 2018 pick Ryan McLeod was excellent in training camp. Caleb Jones looked like a pro in his call-up and Tyler Benson, Cooper Marody, and Cameron Hebig look like they can become depth NHLers one day.

The bad: 

  • One thing making life difficult for the Oilers to make changes are ugly contracts to Milan Lucic, Kris Russell, Andrej Sekera, Ryan Spooner, Brandon Manning, and potentially Mikko Koskinen. There’s a lot of dead weight bogging things down that won’t be easy to deal with.
  • There have been mismanaged prospects under Chiarelli’s watch. Due to the team lacking depth, players like Jesse Puljujarvi, Kailer Yamamoto, and, to a lesser extent Evan Bouchard, were rushed to the NHL level. The organization has to handle these players better in order to get the most out of them long-term.
Advertisement - Continue Reading Below

The future: 

With Chiarelli out of the mix, I think it’s become clear the Oilers aren’t going to be buyers at the trade deadline. They can still make it to the dance with their internal options, namely a healthy Oscar Klefbom, but they are no longer in a position with a desperate general manager at the helm to push for it. Instead, the Oilers would be best to sell at the deadline. I don’t mean a full-on firesale, but if there are teams who could use a player like Alex Chiasson, it’s best for the long-term health of the organization to pull the trigger. If you can find a suitor for somebody like Zack Kassian or Kyle Brodziak, you have to take it.

Edmonton Oilers 2019-20 player review: Tyler Benson

Whoever eventually takes the wheel from the Old Boys Club group effort will have an interesting challenge ahead of them. There’s a lot of talent to work with, especially the best player in the league at the forefront, but there are also obstacles to work around. The worst things Chiarelli did, I think, was losing an MVP-calibre player in Hall and putting the team in cap hell. Finding another quality play driver like Hall and navigating out of cap hell will be the biggest obstacles for whoever comes in next.

When Chiarelli came in, he had a massive load of disposable income in the form of high-quality assets and a blank slate to make his mark. To be fair to Chiarelli, he also had a very obscure roster to fix, loaded with forwards and devoid of blueliners and goalies. He also had a prospect system barren of any kind of depth beyond top picks. The new guy will inherit a more balanced roster with less glaring issues. There won’t be the pressure to execute a Hall of Larsson deal, instead, the new guy will have to be shrewd in making smaller moves that improve the quality of depth at the NHL level.

Bob Nicholson said during the press conference on Wednesday that the suggestions of Old Boys Club involvement were overstated and that Chiarelli’s team was, in fact, Chiarelli’s team. We have to take his word for it, but, still, while this was Chiarelli’s team, Chiarelli was Nicholson’s guy. The situation this time isn’t idiot-proof like it was last time, but righting the ship is doable so long as the Oilers can find the right person for the job.

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below

This article is brought to you by Tourism Jasper

This year, to celebrate Jasper in January’s third decade of winter revelry, the festival is about to get a whole lot louder. A new series of free live shows featuring acclaimed musicians and comedians are coming to the mountains, and with performances every weekend of the festival there’s no shortage of nighttime entertainment. Click here for more info!

  • btrain

    I do think there is reason for optimism and I think the OBC narrative is the distraction but in reality they maybe didnt get involved enough.

    What Chia did in Boston is relatively indistinguishable from what he has done with the Oilers. So for me, the Oilers did give Chia the reins and it’s his fingerprints all over this mess. The overpays, the willingness to move elite level talent, and counting on gambles and gut feelings rather than analytics and league trends are Chia’s calling cards.

    I hold the OBC accountable for not taking back control from Pistol Pete sooner. As a result of a lack of intervention/involvement the Oilers have 3 more in-season contract disasters to deal with in Manning, Spooner, and by far the worst of all (given the timing), Koskinen.

    Chew on this, in 24 games Hammond put up a .941 sv% with the Sens. He literally pulled the Sens into the playoffs. He recieved a 1.35mill over 3 year extension for his efforts. In 56 regular season NHL games Hammond sports a .923 sv%. Koskinen in his 32 NHL games has a .905 sv%. One of these goalies makes league minimum and cant even get into an NHL lineup while the other just received a 4.5mill extension with a NM sweetener to boot. What a parting gift that was! Thanks Pete!

    • A-co

      Burger Bob said Koskinens deal was a collective decision and not solely on Pistol Pete….there are still a couple guys that know a thing or two about winning lingering around which is not good for business BUT makes the little real estate mogul owner happy which is all that matters at the end of the day.

      • btrain

        The alternative to saying it was a group decision was to say that they continued to be hands off with Chia and allowed him to make another immediately critisized decision. From a PR perspective taking ownership of the Koskinen deal was the best play.

  • hockeyartist

    Actually I think the D as a unit is starting to shore up. Jones looks good and will only trend upward. Nurse has reached another level. All depending on how Sekera looks when he comes back.
    The focus should be on plugging those gaping holes on wing.

    • Glencontrolurstik

      The focus for the D should be playing in position & not leaving the goaltending out to dry… That said, with Klef & Sekura coming back they should be able to do that as they won’t be playing every second shift…

  • The Oilers have too many of their top 7 players with losing attitudes and need some of those players traded for players from teams that win, know what it takes to win and refuse to accept team mates that are content with losing. That is called leadership which the Oilers sorely lack. These players can’t be 3rd or 4th liners or bottom pairing d-men but go to top line players. They have to make trades, soon or they can kiss this season goodbye.

  • Spiel

    Nicholson’s own statement was that he thinks they have a good enough group of players in the dressing room to make the playoffs. I don’t see the team making major changes quickly.

  • Alfonso

    Bobby Nick wants to go for the playoffs with a team that is terrible … Jeremy Roenick nails it Jan. 22, 2019 …

    “I’m boggled that this is a professional hockey league team,”Roenick said. “The Edmonton Oilers are so bad. They can’t put two passes together. Their feet and their hands go so much faster than their brains,” he continued. “They have no idea what they’re doing out there and it shows so much. This team might have, from 18 players, the lowest hockey IQ that I’ve ever seen in a long time… It’s embarrassing.”

    • camdog

      Bob’s in charge of press conferences and that is all. If he knew anything about being an NHL GM he’d take on the role until the end of the season. That’ll never happen of course.

  • Goaltender Interference

    The NMCs that Pete handed out like water don’t help very much either.

    Agree with the commenters on the Russell trade. Maybe a slight overpay but unlike some others on the team he’s earning it. The difference in the games he was away and injured was noticeable. His absence had as much impact as Klefbom’s.

    Bob Nicholson is a liar. Right from the Reinhart trade the heavy hand of the OBC has been apparent. If he thinks anyone buys that they aren’t involved then he’s an idiot as much as he is a liar.

  • GK1980

    This will be my last post until this team is competitive and makes the playoffs. I’m not being apart of this new rebuild. It’s been a real pleasure and joy being a part of the nation. Hopefully this team gets better sooner then later.

    • The damage has been done, but non quality management has been retained to continue the gong show would be more accurate. Perhaps they can ruin the 3 good players we have left. The chips have been traded, they have nothing left that they can give up without weakening the team even further. By the time they get better, Katz JR will be the owner and Keegan Lowe will be the GM. I would wager this nonsense is not going to stop as long as Katz remains the owner.

      • AJ88

        What kind of person are you? Your hatred goes far beyond normal. It’s a hockey team that you can choose not to follow, sounds like your life would be much better off, and so would ON, the100’s of posts that are just the same over and over is mind blowing.

        • Don’t read them then . And I wont be. But ON is entertaining. My Fire the OBC mantra is called perseverance, because I believe it is the right thing to do for the beleaguered fan base and the franchise. You would prefer they keep the same clowns driving the same clown car right into the ditch? You have not noticed every media outlet in North America and overseas is mocking the clowns except in Edmonton? You have not noticed that virtually every player has success elsewhere? You are in the minority as far as reality goes. Keep drinking the Kool Aid and propaganda (BS) if you wish, Flames flag goes up on my truck today, until McDavid decides where he is going when he escapes this gong show. This franchise is only good for comic relief at this point. (No offence to the Kool Aid poster!)

  • oil.99.97.11

    A GM of a McDonalds could have done better than Chiarelli. For Eberle and what he gave up for Reinhardt, he should have got no less FOR EACH trade than a top 4 defenceman or a top 6 forward. For Hall, a *real* first pairing D or a young 25+ goal-scoring forward that routinely puts the puck in the net. If he’d got that, maybe he doesn’t need a goalie outside Broissoit and Talbot. And if he does still need a goalie, or he needs more up front, what do you think Lucic’s contract could have brought to town? Pathetic and pitiful. Worst ‘managing’ in the history of the league. We should be challenging for a Cup instead of having our faces rubbed in embarassment.

  • Van isl Oiler

    Playing devils advocate a bit here, but…

    Everyone forgets Sekera has been injured for the past two years. Would things be different if he had been healthy?

  • You just got LITT up!

    Anyone read the Toronto Star article Re: McDavid? Essentially, the Oilers are [email protected] and wasting McDavid’s career … worst part, they’re not wrong.
    I don’t think McDavid will stick around for a rebuild. Trash away!

  • Johnnymaced

    Wow. Even tho the 1st half of the article was still rehashing (for the millionth time) all the harm thats been done, the second half was positive in a cup half full kinda way. First article i read like this. Lets keep it up. Its time to heal and move on.

  • Axe

    Great article.. Was just so painful getting through the first couple of paragraphs and re-living all of the horrible moves made.. I have to agree with some of the other commentators, I don’t view Russel contract as a problem.. But yes I see the point that Chiarelli was spending like a drunken sailor.. And yes a half million here and there will add up and make a difference.. We have to somehow get rid of manning and Spooner I think that’s a good start.. And if Chiasson is not gonna re sign then yes try to get something for him at deadline

  • CMG30

    The trouble is that the line of thinking that resulted in signing a player like Looch to a long term trade-proof contract and valued the character of a player like Russell over actual defensive ability is still ingrained in the Oilers brain trust and sadly much if the fanbase. This is what’s in the water in Edmonton: valuing things in hockey players over and above their actual ability on the ice.

    Sadly, this is why Chirelli was a ‘fit’ in the first place and It’s why having the same dinosaurs picking the next guy will result in more if the same.

    • Datsyukian

      A good point. Character, “grit” and hustle can only get you so far. Today, games and Cups are won on talent and ability much more so than the nebulous “character”.

    • Gorf27

      Dinosaurs for sure. Sorry to be negative, but after listening to Bob yesterday, I am convinced that nothing will really change until season ticket holders cancel, especially those with boxes, and tell the organization they’re doing it because of the OBC. Not only is the on-ice product dreadful, but the entire game experience is bush league. Katz might, just might, get the message if fewer $$ are coming in

  • vetinari

    Every GM needs supporting executives and coaches who can look them in the eye and say “are you sure you want to do that?” and “does this make the team better?” Given Nicholson said that signing and trading players was a collaborative effort between senior management, led by Chiarelli but also including the Old Boy’s Club, wouldn’t it make sense to also replace the brain trust which either approved of Chiarelli’s decisions or were negligent in putting some brakes on his wheeling and dealing? Whoever the next GM is, I hope it is someone from outside the organization, has great evaluation skills when it comes to NHL talent and is uninfluenced by the OBC (preferably because the OBC have also been fired or reassigned to work concessions).

  • >One thing making life difficult for the Oilers to make changes are ugly contracts to Milan Lucic, Kris Russell, Andrej Sekera, Ryan Spooner, Brandon Manning, and potentially Mikko Koskinen. There’s a lot of dead weight bogging things down that won’t be easy to deal with.

    Are we really in any position to call Kris Russell deadweight? If a team actually offered to take his contract for nothing would it really help us? The thought of Benning or Petrovic playing 2nd RHD below Larsson doesn’t sound very nice

  • Heschultzhescores

    So many overpays, so many LTD with NT clauses. So many fringe NHL players. Zero cap space. Too many OBC members still involved behind the scenes, I don’t buy the BS that they keep their noses out. What a challenge for the new GM. Best of lucky buddy.

  • Mc.Rib

    A fan I really admire said to me recently the Oilers last significant player Not taken in the First round was Jarret Stool in 2002, if true that says alot about the team’s scouting staff, and it’s not too good.

  • As much as i hate Hall deal, we did made the playoffs after that. Chiasson is the best contract money/production. Would make sense to try to resign him with little salary increase. Oilers gave him chance again, and he can pay back in term of discount.

    • Hemmercules

      Hahahahah. Discount?!!!! Chiasson is out of town the first chance he gets on a free agency overpay or trade deadline dump. Loyalty isn’t a thing for the Oilers. They have to pay an extra 25% over any team in the league to get a decent player to stick around. It’s not just the fans that loath the OBC either. The entire league knows how brutal the Katz run Oilers are. Every player that leaves generally doesn’t have very good things to say about their time in Edmonton. Been that way for many years.

  • HelpMeBabyJesus

    I understand trying to be positive but let’s go there at the end of this season. This is definitely a period of morning, period! Our prospects are average to below average…period. Klefbom will make no difference once he is the lineup…get that in your head! Embrace how truely mediocre the Oilers are and take joy in the occasional win. At best they may get to play spoiler.

  • HockeyRooster

    The next GM has a hell of a lot of work but this is fixable. My main concern right now is can Nicholson make the right hire? They can’t “Eakins” this hiring. Gotta get it right!
    Let’s go Oilers!

  • madjam

    Nicholson should be gone with Chia , being as he hired him and his team with great long approval in retrospect , not in charge of finding another GM for our team . Nicholson losing faith and luster of the fans . How can Bob and Wayne be unbiased with K.Gretzky being GM supposedly on an interim basis ?

  • Bills Bills

    Still convinced the Reinhardt trade was part of the MacT era or OBC way of decisions made. Koskinen was also an OBC decision Nicholson said it himself. Rushing prospects has been the Oilers way since the day Sather left. What makes you think the PC was the only problem? Because Nicholson hung this entirely on pistol Pete?

    I am not convinced that the much is going to change as long as the direction from the top is still the same.

  • Jordan McNugent-Hallkins

    Brossoit is sitting at a 2.02 GAA and a .943 save % in 12 games with the Jets. I shudder to think what Talbot’s numbers are gonna look like when he gets snapped up by a respectable team. We need a new goalie coach ASAP. Yeah yeah, Hasek himself would look like crap playing behind the Oilers D, but Schwartz had to share some of the blame, no? Goalies must be terrified of coming here to play.

    • HelpMeBabyJesus

      Agreed. With all these ex-Oilers doing well in other organizations it should be telling us something, no? WE SUCK AT PLAYER DEVELOPMENT. Perhaps that is where we should begin to improve until these crap contracts expire.