Photo Credit: Perry Nelson-USA TODAY Sports

Rise of the sad sacks

It’s mid-September with training camp just around the corner, a time when optimism abounds in every NHL city in one form or another. That holds especially true for fans of the Toronto Maple Leafs and Edmonton Oilers, and with good reason. Both teams look like they have a chance to be Stanley Cup contenders. Think back over the last decade or so and let that sink in for a minute.

What about a Toronto-Edmonton Cup final in 2018 or 2019? Is it likely? I don’t know about that. Is it possible? I bet if you took a vote of both long-suffering fan bases here and now, the answer would be “yes.” We’ll see. What I do know is anybody suggesting such a thing just two or three years ago would’ve been laughed off as delusional, given the sad sack state of both franchises.

Yet, here were are. Out in Toronto, with Auston Matthews and the Maple Leafs coming off a 95-point season, long-time columnist Steve Simmons is daring to dream about the possibility of a Stanley Cup for the Maple Leafs – if not now, then not that far down the road. Here in Edmonton, many fans are thinking much the same thing about Connor McDavid and the Oilers, who are coming off a 103-point campaign.

Edmonton’s first playoff appearance since making the Cup final in 2006, a second-round loss in seven games to the Anaheim Ducks, came on the heels of 47-26-9 record. That marked a 33-point improvement over the 31-43-8 record they managed in 2015-16 and a 41-point gain over their 24-44-14 record of 2014-15. The Maple Leafs, meanwhile, made the playoffs for just the second time in 12 seasons. They went 40-27-15, good for a 26-point improvement over 2015-16 (29-42-11) and a 27-point gain on 2014-15 (30-44-8). Both outfits, clearly, have pulled themselves out of the ditch.

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below
Advertisement - Continue Reading Below


Nov 29, 2016; Edmonton, Alberta, CAN; Edmonton Oilers forward Connor McDavid (97) and Toronto Maple Leafs forward Leo Komarov (47) chase a loose puck during the third period at Rogers Place. Mandatory Credit: Perry Nelson-USA TODAY Sports

Simmons, who is one of those Hogtown writers who regularly rubs Oiler fans raw (and who I seldom agree with), is certainly all-in on coach Mike Babcock and the unquestionably talented young Maple Leafs. Here’s a snippet or two of his take Monday about the team he covers. For context, the entire item is here.

“You can see a Stanley Cup from here. Maybe for the first time since the Stanley Cup season of 1967, you can see it. You can envision it. You can believe in it. You can close your eyes and actually picture Gary Bettman calling Auston Matthews — assuming he will eventually be granted the captaincy — to come up and grab the Cup. The Toronto Maple Leafs: future Stanley Cup champion.

“This isn’t a dream or a joke, it’s a path. It’s a destination. The seemingly impossible eventually becoming possible. For most of our lives, we haven’t known anything like this at all. You could hope, but it was never realistic. You could predict, but it wasn’t logical. There hasn’t been a Maple Leafs team in 50 years that looked to be the anywhere near the part of a champion in September — and even that old 1967 team, and they were old, didn’t begin the season as any kind of favourites.”

It’s been a long time between sips of champagne in both cities. Replace 1967 with 1990, when the Oilers hoisted their fifth Cup, and Matthews with McDavid, and a lot of fans around here feel the same way about the Oilers, even if they’re not spinning it into column form like Simmons has. For the first time in a long time, I don’t think the notion of either team contending, if not this season then in the next two or three, is ridiculous. There is work to do for both teams, of course, but it’s no joke.

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below


Apr 1, 2017; Edmonton, Alberta, CAN; The Edmonton Oilers celebrate an overtime goal by forward Leon Draisaitl (29) against the Anaheim Ducks at Rogers Place. Mandatory Credit: Perry Nelson-USA TODAY Sports

The arrival of an established winner behind the bench like Babcock was the beginning of the turnaround for the Maple Leafs, but it’s the core of young talent – namely the trio of Matthews, a 40-goal man last season, William Nylander and Mitch Marner – that’s the real reason for optimism. Toronto’s best players are their young players. There is, at long last, something to build around, even with a blue line that looks thin to me.

Much the same thing here in Edmonton. The arrival of GM Peter Chiarelli and coach Todd McLellan after years of instability in the front office and behind the bench was a start. That said, the Golden Ticket that landed McDavid was the game-changer. Then, there’s the emergence of Leon Draisaitl and Oscar Klefbom and the additions of Cam Talbot, Patrick Maroon and Adam Larsson. This is the best core group the Oilers have had since the 1980s.

Yes, there are holes to fill on both rosters, and that process will continue when training camp opens, but there’s reason to believe with the cornerstones pieces in place – McDavid and Draisaitl, Matthews, Marner and Nylander. That’s a pretty talented group right there, no? Of course, teams like the Washington Capitals, Pittsburgh Penguins, Chicago Blackhawks and Anaheim Ducks aren’t going to stand around and let the Maple Leafs and Oilers blow by them. No chance.

Sad sacks no more, these outfits. There is hope in Hogtown and expectations in Edmonton — the likes of which we haven’t seen in years and years. A Cup for one of them this season? We’ll see about that. Contenders? Yes.


  • Ty Guy

    I’m sure once the leafs add John Tavares and every other high profile Ontario born player that is looking to become a free agent (because they all want to play in Toronto) in the next few years, they will still be hoping for the cup….they will need to pry it from Oilers and the Oil have Conner…sorry TO.

  • Ready to Win

    I think some of Pat Quinn’s teams looked better in September than this year’s Leafs, but its unsurprising that Simmons is dismissing teams he once showered praise on.

    • btrain

      Exactly. The Leafs have youthful optimism like they haven’t maybe ever had, but pre-cap days, they stacked their teams and still failed. The 2003 roster had a number high profile Vets sprinkled with some young talent that couldn’t get the job done:
      – Sundin
      – Nolan
      – Antropov
      – Mogilny
      – Leetch
      – McCabe
      – Kaberle
      – Belfour
      – Francis
      – Nieundyk
      – Roberts

  • vetinari

    I look at the Leaf roster and still see weakness on the blue line compared to their Eastern conference peers– couple that with a new Nylander contract next year and the Matthews & Marner contract extensions for 2019/20 and they, too, will be pressed into cap hell and will have a challenge to fill out a balanced roster.

  • Maple Mousse

    You’d think that when the Leafs almost made the Cup Finals in the 90s that the team could have “seen” the Cup being close, as well. Otherwise they’d be expecting defeat?

    Odd that the 1967 Cup win was used I guess.

  • Roberto

    I’m actually not even sure if the leafs will make the playoffs this season… Tampa seems like they should surely be back in the playoffs, and Philly, NYI and Florida aren’t far removed from good seasons. Didn’t the Leafs lose first round, just like everyone expected? In Edmonton, there was a time when the Oilers had very good, young, skilled forwards (Hall, Yak, RNH, Ebs, Etc…). Most of those guys even had 1 or more very good seasons…. Even Yaks rookie season was OK. I agree that none of those guys are Auston Matthews, but that’s a lot of TO media bias from Simmons. I would not be surprised at all to see all of TO’s young guys regress this season.

  • Explicit

    Not to be “that guy”… but Matthews only had 69 points. It’s good to see Canadian teams on the rise finally, but some people in Toronto are getting a little carried away.

    Hope Edmonton meets Toronto in the final, it’d be an easy sweep!!

    • Randaman

      I’m a diehard Oiler fan but statements like that make you sound like a Leafs fan. The Leafs gave us all kinds of trouble last year if I remember correctly! Be better

  • Makaveli

    Hi Robin, I enjoy reading your articles but this one could have used a little editing.

    Also, I hate to mention this again but the new website leaves much to be desired.
    Too many adds slowing the site down.
    Always having to enter my username and PW to comment even though I tell my computer to remember the login credentials.
    No edit button for comments.
    Comment section layout in general
    Navigating to older articles by using the “next page” feature is broken

    Come on ON, the site needs a major fix.

    • camdog

      “What about a Toronto-Edmonton Cup final in 2017 or 2018?” Hard to believe next year will already be the 2018 Stanley Cup Final… Where did the time go?

    • Oilers G- Nations Poet Laureate

      Just “Bookmark” the site, or “Save to Favourites Bar”….that way you REMAIN logged in and don’t have to keep entering your UN and PW, and I agree with the “Edit button” (or lack thereof)…
      The rest of your complaints are “meh*” IMO.

      *read as Not that big of a deal.

    • Anton CP

      Should go back in time, let’s say, 3 years ago, and tell Leafs fans that Kessel will be 2 time Stanley Cup Champion (which…well…also applied to Justin Schultz)

  • if you ever wanted to know what it’s like to be simultaneous arrogant and ignorant, just read a Steve Simmons article. I assume he maintains employment because his stories get a lot of readership based on him being universally loathed. People just read his garbage to be angry.

  • oilerjed

    The hate that Toronto fans will heap on the Oilers will be glorious as they watch their best chance of a championship in years go down in flames thanks to it happening in the Connor era 🙂

    There is a certain poetry in it that the best player Ontario has put out since Gretzky will be the one to keep the cup out of their grasping hands.