GDB 55.0 Wrap Up: We’re gonna need a bigger boat, Oilers lose 5-2 to San Jose

Most of that game looked like what I imagine a fart to taste like. Final Score: 5-2 Sharks

I’d be lying to everyone reading this if I said that I wasn’t nervous about how this hockey game was going to play out. The Sharks are rolling right now and they tagged the Oilers for a touchdown in each of their last two meetings and I was really not wanting to sit through a three-peat. That’s just not the best way to kick off a Saturday evening, ya know? Even with Klefbom back, the Oilers have a tendency for porous defending and that’s a recipe for disaster against a team with as many offensive weapons as San Jose can throw over the boards. If they were going to find a way to win then the Oilers were going to need everyone on the bench to elevate themselves and for the goaltending to be as good as it was against the Wild on Thursday. If they couldn’t get that done, the table was set for a fresh look at just how far away this team is from being a threat in the West, and I really wasn’t ready to sit through that movie again.

After working through a temporary stalemate in the opening minutes of the first period, the Sharks were able to open the scoring which took the crowd out early and put the Oilers in chase mode. Unfortunately, Edmonton’s pursuit mode must take a while to engage because rather than pushing back to try and tie things up, they ended up dropping a second goal only moments later. Frankly, had it not been for some luck and a few big saves then this game would have been over before the first period was over, though, if we’re being honest, it’s not like things got much better from there. From start to finish, it was depressing to watch the Oilers struggle to counterpunch against a team that is noticeably fighting at a higher weight class than them. Even when the Oilers managed to get themselves on the board, they were never truly in the fight. At best, this was a lopsided victory. At worst, this was a game where we all knew in our heart of hearts what the outcome would be before the game even started.

To put it another way, the Oilers looked like they had about as much of a chance to win this hockey game as I do to live out the rest of my life as a fire truck, and I don’t think many of us are surprised by that. Thanks, Pete.

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below

The wrap.

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below


  • Ryan Nugent-Hopkins got the Oilers on the board with a power play goal after he picked up a rebound in the slot a roofed over the falling tender. With the Sharks up by three goals, the Oilers needed any signs of life they could muster and Nuge’s goal certainly qualified. I mean, the goal didn’t matter much in the end but I did appreciate knowing that the team had an actual pulse.
  • Zack Kassian showed some very nice hand-eye coordination as he knocked a puck out of the air to beat the goalie and put up a second Oilers goal on the board. Unfortunately, Kass’ goal was too little too late but it was definitely a nice display of skill and touch from the big man.
  • I want to give Adam Larsson some love for the huge hit he threw on Tomas Hertl. Yes, I’m reaching for bright sides.
  • Brad Malone led the team in shots with five. No other Oiler had more than two. Bright side? Maybe? Bah, I don’t know anymore.
  • Best defenceman for the Oilers was easily Darnell Nurse tonight. As he’s done a lot lately, Darryl led the team in ice time with 26:58 after playing a lot of minutes all situations, finishing his night with one shot on net, four hits, and a block.
  • I just want to take a quick minute to say how much I appreciate Oscar Klefbom. After having him out of the lineup for nearly two months, it’s been nice to watch him do his thing over these past few games. No, he’s not yet up to speed and we shouldn’t expect him to be after missing so much time but it’s clear that he’s sorely needed on this blue line. Klefbom finished the night with 22:17 minutes, two shots and five blocks.
  • At least the Oilers didn’t lose 7-2 this time? *ducks from flying fruit*


  • Did you guys know that the Oilers have the most regulation losses at home in the NHL? You do now.
  • Kevin Labanc opened the scoring for the Sharks after his shot from the high slot deflected in off Kevin Gravel’s leg, a shot that Talbot didn’t have much chance on. It was a tough-luck goal for Talbot, but that’s kinda the way things have been going around here lately, isn’t it? Labanc sniped a second goal on the power play in the second period when he was gifted with all kinds of time and space in the slot, beating Talbot high on the glove side. Unsurprisingly, he was able to complete his first career hat trick early in the third period after his line was, once again, able to do as they wished in the offensive zone.
  • Only a few minutes later, Evander Kane put the Sharks up by a pair after he got set up with a tap in by Donskoi and Hertl. If I was a Sharks fan, I would have appreciated the precision of the passing put on by this line, but I love the Oilers so all I got was another dose of sadness.
  • By the time Hertl scored the fifth Sharks goal of the night, I was more focused on how many beers I had left in my fridge. I’m trying to work out the math and figure out how what’s the number of brews I’ll need to get to put back to forget that this game ever happened.
  • After playing very well against the Minnesota Wild, I wasn’t really surprised to see Hitchcock go back to Cam Talbot again. Hitch has said over the past couple of days that he’s going to play the guy that he thinks gives him the best chance to win and doesn’t really care about the contract Koskinen signed three weeks ago. That was not the case tonight. I wouldn’t go so far as to blame Talbot for the lose, the team in front of him wasn’t much better than he was, but I would certainly say that he needs to be much better than what we got from him tonight. Talbot finished the night with 26 saves and a .839 save%.
  • Oh man, did I ever feel bad for Ty Rattie after he took a clapper to the ankle at the end of the first period. Immediately before the play that sent Rattie out of the game, I thought Connor actually beat out the icing call that sent the puck back into the Oilers zone but the linesmen disagreed, and it was very unfortunate to see Rattie get hurt immediately after the resulting draw.
  • The Oilers got roasted in the faceoff circle tonight, winning only 40% of the draws they took. Again, I know some stats folks aren’t big on faceoffs but I’m always of the opinion that it’s better off to start a sequence with the puck than chasing it.
  • Of course I have to eat beets again. Why not? This bet is going to haunt me forever. As always, you can join in on the #BeetCast win cast conversation over on my Twitter account.
GBD 63.0 Wrap Up: Oilers new guys shine in 4-3 loss to Ducks



10:39 San Jose Kevin Labanc (7) ASST: Joe Thornton (18), Marcus Sorensen (8) 1-0
12:18 San Jose Evander Kane (24) ASST: Joonas Donskoi (15), Tomas Hertl (26) 2-0


06:10 San Jose PPG – Kevin Labanc (8) ASST: Timo Meier (29), Evander Kane (23) 3-0
12:00 Edmonton PPG – Ryan Nugent-Hopkins (17) ASST: Alex Chiasson (10) 3-1


01:36 San Jose Kevin Labanc (9) ASST: Joe Thornton (19), Brenden Dillon (16) 4-1
04:24 San Jose Tomas Hertl (25) 5-1
14:03 Edmonton Zack Kassian (8) ASST: Adam Larsson (13) 5-2


Advertisement - Continue Reading Below

Talk to me, Twitter. Tweet at @OilersNation and @jsbmbaggedmilk for your chance to land in the Best of the Tweets.

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below

Source: NHL, Official Game Page, 2/9/2019 – 8:00 pm MT

  • Dark Knight Returns

    Hello writers in the Nation!
    I’m writing to request an article: given that the Oilers won’t make the playoffs and you guys might feel the financial pain from advertising going thin into the Spring, can you put together an article or a series of articles on who could the Oilers be getting back from each team when McDavid requests a trade?
    So for example, if McDavid is traded to Anaheim, what do you think is the return?
    If traded to Arizona, and see on.

    That would be an interesting series and we might as well warm up to the idea.

    He deserves so much better.

    • slats-west

      This won’t happen. There is about 17000 McDavid jerseys at every game (as some have said that’s indicative of a bigger problem). The article should be on Draisaitl. I think he’s a great offensive talent but the only real return for a feasible trade is for #29 not #97. Return could a top 6 legit winger and a #1/2 dman by NHL standards (not the current Oiler braintrust) and a top prospect. MCDavid trade is a death sentence and there is no competent mngt team that can pull it off – you really want Bob Nicholson & Co making that trade of a decade? Really? You would end with something like Jeff Carter, Toffoli and Martinez. Please NO!

      • You just got LITT up!

        Bingo! McDavid will request a trade from this loser organization. The Oilers are rotten and it’ll take years to fix. Mcdavid won’t waste his career playing on lottery teams. Think about this, the oilers suck with mcdavid … They are gonna be brutal without him.

      • Dark Knight Returns

        You’re right. 200%. But when (not if) McDavid requests a trade…. what do we get?
        I know I know I know “he is a class act he will never do that”…. I’d argue he OWES NOTHING to the Oilers, they’d done nothing for him and nothing for this to be a winning team.
        If you’re top employee in your company but your career is at a halt by staying there…. do you stay? If you leave to a company that pays you the same but where you will thrive, can I blame you?

        • slats-west

          Fortunately (or unfortunately) the NHLPA is not normal Labour Law. The Oilers own McDavid there’s a difference. He may leave after his term, just not before.

          For Drai’s salary +9MM that should translate to the fwd + Dman based on current salaries for both. The prospect is the kicker for getting Drai over other teams.

      • nijames

        Unfortunately I believe you are over valuing Draisaitl. You would not get a top 6 forward and a number 1/2 d-man for him. Never a 1/2 d-man, a top 6 forward and a good prospect or high draft pick probably.

  • Total Points

    There has to be problems in the dressing room. This down turn in the Oiler’s play started last year when Drai showed up with a concussion and the rumors started about a fight with another player.

    Oiler’s nation need to look at that and the answer will be there.

    • Stickhandler

      guarantee there is dissension in the locker room, drippdri, lurch and mcnotaleader on 1 side with a couple others, the nugget, (oil’s most responsible player) and nurse and others on the other. A toxic stew nobody is willing to confront. drippy will be lurch in 2 to 3 years.

    • sweatyballs2

      Rumours only, I had dinner with a sports writer well known in edmonton and that was BS, he fell over smoked his face on a table at the bar, at least that is the story I was given

  • Odanada

    Get out the broom Katz
    Howson, Schwartz – fire them yesterday
    Bob Nicholson – fire him today
    Hire a guy OUTSIDE of the organization to search out a new head of hockey ops. Once that is decided, announce that K-Lowe, MacT, Gretz etc will stay to help transition the new Boss, but will then be taking a well earned retirement from the organization. It’s just talk, as they are frozen out immediately – we can give them a big round of applause at the home opener next year, at which point they start their new lives wintering in Arizona.
    The new Boss will hire his own guys to run the show and import his own water if necessary.
    The new Boss will also have to meet with the players and sort through the psychological mess they’ve become and get them focused.
    It is an epic task and can only be accomplished through cleaning house – 80s Oilers be damned.

  • Bluetomorrow

    If I was coaching tonight Draisaitl would have been benched after that Kane goal. He had 2-3 brutal blind pass giveaways by that part of the game and then shows no effort on the backcheck leading to a goal against which basically broke the Oilers back. Everyone blaming the goalies but when you see the team in front of them giving skilled guys absolutely wideopen uncontested shots from 10-15 feet pucks are going to go in no matter what goalie you have in net.

  • Rob19

    Good Lord I hope the Prospects don’t leave Edm, that’s the only playoff team we’re gonna see for a while (and it’s affordable to watch them, in a nice facility too)

  • CMG30

    The only good news here is that another sad letter to the season ticket holders will not not cut it. If Katz wants to save his fanbase hes going to need to make real changes to management…

  • Beer_League_Ringer

    How can we still be talking about a heart transplant for the dressing room? I’m starting to think there are some key guys with off ice issues. I hope I am wrong and it’s just immaturity.

  • madjam

    Is it not possible to build a playoff team around the likes of Hopkins , Draisaitl and McDavid ? Add Nurse and Klefbom to that group as well . 4 years in , and it feels like they need to bust a lot of that group up , if they hope to move forward . Our top 5 underachieving as usual .

    • sweatyballs2

      My concern, KG was head of amateur scouting in Boston the year Boston had 3 consecutive 1st round picks, all 3 are worse then the 3 homeruns that were picked by other teams right after Boston’s 3, new GM needs to replace scouts with people that can recognize talent or we are screwed- Boston 13/14/15 were zboril/ debunk, senyshyn and 16/17/18 were barzal/Kyle Connor/ chabot

      • madjam

        We have spent 4 fruitless years trying to surround our 5 with little to no success . The problem seems more the top 5 , not helping the others enough to make playoffs .

        • Ratt McNuge

          Disagree. When I look at the lineup, I see holes everywhere except in the positions the top 5 are playing in. We have no viable wingers and no talented -dmen.

  • Todd the electron rod

    Let’s ask Alex…
    “Great game by Dadbot! Wow did he ever keep us in it and give us a chance! No question his .839 save% performance tonight demonstrated why he is an elite goaltender and the bonafide go to starter.”

  • Heschultzhescores

    I’m finding a huge difference in intensity watching the Leafs vs Montreal and Calgary vs Vancouver. Those teams seem hungry every shift. The Oiler’s seem like their pre-game meal is from a deep fryer with Oil that needs changing.

  • DannyGallivan

    Turned the game off after the first period as they had no compete. Look at the bright side. Chia is gone and we are now 26th, only 6 pts out of the race for the first overall pick. Sound familiar?

  • usetobewise

    How can what happened with Leon Draisaitl on the second goal be acceptable? A lazy give away pass high in the offensive zone by him which creates a transition going the other way. He allows a 3-on-3 to become a 3-on-2 as he completely quits skating on the back check (Geee why would he want the puck back? He had only just coughed it up) allowing Kane to skate to the corner of the net to receive the pass directly on his tape. Doesn’t that shift pretty much some up why they are losing games? He should have been sat for at least a period, but ideally the rest of the game. How can you promote a culture of accountability by allowing that stuff to carry on?

    • Leichs

      Lol Drai might be the most overrated player in the league. Without McD he would never hit 30 goals and 70 points. Weve all seen him center his own second line and pretty much turn invisible. Although its tough to generate anything anchored to guys like Lucic, Spooner and Reider lol. Sure he scores a couple goals every few games but hes good for at least three blind pass turnovers and lazy backchecks every single game. Id trade him for a Boeser or Pasternak in a heartbeat no question. I keep Nuge over Drai.

      • Datsyukian

        They won’t trade Pastrnak for Draisaitl. I like Draisaitl, but objectively Pastrnak is just more valuable and skilled player overall. He is in the same league as Crosby, Kucherov, McDavid, etc. Draisaitl is a “second-tier” superstar.