Time With Ales Hemsky/Alexander Ovechkin – Debunking the Liam Reddox Myth
14 years ago
This is a pretty straight-forward post, inspired by some discussion in Jason Gregor’s post yesterday: a list of minutes played with Ales Hemsky by Oilers forwards over the course of the season.
All raw data courtesy of HockeyAnalysis.com.
Ales Hemsky’s Linemates
The chart lists first total minutes, followed by what percentage of the time each player was with Hemsky. Ales Hemsky played 1030 minutes and 23 seconds at even-strength last year. Only players with more than ten minutes are counted.
- Shawn Horcoff – 745:02 (72.3%)
- Dustin Penner – 353:46 (34.3%)
- Ales Kotalik – 161:37 (15.7%)
- Sam Gagner – 152:09 (14.8%)
- Ethan Moreau – 134:49 (13.1%)
- Erik Cole – 97:57 (9.5%)
- Robert Nilsson – 94:47 (9.2%)
- Patrick O’Sullivan – 89:42 (8.7%)
- Andrew Cogliano – 72:34 (7.0%)
- Kyle Brodziak – 55:59 (5.4%)
- Liam Reddox – 28:01 (2.7%)
- Marc Pouliot – 17:44 (1.7%)
Alexander Ovechkin’s Linemates
Meanwhile, for fun contrast, here’s the same type of chart for Alexander Ovechkin over in Washington. Ovechkin played 1316:11 at even strength last season.
- Nicklas Backstrom – 1009:52 (76.7%)
- Viktor Kozlov – 557:09 (42.3%)
- Alexander Semin – 365:22 (27.8%)
- Sergei Fedorov – 184:29 (14.0%)
- Michael Nylander – 130:50 (9.9%)
- Eric Fehr – 79:46 (6.1%)
- Chris Clark – 59:59 (4.6%)
- Brooks Laich – 52:20 (4.0%)
- Boyd Gordon – 40:45 (3.1%)
- David Steckel – 40:30 (3.1%)
- Matt Bradley – 40:02 (3.0%)
The New MacT Sucks Meme
Because Lord knows we need one.
I give you a new stick to beat MacTavish with: Craig MacTavish is a lousy NHL coach because he didn’t play Liam Reddox with Ales Hemsky enough.
Matt Bradley got 3% of Alex Ovechkin’s ice-time, and he only scored 11 points in 81 games. Liam Reddox scored 12 points in only 46 games – clearly, a better offensive record. Bruce Boudreau probably would have given Reddox 5% of Ovechkin’s ice-time.
Seriously, though, I think this is definitive: Liam Reddox’s single game on the top line was an aberration – exactly the same kind of aberration that happens on every team in the NHL. To beat Craig MacTavish’s record with it after comparing these charts is indescribably stupid; unless the consensus is that Bruce Boudreau is also a lousy coach – in which case it only takes a five second look at players like Rick Nash and Henrik Zetterberg to know that this is a common NHL occurrence.
Recent articles from Jonathan Willis
