WWYDW: Navigating Klefbom’s injury

The Oilers had a great game against Colorado on Tuesday night, but the night was spoiled by the loss of Oscar Klefbom. After the game, it was revealed Klefbom will miss “weeks” due to a broken finger, which is obviously a massive blow to the Oilers.

Honestly, after Connor McDavid, Klefbom might be the Oilers’ most important skater. He’s emerged as the team’s No. 1 defender, thriving at both ends of the ice as both a rock-solid defender and a strong offensive catalyst, and he’s been a workhorse, logging just over 25 minutes per game. The Oilers will now have to navigate life without their top defender, replacing a large number of minutes at both ends of the ice.

That brings us to this week’s What Would You Do Wednesday question. How should the Oilers navigate Oscar Klefbom’s injury? Should they just re-shuffle their current options to compensate him not being in the lineup? Or is his loss important enough they should explore external options?

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below

As of right now, it looks like the Oilers would slide up Darnell Nurse to the top pairing with Adam Larsson, which creates a domino effect with the rest of the pairings. Nurse and Kris Russell have been the second pair, but Russell would presumably slide into the second left spot, meaning Matt Benning would have to jump up to the second pairing. That would then leave Kevin Gravel, Jason Garrison, and Chris Wideman to fill up the third pair.

I don’t mind Nurse sliding up with Larsson to the top pair. Nurse and Larsson played a lot together last year and he’s a competent defender who can handle an increase in minutes. It’s the next two pairings and the domino effect which is more worrying. Benning has been solid on the third pair with Gravel but, as we saw last year, he struggled in an increased role.

Oilersnation Pre Game Podcast - Edmonton Oilers vs Chicago Blackhawks

In the AHL, Ethan Bear figured to be the first call-up. We all assumed Bear would be on the team as soon as Evan Bouchard was returned to the OHL, but that hasn’t happened yet. There’s also Caleb Jones, a rookie in the AHL who has 12 points through 21 games. I don’t know if adding a rookie to the mix will help much, but Bear would be a nice replacement for Klefbom on the team’s first power play.

Then there are external options. It’s well known the Oilers should add to their blueline in some capacity to take the next step and become a contending team. I’m not sure if they can find their right-handed, offensive defenceman in the middle of the season, but there are rental options out there that can help deepen the blueline right now.

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below

Names on rebuilding teams who immediately come to mind are Jay Bouwmeester on the Blues, Alex Edler on the Canucks, Niklas Kronwall on the Red Wings, and Alex Petrovic on the Panthers. Obviously, these players aren’t perfect, but they provide legitimate NHL veteran depth and are probably more reliable than giving Benning increased minutes on the second pair and having a third pair of Gravel and Garrison or Wideman.

What say you, Nation? How do you organize the blueline with Klefbom out? Can the Oilers patch it together internally or should they dive in and make an early rental acquisition? 

  • Bills Bills

    Let’s be honest, trading for someone is pretty much a non starter as the team does not have cap space for it. Trading for another 6-7 guy that does fit under the cap, is not going to solve any problems either. Weeks without Klefbom is certainly devastating. This is where Hitchcock is going to earn his dollars. They have no real option but to try and solve this from within.

    I am interested to see how the team responds defensively. Tomorrow night is going to either be a good test or it is going to be a sign of things to come.

    • Glencontrolurstik

      I am about to be trashed “big-time”… Are you sitting down?
      We can probably ask Kevin Bieksa to help out for a few months?
      I could actually see Chia/Hitch doing that…

  • OilCan2

    Bouchard. Kidding. Jones. Done deal. Both of these guys will be our future; this spring for the playoffs will be interesting. Sekera and Klefbom both look to be returning sometime in January. All I wwwwwwwant for Christmas is more w’s.

  • Jaxon

    Spooner out for one of Petrovic, Folin, Lovejoy, Rutta, or Bortuzzo. Petrovic (Florida, Eastern team out of playoff picture) makes the most sense. They’re all RHD on expiring contacts on currently non-playoff teams so they’d be rentals but I think there would be a great chance Petrovic would re-sign for his hometown Oilers. He’s also still young so his play shouldn’t fall off anytime soon. He’s decent as third pair guy who can do well at 2nd pair too. He’s big and has some (some) offensive skill to his game. Dump Spooner’s too expensive contact for a serviceable and possibly long term right D. Florida has the cap space to take on Spooner’s 3.1M in exchange for Petrovic’s 1.95M. Or the cheap route is to gamble on Justin Holl, who should be given a chance but isn’t getting it in Toronto. He was arguably the best RHD not in the NHL last season but has played only one game this year and has to be placed on waivers to get sent down. He’s big, fast, dependable and showed some great offense last year.

    • Jaxon

      Plus Petrovic is willing to do his gloves against other fighters (ex. Tom Wilson, Matt Martin, JT. Brown, Kevin Bieksa).


      Would be one of the toughest units in the NHL to put out at the end of a game with a big lead if the other team starts to get chippy.

      • Wiggleswag

        This tells me Russell would be better off on the left and Nurse needs to smarten up. Sooner or later they need to use/see Wideman maybe Gravel can help him now.