What does the next GM have?

At some point over the next few months, Bob Nicholson will stand in front of a podium at Rogers Place and introduce a new General Manager. That person will be given the reins and tasked with building a contender around Connor McDavid. It’s a task that can be summarized in one sentence but as we all know, it’s much more complex than that. The list of chores that the incoming GM will need to accomplish this summer is rather long, but so is the list of attractive assets that sit as building blocks for the next hire to build around.


Dec 13, 2018; Winnipeg, Manitoba, CAN; Edmonton Oilers center Connor McDavid (97) look on during the first period against the Winnipeg Jets at Bell MTS Place. Mandatory Credit: James Carey Lauder-USA TODAY Sports

Finding elite, superstar level players are the most difficult part of building a team. To get them, you either need to make a massive trade a lose a bunch of assets or you need to tank for three or four years and hope the lottery balls are kind to you.

Luckily for the next GM of the Oilers, he already has a franchise player in Connor McDavid. He also has a 50 goal scorer in Leon Draisaitl to slot next to him. The supporting cast around the two young stars is not good, but the best players are already in place. The next GM will get to start his tenure with the most dynamic duo in the NHL.

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below

Most teams in the NHL are looking for high-quality centres. The Oilers have Ryan Nugent-Hopkins on their second line center. When it comes to second line centres, I honestly believe Nugent-Hopkins is in the elite category. He can take tough minutes and has eight years of going head-to-head with the top centermen in the Western Conference. 

Having a duo like McDavid and Draisaitl is something every single rebuilding team in the league is trying to get. A second line centre like Nugent-Hopkins is something that every GM in the league would love to have. Those are fantastic building blocks and are often, some of the toughest pieces to acquire when trying to build a team. The new GM has those pieces in their primes.

After those three, their forward group is about as far away from being competitive as any other group in the NHL. Finding solid depth pieces and support players for the teams’ skilled pieces will no doubt be difficult, but it’s easier than finding high-end skill.


Oct 21, 2017; Philadelphia, PA, USA; Edmonton Oilers defenseman Oscar Klefbom (77) in action during the first period against the Philadelphia Flyers at Wells Fargo Center. Mandatory Credit: Derik Hamilton-USA TODAY Sports

The Oilers have been searching for a top pairing, puck-moving defenseman for over a decade. I don’t expect that search to magically stop this summer. Those are just very tough trades to find and complete.

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below

The defence that the incoming GM will inherit is not perfect, but there are some nice pieces that do exist. I believe Oscar Klefbom is already a top-pairing defenseman and he’s locked up on a great contract for the next four years. Darnell Nurse is a young top-four defenseman who the next GM will have a chance to sign to whatever type of contract he desires (long or short term).

Andrej Sekera and Adam Larsson are more experienced than the first two and while they also have some holes in their games, you can’t deny that they’re effective NHL defenders.

The young group that features Evan Bouchard, Caleb Jones, Ethan Bear, and Dmitri Samorukov also looks very promising. There are some good pieces on the blueline, even if they won’t be ready for the 2019-20 season.

The new GM will no doubt be looking for that big, offensive, top pairing defenseman this summer but even if he can’t get that piece, he still has a group of six defenders who anchored this team to a 103 point season in 2016-17 plus a handful of young prospects. That’s a good start.


If the next GM were to sit me down and ask me about the goaltending situation he’ll have to deal with in Edmonton, I would simply say “you’re pretty screwed, man”. The current regime decided that committing $4.5 million to Mikko Koskinen for the next three seasons was smart and now whoever takes over this organization is stuck with it. The only thing that the next GM can really do is find the best backup goaltender on the market. That’s it. They’re stuck with Koskinen as their starter.

Now, finding a quality backup would be easy if you had a bunch of cap space to play with. The next Oilers GM won’t have that luxury when he takes over the team.

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below


I’m not calling it “cap hell” anymore because there are plenty of ways for the Oilers to give themselves a little breathing room. Here is my quick summary of the Oilers cap situation:

  • Many believe that the salary cap will go up by $3-4 million for next season. If we assume the low-end of that, the Oilers will start the offseason with $11.4 million in cap space.
  • They have plenty of free agents who they’ll let walk, but I think they will no doubt bring back Alex Chiasson, Jesse Puljujarvi, and Jujhar Khaira.
  • I believe it will cost a maximum of $4.5 million to resign those four players. That means the Oilers could have as much as $7 million in cap space with 11 forwards, six defensemen, and one goalie. That’s not the worst situation possible. A seventh defenseman, 13th forward, and a backup should not cost more than $3.5 million which means the Oilers could afford to bring in one $3 million player this summer. 

The situation is more complex, and they need to bring in more than one quality player who makes $3 million but, if the incoming GM wants to create some added cap space, there are two ways he could do so rather quickly.

  • Buying out Sam Gagner immediately saves the team $2 million against the cap.
  • Trading Matt Benning for a draft pick and replacing him on the roster with Caleb Jones saves the team roughly $1.2 million against the cap.

Those are two quick solutions which could give them an extra $3.2 million in wiggle room. If that were to happen, then the team could suddenly sign their in-house free agents, fill out the fringe of their roster, and have around $6 million in cap space. I’m not saying those are good or bad ideas, but they’re possible solutions to the cap problem. They could also look at trading big contracts like Kris Russell, Andrej Sekera, Milan Lucic (nearly impossible), or Adam Larsson. Those moves create bigger holes on the roster and is a whole different conversation.

My point, the Oilers are tight against the cap, but it isn’t quite “cap hell”. With two simple transactions, they could start the summer with just north of $6million.

The next GM will have to do some heavy lifting, I’m not denying that, but you also can’t argue that he isn’t exactly starting with nothing. There are some great pieces on the Edmonton Oilers roster, they just need more support. Finding cheap support should be the main focus of the incoming General Manager.

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below

  • Dallas Eakins Hair

    Whoever the next GM is their initials better not be K.G. Sorry the Oilers are a huge mess and its really going to take a lot to right the mess we are in and Keith isnt the person to lead the charge. Chia left one hell of a mess, we have a ton of contracts that are going to be hard to pawn off on other teams we have a ton of needs and not a lot of Cap cash to spend and we have players we would love to trade but its going to take one hell of a snake oil salesman in a GM to get rid of them. Manning Petrovic those contracts need to go, Petrrovic might not be that hard, Mannings will be a difficult one. If I am the GM I look at trying to Trade Benning for a forward and using Kevin Gravel in his place, Gravel seems fairly steady when he gets to play and we need to clear some cash up and trading Benning may help us in getting a forward to help with the 3 and 4th lines that maybe can put pucks in the net. I love Russel and I dont mind Larsson, but I think if you can trade them and free up that cash, then you have to do it.

    Reider like the guys heart but not the lack of goals or points…. unless you can bring him back dirt cheap on a 1 year..okay if not so be it.Gange I have always liked, but if we could move him for someone else that costs less and that can put up a few points, I would jump on that. Cave I would keep, the kid isnt a liability, he can win faceoffs and he isnt afraid to go into the dirty areas or try and make plays. I am torn on Kassian… he disappeared for a season and a half and then wanted out and came on in the second half this season, what worries me is if he disappears next season for half a season again… The Oilers just cant have that happen..JJ I would resign, I think he got injured earlier in a season maybe with a hit or fight and then his foot the guy didnt seem at all like himself from the year before, I think he comes back refreshed and ready to go at camp. Poolparty….man that’s tough, I think the kid needs a fresh start… not only here but maybe even elsewhere, and it is too bad cause he was flying in the preseason and brimming with confidence and then I dont know what happened from there but he just seemed shattered after that, maybe a new coach will do wonders for him, but the kid needs to play, if not here then in Bakersfiled he can not be playing 6 minutes a night or be in the pressbox, if the Oilers dont think he will get it done then trade him for what you can and you have to call it a day… I hate t say that I think he has potential just his development has been terrible here. I would be getting on the horn with Koskinen agent and saying get him some rest and then get him working with a goalie coach with NHL experience and away from Schwartz. get him working on not making himself so small in net, not going down so early and staying down so long and his glove hand… and get that happening before camp. I would be looking for a 1A cause man this last stretch has me worried about Koskinen next year. I dont think Stolarz did bad in the games he did play considering most were mop , but I dont think he is the guy, would I sign him for Bakersfield, sure… I think the potential could be there if he stays away from Schwartz, but the Oilers need another goalie who can do at least 25 to 35 games. Get rid of the pro scoUt staff, the assistant coaches, goalie coach Schwartz, hows son Lowe and MacT all need to go as well, let Hitch go consult and find a different HC..

    • Gorf27

      Good comments, especially your last sentence: get rid of all those people! In addition, fire anyone else who went along with the Koskinen deal…which was, and remains, the single stupidest move these idiots have made. Bob said in his post-Chiarelli that presser that the Koski deal was a group decision. Wow! This admission alone is mindboggling! You’ve decided to dismiss the GM, but you somehow allow him to make this nonsensical signing just before you show him the door? How does that happen?
      Of course, nobody will be fired. This is a smug, incompetent group with fancy job titles and a very impressive record of massive failure and zero accountability

  • OilerForLife

    Good job pointing out that the problem isn’t the core players, which are primarily centermen, or the D men.

    The big time problem is scoring on the wings, and penalty killing.

    Forget about depth on the wings, they are so weak, that they hardly have any performers there. Kassian and Chaisson are the only ones that who had success this past season, and then they trade away Caggiula. Then things really fell apart. He laughed when Manning was sent to the AHL, and was then sent to the press box in the AHL.

    The jury is still out on goaltending.

  • This team needs to trade/buy out a lot of deadwood and undeserved contracts to free up space to trade for or sign players from winning organizations with leadership qualities this team desperately needs. Anyone who believes that the Oilers are one or two players away from being a cup contender are not looking at this team objectively. If big changes aren’t made the Oiler fans will be having this conversation of why can’t we make the playoffs, again next year.

  • J.P Michaels

    What does the next GM have?
    Depends on when they make their decision…. no time to hire a new HC, no time to attend training camp, not be at the draft table, no 29 and 97 because they’re traded already!!!! Get the drift???