logo

WWYDW: The Edmonton Oilers and the remains of free agency

alt
Photo credit:Robert Mayer/USA TODAY Sports
Jonathan Willis
6 years ago
Less than a week into NHL free agency, and the vast majority of the big names and a large swath of the little names have been cleared off the board. That puts us officially in bargain-hunting territory, and Edmonton Oilers GM Peter Chiarelli has hinted that his team might be in the hunt for a bargain or two prior to the start of next season.
In Chiarelli’s shoes, which players would you be looking at?

Centre

Pos.PlayerRolesNotes
CMikhail GrigorenkoPP/PK2012 12th OV pick won 58% of his faceoffs
CBrandon PirriPP57 goals in 226 NHL games; avg. 21 per 82 games
CMike FisherPP/PKTwo years of negligble 5v5 scoring now
CJay McClementPK54% on faceoffs over last three years
CJohn MitchellPK55% on faceoffs, offense disappeared
CRyan WhitePKPhysical utility guy had 16 points last year
CChris VandeVeldePKOilers draft pick physical, won 52% of faceoffs
CChris KellyPKNow 36, underlying numbers in sharp decline
CMike RibeiroPPMaybe the NHL’s most sheltered player
CSergey KalininPKPhysical, pure DZ specialist
CAndrew DesjardinsPKOne point, 57% on faceoffs
CVernon FiddlerPK4 points in 59 games for 37-year-old
The Oilers have room to add a centre, perhaps as a No. 13/14 forward or just possibly a little higher up the lineup, though of course he might also spend some time on wing.
To my mind, there are two possibilities on the list above.
The first is someone young with some upside, specifically one of Mikhail Grigorenko or Brandon Pirri. Grigorenko still gets slagged as a casual player, but he’s also massive, had really decent on-ice results for a miserable Colorado team last year, and has added faceoffs and penalty killing to his strengths. There’s also offensive potential there yet to be unlocked. Pirri is less interesting but knows how to score goals and might be a cheap complement on a line with high-end talents.
The other option is a reserve guy, someone to play the Matt Hendricks role from last season. There are four or five players on the list above who would qualify; if I had to pick one I’d gamble on John Mitchell, who tallied 10-plus goals for four straight years before last season.

Wing

Pos.PlayerRolesNotes
RWJaromir JagrPP45 years old, 54% Fenwick last season
LWDaniel WinnikPKUtility guy had 12 goals, does a bit of everything
RWJiri HudlerPP31 goals in 2014-15
RWP-A ParenteauPP13 goals, 6th time in 7 years he’s had 10+
RWBrian GiontaPP/PKTopped 10 goals for fifth straight year
RWAlex ChiassonPP/PK6’3″, 208 lbs, 26 years old, played at BU
LWThomas VanekPPSheltered like crazy, 48 points
LWDwight KingPK28, 6’4″, 232lbs; offence cratered last season
LWKenneth AgostinoPPSigned in Boston
RWTeddy PurcellPP/PKPerformed well in Edmonton previously
RWShane DoanPPRight shot had 12 PPG in 2015-16
RWJarome IginlaPPNow 40; scoring dried up last year
LWViktor StalbergPP/PKOffence is sliding, turns 32 in January
RWScottie UpshallPKFine work last year on pure DZ forward unit
RWAndrej NestrasilPP23 points in 55 GP in 2015-16
RWDrew StaffordPPLast outperformed team Fenwick% in 2011
LWRene BourquePP12 goals highest since 2011-12
RWJack SkillePhysical, reasonable offence for L4 option
LWMilan MichalekPP/PK446 career NHL points, history with McLellan
LWLauri KorpikoskiPP/PKBought out by Edmonton last summer
LWMatt HendricksPKDefensive specialist now a part-time player
RWStephen GiontaPK2 goals in 108 NHL games over last 2 seasons
LWTanner GlassPlayer-type is rapidly disappearing from NHL
RWChris Neil1 goal in 53 games, sniped coach over ice-time
There are too many options here to go through them all.
Jaromir Jagr would be an extremely popular pick-up option for the Oilers, and the man can clearly still play. For most NHL teams, including Edmonton, he’d be my preference over another famous old guy like Shane Doan or Jarome Iginla.
Daniel Winnik is what Lowetide would call a “Fernando Pisani-type” winger and could conceivably fit in anywhere. Brian Gionta and Viktor Stalberg are lower-end examples of the same general kind of player and there are a few others who might fit that description on this list. Alex Chiasson is not a guy I’d look at in this role, but having played at Boston University he’ll be a familiar name for Chiarelli.
There are some pure-offence and pure-defence types that might be useful in the right role. Jiri Hudler is the most interesting name to me of a scoring group that includes P-A Parenteau and Thomas Vanek as well. Dwight King and Scottie Upshall are potential Matt Hendricks replacements.

Defence

Pos.PlayerRolesNotes
LDAndrei MarkovPP/PKBest defenceman on the market
RDCody FransonPP/PKIs he fast, aggressive enough for McLellan?
LDBrian CampbellPPTailed off last season; now age 38
LDNikita NesterovPP24 years old, some offensive dimension
RDRoman PolakPKEric Gryba, but a little better
RDChristian Folin (off market now)PKGood chem with Brodin, sunk with Scandella
LDJohn-Michael LilesPP/PK56% Fenwick, 52% Goals in sheltered role
LDYohann AuvituPPOlder rookie last year, has offensive ability
LDMark StreitPP/PK27 points in 68 games for the 39-year-old
LDJohnny OduyaPKStill playing nasty DZ minutes
RDNate ProsserPKCompetent end-of-roster type
LDJyrki Jokipakka45% Fenwick rating last season
LDFedor TyutinPKGot killed in defensive minutes w/ Tyson Barrie
RDDennis WidemanPP/PK56 points in 2014-15, history with Chiarelli
RDTom GilbertPK34-year-old played more AHL than NHL in 16-17
LDJakub KindlNo longer a full-time NHL player
RDMatt TennysonFringe NHL’er has history with McLellan
LDEric GelinasMinus-22 in 27 AHL games
There are still NHL defencemen available in free agency who could conceivably help Edmonton.
Andrei Markov would be a great fit but will certainly cost too much. Cody Franson is likely to be more affordable, but lacks high-end mobility or aggression and seems to me a terrible fit for Todd McLellan.
The “Andrej Sekera stopgap” class has a bunch of entries. I like Brian Campbell or Mark Streit, others might prefer someone like John-Michael Liles of Johnny Oduya.
If we’re looking past guaranteed stopgaps, Nikita Nesterov and Christian Folin stand out as younger guys who might be able to carve out a role beyond a single season. Yohann Auvitu belongs somewhere in this mix too, and if you’re a big Jyrki Jokipakka fan and squint really hard he might as well.
We should also mention Roman Polak, who played nearly 18 minutes per game for Toronto last season. He has a lot in common with current Oiler Eric Gryba, but is a more established NHL option. I’m very curious to see if he commands a multi-year deal or has to settle for another one-year pact.
That’s all from me. So: Which bargain free agent(s) would you like to see Edmonton pursue?

Planning a summer getaway?

What Would You Do for your dream vacation? The Nation and Contiki want to help you get there. Visit www.contiki.com for the best vacation ideas around the globe, and enter promo code  PPCTHENATION on any trip, 7 days or longer, and get $100 off your trip.”

Check out these posts...