David Perron: MacTavish’s Masterpiece?

With the Edmonton Oilers struggling as they are, Craig MacTavish hasn’t exactly been given a free pass by fans in his first full season as general manager. What even his most ardent critics should agree on, though, is that it looks like he fleeced the St. Louis Blues when he pawned off Magnus Paajarvi and a draft pick in exchange for David Perron.

Perron was already a pretty good player when MacTavish added him. But the 25-year-old forward is on pace to exceed his previous career bests – and by a lot.

The Basic Numbers

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below

The chart above shows Perron’s 82-game pace from every season in his career where he played more than 40 games. The only preceding season even close to his early work this year was 2011-12, where Perron rode a high shooting percentage to a 30-goal pace.

The really astonishing item here is Perron’s shot totals. Players don’t typically see huge leaps in shot totals, but Perron is running at more than double his established career rate. What’s going on?


Numbers for this chart (and the next one) come from ExtraSkater.com and BehindtheNet.ca.

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below

There really isn’t much to see at this level: Perron is a hair below his career goal numbers and a touch above his career assist numbers.

But something interesting happens when we compare Perron’s shot numbers for this season to last season. Perron had 61 shots at five-on-five in 48 games a year ago; this season he has 54 in 20 games. He’s firing the puck roughly twice as often as he has in the past once ice-time is accounted for. His goal totals are only at his career rate because his shooting percentage is half what it was last year at even-strength.

In short: he’s been good so far, but if these shot numbers are for real he’s likely going to be even better at evens in the near future. Which is frightening.


Perron’s numbers are through the roof here. Some of that may come from playing on a better power play unit – it’s extremely difficult to separate teammate and coaching effects from player talent when looking at special teams numbers – and the assist totals in particular may not be ridiculous.

As for the goal totals? Digging into the shot numbers again, we find that Perron is again firing the puck at roughly twice the rate he did in St. Louis, but this time his shooting percentage is roughly double what it was last season. This to some degree will off-set the expected rise in his five-on-five shooting percentage.

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below

In other words, these numbers are likely going to come down because that spike in shooting percentage probably isn’t sustainable, but even so he’s legitimately on pace for a career-best season.

The Biggest Question

I can’t recall an instance of an experienced NHL forward suddenly doubling his shot rates at the age of 25. One of the reasons people like me prize shot rates so much is because they tend to be pretty stable; players reach an established level of ability and move a bit but the fluctuations are nowhere near as dramatic as shooting percentage is.

I don’t know if Perron can keep up this shooting pace, and I didn’t watch him closely enough in St. Louis to hazard a guess as to what’s changed. One item that stands out – Tyler Dellow brought it to my attention on Twitter last night – is that Perron is getting a higher percentage of his shots through to the net (he has 16 missed shots on 80 shots this year; last year the number was 31 on 84) and that seems like something that probably won’t continue, but it isn’t close to being the whole explanation either.

My gut feeling is that Perron shoots a little less frequently simply because this is so far out of the norm, but at the same time it seems entirely possible to me that this is a breakout campaign and an indication of a more trigger-happy player.

If so, that’s fantastic news for Edmonton. Perron is under contract for two more years at a $3.812 million cap hit; that’s a pretty fair deal for a 50-point guy and a ridiculously good deal for a player who will challenge for 30 goals every year if he keeps shooting like this.

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below

  • Oil Kings 'n' Pretty Things

    All I know is that I picked him up in the 18th round of my fantasy draft because of a comment on the trade article that predicted an uptick in his production.

    Couldn’t be happier.

  • Jordan McNugent-Hallkins

    What a trade by MacT, St Louis was thoroughly fleeced. Their backs were to the (cap) wall, but it’s good to see a GM capable of making a calculated move against a team backed into a corner. Usually it’s the Oilers between the hammer and the anvil.

    The Smid trade is still a head scratcher though, ol’ silver fox must be confident he can get Belov to re-sign.

    • camdog

      I’m starting to follow Mact’s logic here, not saying that I agree, but I understand.

      Mact thinks that Klefbomb will be as tough as Smid and ready for next season. Between Belov and N.Shultz the Smid role became redundant. The organization doesn’t think Smid is good enough with the puck and not tough enough to warrant keeping around for another 3 seasons at his projected salary and subsequent cap hit.

      • Jordan McNugent-Hallkins

        If the ‘Smid with offense’ comparison of Klefbom is correct, then I would completely understand jettisoning Smid at his cap hit. But if Belov elects to go to a contender, and Klefbom doesn’t live up to his billing, the Oilers could be hurting for defensemen next year.

        Here’s hoping Belov signs here and the big Swede is all that and a bag of chips. I’m looking forward to shouting ‘DROP THE K-BOMB’ when opponents cross the blue.

        • pkam

          The Habs just signed Alexei Emelin to 4 years @ 4.1M per. I guess Belov will be asking somewhere around that number. If we believe we can sign him to 3-4 years @ 3.5M per, then it is a better contract that Smid’s 3.5M contract.

      • pkam

        I agree with the assessment of Smid and agree he is redundant. But I am still pissed at that trade for the little return that we get.

        Perron is also redundant in the Blues roster and they need to dump his salary, yet they get something back in MPS and a 2nd. What do we get for Smid? A 170 lb AHL center and a goalie prospect who just graduated from WHL. I don’t care about giving Roy because he won’t get us anything anyway.

        Didn’t San Jose Sharks get 2 2nd round picks for Douglas Murray last year at trade deadline? I’ll take Smid over Murray any day. So can we at least get one 2nd round pick for Smid?

        • Oil Kings 'n' Pretty Things

          This is my main beef with it. If they thought he was redundant for next year, the right move is to wait for the trade deadline when even mediocre defencemen will net a decent return from teams making a push.

          • Old Retired Guy (A.K.A. Die-Nasty)

            You make a good point……It makes you wonder about the details……did they consider moving Nick Schultz before Smid but could find no takers? Did they value N Schultz more than Smid?(which would imply that they think Smids reputation as a tough gritty D man was exaggerated)….or did they value them about equally but liked the Schultz contract more ….or was it that the return for Smid was greater than what was offered for Schultz?

            Also, did their scouts value Brossoit and Horak more than most of us casual observers do?

            Also, is the new management style gaining traction?…..not waiting around once a decision is made….impatient….etc.

            I wish the local media would ask these questions in the pressers….or maybe they did and I missed it?

  • While Perron is an obvious win for MacTavish, Like most Oilers fans I’m still left wanting more!

    While Perron was a win, it has little consultation to myself this year.

    MacTavish talk at the beginning of the year just seems to be complete lip service.

    I want more, hell, I demand more after 8 years of inept management!!

    Get us two top pairing defesmen, Two centermen and a third & forth line for Pete sake.

    • Jordan McNugent-Hallkins

      Top pairing defenders don’t grow on trees, as much as I wish they did. And it’s a little more complicated than getting a couple centres, MacT needs to find a couple centres that bring an element the Oil are missing, namely size and functional toughness. And those don’t grown on trees either.

      I’d say they have the pieces to make a good 3rd line. The fourth line definitely needs a serious overhaul, when you’re right, you’re right.

  • Romulus' Apotheosis

    Dubnyk has not been rock solid, his corners are still the place to get goals, he’s been beat so many times and saved by the post the past games.

    With the Hawks, those guys don’t miss a lot so I aspect him to be as soft as butter on Jennifer Garners a**.

    • pkam

      I have said before, by the end of the year, his SV% will be .915 or better, mean average or better than average.

      Dubnyk’s number is about the same as Crawford and Crawford has a much better team in front of him.

      If we want an elite goalie, than Dubnyk is not the answer. But who is going to trade away their elite goalie?

      Before we can develop our elite goalie (either we draft our own or we trade for a prospect with the potential), I think we are stuck with Dubnyk.

    • Ya, ok.

      ~After wins vs the powerhouse Blue Jackets & the Flames, this set Dubnyk up for the real test which was the Panthers! ~

      If Dubnyks the answer, then why are the Oilers looking so hard for a replacement?

      Don’t answer that, I’ll come back to that after December & January.

      You do this Rom, I tell you Paajarvi is junk, you throw stats at me, I tell you Hartikainen is junk you still throw stats.

      Tell me something you know that the coaching staff & management don’t know? Cause you are a complete miss on both Paajarvi & Hartkainen despite what the eyes tell everyone.

  • pkam

    Mact did great getting Perron,Gordon and Ferrence,and I gotta think theres something coming after getting rid of Smid,so i give him a b+ for that.He gets a d+ for the goaltending issue though and hope he fixes that during the off season

    • Jordan McNugent-Hallkins

      I’ll give him credit for chasing Schneider and Bishop, at least he recognizes the weakness in net. Was it ever revealed what Gillis was asking for? Schneider would look great between the pipes in orange and blue right now, and this season would probably have started much differently.

      Plus my sister is a massive Vancouver fan, I’d have loved to be able to rub her nose in it.