Photo Credit: Isaiah J. Downing-USA TODAY Sports

2019 Resolution: Depth Scoring

Every October fans across the NHL have renewed hope for their team, especially those in cities where their beloved team missed the playoffs. Optimism runs high, as it should. There is no point being a fan if you don’t think, even for a brief moment, your team will improve. Fans in Buffalo, Montreal, Dallas and Calgary should be elated right now. Their teams are in a playoff spot after missing the postseason last year and fans in Vancouver, Long Island and here in Edmonton are still in the hunt. If a few things go right, they could get in.

2018 ended with a thud for the Oilers and their fans. Six consecutive losses saw the Blue and Orange fall out of a playoff spot, but 2019 started with a win and the Oilers have a big weekend coming up in Los Angeles and Anaheim on Saturday and Sunday. Edmonton sits four points back of the Ducks, with a game in hand, for the final wild card spot in the Western Conference.

A new year brings similar optimism for many in our everyday lives. Maybe you’re embarking on a New Year resolution to eat better, start working out, run 10KM or a marathon, get a new job, find a boyfriend or girlfriend or simply hope you have more fun, happiness and success in 2019. Whatever it is, I wish you well.

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below

It is obvious what the Oilers resolution is (or should be): get some complementary scoring.

The scary part for head coach Ken Hitchcock is the secondary scoring is getting worse, not better.

Connor McDavid (23), Leon Draisaitl (22), Alex Chiasson (16) and Ryan Nugent-Hopkins (14) and are their top four goal scorers. Chiasson has missed the past three games and the final 40 minutes of the Vancouver tilt on December 27th, so for the past four games the Oilers have three forwards they can rely on to score. It isn’t pretty.

Of their previous 20 goals scored by forwards, these four players have scored 19 of them. Jesse Puljujarvi scored against the Blues on December 18th. The Oilers have one goal outside of their top-four forwards since December 14th. It is bordering on amazing how little offensive support McDavid and Draisaitl especially, and to a lesser extent Nugent-Hopkins, are getting.

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below

The good news is Chiasson could return this weekend, and if he does Hitchcock has to play with him with RNH, doesn’t he? Chiasson has scored two goals in 78 minutes (5×5) with RNH and two goals in 167 minutes with McDavid, so put him on the right wing second line and give RNH a fighting chance to take some of the offensive burden off the shoulders of McDavid and Draisaitl. I’d put Jujhar Khaira on the left wing, since he was producing well prior to his suspension on Nugent-Hopkins’ wing, but since they have no third line centre option (Ryan Strome isn’t great, but he’d fit that role right now), Hitchcock likely can’t do that. So I guess you give Ryan Spooner a look. At least he’s scored a few goals, unlike Milan Lucic and Tobias Rieder.

Chiasson on the second line makes the most sense. I’m sorry, but Puljujarvi isn’t producing and Hitchcock and the management can’t stubbornly keep him on RNH’s wing with the “hope” he starts to score. I should rephrase that. They can keep him there, but if they want to improve their chances of winning then Chiasson should slot in their upon his return. Puljujarvi has one goal in his past 15 games, two in his last 25 and three all season. Chiasson has 16 goals. Put the player who is producing now on the second line. I know where Puljujarvi should be, but the organization still believes he will develop better in the NHL. It is pointless to rehash it, but at the very least play him on a third line with Khaira and one of Rieder or Lucic and move forward.


Nov 27, 2018; Edmonton, Alberta, CAN; Dallas Stars defensemen Joel Hanley (39) tries to check Edmonton Oilers forward Jesse Puljujarvi (98) during the third period at Rogers Place. Mandatory Credit: Perry Nelson-USA TODAY Sports

I’ve never seen this many forwards struggle to score like the majority of the Oilers forwards. The Oilers top-four forwards have combined for 75 goals. The other forwards have scored 24 goals, which is now 16 due to the trade of Drake Caggiula (seven goals) and Ryan Strome (one goal). Yes, the remaining eight forward spots for Saturday’s game in Los Angeles (assuming Chiasson plays) will be filled out by forwards who have combined to score 16 goals for the Oilers this season. They’ve combined to play 282 games for the Oilers this season. If I hadn’t watched every game, I wouldn’t believe it.

Puljujarvi has three goals in 29 games.
Kyle Brodziak has three in 38 games.
Ryan Spooner has two in 19 games.
Ty Rattie has two in 24.
Kharia has two in 36.
Zack Kassian has two in 37.
Kailer Yamamoto has one in 13
Milan Lucic has one in 40.
Joseph Gambardella has zero in two games.
Tobias Rieder has zero in 27 games.

Captain Obvious comes to the conclusion this is not good, and it looks worse when you compare them to the other teams in the West. Here is how the west matches up comparing their top-four goal scorers and then the rest of their forwards.

TEAM          TOP FOUR      Rest of FWDS      TOTAL
Calgary             81                    46                  127
Colorado          76                    47                   123
Edmonton        75                    24                    99
Winnipeg         74                    40                   114
San Jose           71                    59                   130
Chicago            67                    36                   103
Vancouver        64                    47                   111
Vegas               54                    60                   114
Minnesota       51                    33                     84
Dallas              50                     37                    87
St.Louis           46                     38                    84
Nashville         45                    59                    104
Anaheim         41                    42                     83
Arizona           36                    50                     86

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below

Minnesota is the closest to the Oilers with 33 goals from their bottom eight spots, but they still have all those players on the roster, while the Oilers have 16 goals from their remaining roster. Carolina is the closest Eastern team and they too have 33 goals from the bottom eight spots. I knew the Oilers depth production was limited, but when you compare it to other teams it magnifies how anemic it has been.

I’d like to believe they will be able to chip in more than 24 goals in the second half of the season, but with Caggiula’s departure that makes it much less likely unless one or two of the Oilers bottom eight get on a hot streak.

I’m sure some of you are curious about the Eastern Conference as well.

TEAM          TOP FOUR      Rest of FWDS      TOTAL
Tampa Bay        82                    67                  149
Toronto             72                    51                  123
Pittsburgh         67                    56                  123
Columbus         66                    40                  106
Washington      63                    52                  115
Boston              61                    38                   99
Florida              60                    45                  105
Ottawa             60                    39                    99
Buffalo             58                    36                    94
Montreal          55                    54                   109
New Jersey       53                   51                    104
NY Rangers      51                   39                     90
Detroit             50                    45                    95
NY Islanders    48                    52                    100
Philadelphia    48                    43                     91
Carolina          46                    33                     79

How good is Tampa Bay’s depth scoring? Their bottom eight has more goals than every team’s top-four scorers except Calgary, Colorado, Edmonton, Toronto and Winnipeg. The Bolts are very deep.


Nov 27, 2018; Edmonton, Alberta, CAN; Edmonton Oilers head coach Ken Hitchcock watches a game against the Dallas Stars from the bench at Rogers Place. Mandatory Credit: Perry Nelson-USA TODAY Sports

Ken Hitchcock said the Oilers score enough, but they need to defend better. I see why he said that during their losing streak, but if you look at the Oilers entire season their overall team defence isn’t nearly as bad as their lack of complementary scoring.

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below

The Oilers have allowed 80 goals against at 5×5. They are seventh in the Western Conference, better than San Jose (97) and Vegas (85) and just below Colorado (79), Calgary (77), Winnipeg (77) and Dallas (76). The Ducks are in the playoffs because John Gibson is playing lights out and they’ve allowed a Western Conference-low 65 goals at 5×5, while the Nashville Predators dominant blueline has them at 67 5×5 goals against. I don’t see GA as the Oilers main issue. Of course it can improve, but it isn’t lagging far behind like their secondary scoring.

If you include PP goals against the Oilers sit at 108, while San Jose is at 116, Colorado 113, Vegas 106, Calgary 103, Winnipeg and Dallas 98, Anaheim 96 and Nashville 91. Edmonton has allowed two more PP goals than the Flames, four more than Nashville and one fewer than the Ducks and six fewer than Colorado.

I would argue the depth scoring is hurting this team much more than overall team defence. The Oilers top-four goal scorers have combined for the fourth most goals in the NHL. The rest of the forwards are 31st and that is why the Caggiula for Brandon Manning trade made little sense to me. Manning isn’t that much better than Gravel at this point, at least from what I’ve watched and what the underlying numbers suggest.


The Oilers have to hope that two of Khaira, Spooner, Puljujarvi, Kassian, Rattie, Lucic or Rieder can get some traction and be solid supporting scorers. If the first 40 games are any indication then Khaira is the best bet to get going, but he’s playing centre again and I think he is better as a left winger.

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below

The good news for the Oilers is McDavid, Draisaitl and Nugent-Hopkins are showing no signs of slowing down. It would be unexpected if Chiasson scored another 16 goals in the second half, but so far he has been very consistent all season. He hasn’t got hot for a week or two. When he’s in the lineup he has produced and I hope when he returns he is skating on Nugent-Hopkins’ right side.

Go to A Game

If you want to win a pair of lower bowl seats to watch Aleksander Barkov battle McDavid next Thursday then in the comment section fill out which forward not named McDavid, Draisaitl, RNH or Chiasson will score the next goal. You need to put their name, which upcoming game (LA, ANA or SJ), the period and time. Whoever is closest will win the seats.

Good luck and Happy New Year.

Recently by Jason Gregor:

  • J-Dub

    Thanks Mr. Gregor for this fine post. As a longtime loyal Oilers fan, it’s been agonizing watching the organization continue to try to plug the leaky holes from defense, to management, to coaching, to forwards, and so on. It would be nice to have a time machine to go back to before Chiarelli was brought on board (as our roster I believe would be more competitive than it is now). It would be nice to go back to when we had relatively successful coaches working with VERY little (eg Krueger and Nelson – I wonder what they could have done with McDavid). As much analytics as we have on the team, perhaps we need to have tailored analytics for each player to work on exactly what they need to help this team.

    1) Outside of Mcdavid, Drai, Nuge – nobody else seems to have much success driving the puck into the offensive zone.

    2) Related to (1), players like Pulj, Rieder, Kassian should use their speed/size take the puck wide, and drive to the net (below the dot). From there – take a shot or center it into the slot, by then there should be support available to receive the pass or get the rebound. Far too often I see Pulj quit at the top of the circle and take an ineffective wrist shot on goal, with the rest of his line, skating towards the net as the goalie covers it.

    3) Players need to work on breakaways. Rieder and Kassian need to score on their opportunities. They need to simplify and practice one “GO TO” move over and over again – and just “DO IT”. Personally, I would like to see the players deke to the forehand, as it gives them more time to delay and get the puck up once the goalie has committed. See the game where both Nuge and McD deked to the forehand in the shootout.

    4) Get Rattie back in a top 6 role. He had 3 assists just a couple games ago, and he’s getting shots on goal and hitting posts. He’s doing a fine job on the top PP unit, screening the goalie. I love Struddy – but his comment about Rattie not getting a shot last game – is because he’s playing on the 4th line. On the PP – he’s the screen man – so the opportunity to shoot is lower. He might have gotten a chance for the rebound had Drai’s deflection not gone in.

    5) Lucic needs to stay in a bottom 6 role. He’s most effective when he’s physical and wears down the other team. I’m not going to question his pay, but the play dies with him too often – which is to the detriment of the lines expected to score.

    6) We don’t have enough shooters on our roster. Zykov was supposed to be a shooter – but I don’t know if he was given a fair shake to even test out his twig. However, players sometimes have to make their own luck to get noticed – eg Chiasson. Give the guys with even a “history” of offense, and study their past successes, and try to setup plays to recreate the “sweet spots” for the players.

    7) In the off season, Pulj needs to work on his first 3 steps. Go train with Draisaitl – as he had this problem too early on. Pulj needs to work on his puck control as well (perhaps adding some tape to his blade may help with the puck control). He has to be one of the minority in the league that doesn’t tape the entire blade. Oates might suggest, he cut his stick shorter 🙂

    8) Yamamoto needs some confidence playing in the top 6. Far too often he defers to the big 3 to drive the play. Kid has a solid shot, and should use it.

    9) Maybe give this kid Tye Felhaber a look. Kid has sick hands – and looks to be scorer – tearing up the OHL.

    10) Chia needs to go. Team’s gotten worse since he’s come to town. Reminds me of Costanza running the Yankees.

    Anyways – always the Oiler’s hopeful. Looking forward to seeing the team go on a winning streak 🙂

    Rattie in the 2nd period against LA with 6 min left on the clock.

  • TKB2677

    Lucic is baffling to me. I wasn’t a fan of the contract but I thought given he was only late 20’s when he signed, they would get at least 2, maybe 3 good years as in his usual totals (20+ 50 pts) out of him. Then one he is over 30, probably 2 more years of decline where you are getting say 13-15 goals, 35-40 pts. Then the last 2 seasons you are getting 10 or less goals, 25 pts so 4th line numbers. I know his skating isn’t great and won’t get any better so I expected the rush goals to decline as he got older but with him just being that big and strong, just being around the net to clean up the garbage and basically ram a few in was what I expected as he got older. But even that is gone. It’s one thing where if you are a player who rely on your skating, quickness and the ability to get open to score. So as you slow down, it becomes harder to get open or get your shot off. It’s another where you are like Lucic who is just a huge body who mucks it up in front and in the corners and relies on his huge frame to create space and is more of a just ram it in guy.