WWYDW: Should the Oilers get a new backup goalie?


It isn’t debatable that Cam Talbot has had an excellent
season. Edmonton’s starting goaltender leads the league with 43 appearances,
two more than the next-busiest goalie, and has a very solid 0.919 save

More debatable is whether he should be playing so much, and
what would happen to the Oilers if he got hurt. In this week’s edition of What
Would You Do Wednesday, we ask whether Edmonton should look into getting a more
experienced backup to lighten Talbot’s load.

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below


The team’s current No. 2 is Laurent Brossoit. Brossoit has
spent the last two years playing extremely well in the AHL, but struggled when
given a shot at major-league minutes in 2015-16. This year, he’s been less
impressive in the minors, but handled his only NHL appearance well, making 38
saves on 41 shots in a win over Calgary.

Brossoit needs to clear waivers next season, so there isn’t
really a development angle to this. He needs to make the jump soon. We just don’t
know for sure whether or not he can, and there’s risk involved in finding out.

There are other options.

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below

One imagines that the New York Islanders would love to move
Jaroslav Halak. The long-time NHL starter was waived and shipped to the minors
at the start of the month, the loser of a three-way battle for minutes to
Thomas Greiss and the cheaper, younger Jean-Francois Berube. He has another
year after this one at a $4.5 million
cap hit

That’s a lot of money to take on, which is why Halak cleared
waivers despite what was effectively 20-medicore games following a long and
decent career. Any deal for him would involve figuring out money—perhaps sending
some back (Benoit Pouliot, Mark Fayne, maybe Matt Hendricks) or getting the
Isles to retain salary. But Halak would give Edmonton a veteran fallback option
both this year and next.

Ken Holland breaks down the week ahead for the Edmonton Oilers

Also expensive, but in the final year
of his deal
, is Ondrej Pavelec. The Winnipeg Jets banished him to the AHL
at the start of the season, but with both of their major-league options
struggling turned to him last week. He’s now 2-2-0 with a 0.897 save percentage
on the season.

Unlike Halak, Pavelec has an unimpressive track record. He’s
spent the last seven years as either a starter or 1B goaltender, and in five of
those seasons has come in with a save percentage of 0.906 or lower.

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below

Reto Berra is another popular goaltending candidate. A
pending free agent with a modest cap
, there are no financial concerns with regard to his deal. He provided
quality minutes as a designated No. 2 for Colorado in each of the last two
seasons. This year, he’s been a strong starting option for the AHL’s
Springfield Falcons. With Roberto Luongo and James Reimer ahead of him, Florida
can afford to make a trade.

Those three players are the most obvious candidates for a
trade, but they aren’t the only ones, and the list is only going to get longer
as teams fall out of playoff contention.

How interested should the Oilers be? Does Brossoit deserve
more time, or should Edmonton bring in a veteran immediately, one whom Todd McLellan
can have confidence in and will play regularly?  

  • OriginalPouzar

    My only concern with adding a more proven NHL back-up (on an expiring deal) is adding a contract to put us at 49 contracts which could limit other potential deadline deals (i.e. a RW or 3C upgrade).

    At the end of the day, if Talbot gets hurt, there really aren’t any “available” goalies that will be able to save the season.

  • toprightcorner

    Reto Berra all the way. He has back up expirience and that is likely better then a career starter playing once every 8 games.

    I would rather have Pouliot on the ice then trade him for a backup playing 15 games a year.

    Can’t give LB 3-4 more games to see how he handles it, that is 20 games and 6 weeks at least. He has his big win, maybe give him one more game until a trade can be made for Berra and send him back down with confidence knowing he can play in the NHL and he can get in more games next year when he can be the back up.

    Nobody who is still developing gets better playing once ever 2-3 weeks and nobody gets worse playing more games developing in the AHL.

    PLUS, even though I don’t think LB is at risk to expansion draft, I would hate to see him play fantastic for 5 games, get on their radar and have Vegas pick him as their back up. That would make all fans cry!

  • We need to give Brossoit 3-5 starts before the deadline. Im not too worried about Vegas taking him. With the rate Talbot is playing Brossoit will probably play 10 games at most so he’d need to have a 30 save shut out and win every start for Vegas to even considering using a pick on him

  • Jaxon

    Are the Islanders sure they’ll be able to sign Greiss? Or do they have a gentleman’s agreement and are not signing him so they don’t have to protect him? Or is that even a thing?

    EDIT: Nilsson in Buffalo and Kinkaid in New Jersey are also interesting options who will be UFAs this summer on seller teams.

  • jonnyquixote

    Other than Halak, whose $4.5 million contract next season makes it an impossibility, I don’t see any of those players as being a clear upgrade on Broissot.

    So then the answer is either give Broissot a chance or find different options. There’s probably not an obviously better one out there, especially given the unpredictability of the job (We were all hoping for Enroth during this off-season, but look at how he did).

  • OilCan2

    Keep Brossoit and Ennis. Their numbers are both decent and LB was an All Star in the AHL last year. If they both make it past the Vegas draft then you have all summer to decide on goalie B for next year.