Don’t Expect a Massive Payday for Justin Schultz


Taylor Hall got $6.0 million per season coming out of his entry-level contract. So did Jordan Eberle. So did Ryan Nugent-Hopkins.

By the sounds of it, Justin Schultz will not be joining the club.

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below

Craig MacTavish talked to the media from Jasper on Monday, and after discussing the deal with Jeff Petry he was asked whether we could expect to see a similar announcement with regard to Schultz. His answer was illuminating.

“That’s still ongoing,” he said, before offering some optimism. “I think that both sides fully expect to get a deal. We want to treat Justin very, very fairly.”

Well, that sounds good for Schultz, right?

“He’s working his way through the system,” MacTavish said. “I guess at this point that’s probably the friction point. When you even compare him to guys on our team, where he fits in is not going to be entirely reflective of our value of him, it’s more a reflection of the system and where he is in the system.”

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below

When MacTavish talks about where Schultz fits in, he must mean financially. In other words, he hopes the defenceman doesn’t take it personally when the Oilers pay him less than his high-profile teammates at forward.

Kid Gloves

Craig MacTavish2

But while the Oilers clearly seem to have a line they don’t want to cross in terms of payment, that doesn’t mean they want to alienate a player they see as a key piece moving forward. As evidence of that, MacTavish offered the team’s decision not to take Schultz to club-elected arbitration.

“We didn’t file,” he said. “The thinking there was that we didn’t want to go through that divisive process with [Schultz]. He’s very much one of our core players and the last thing we want to do is get into that type of relationship with a guy like that because he’s got huge upside.”

That’s a pretty decent rationale, but there’s another good one, too. Sportsnet’s Tyler Dellow put it plainly:

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below

It’s pretty hard to put a number on defensive performance. It’s really easy to say, “yes, but POINTS!” and with Schultz leading the Oilers in average time on ice last season Edmonton would have some trouble arguing he was the disaster in his own end that he so often was.

Avoiding the route where the team hammers the player in front of the arbitrator and still ends up paying him money because he’s put points on the board seems like a smart route for the Oilers. We’ll see where the dollars come in on the final contract but from this vantage point the team’s resistance to just giving him the wunderkind special also seems like an intelligent way to proceed.


  • Serious Gord

    Oilers want him to be Duncan Keith, but Schultz is more like Karlsson, who makes $6.5 million.

    Give Schultz the lattitude that Karlsson gets in Ottawa, and he would put up Karlsson type numbers, or close to it.

    Trouble is that Oilers never play to the players ability and are always trying to make them something they are not.

    Play him with Fayne and let him run. He will score more points than the Nuge.

    Can’t we have at least one D-man who scores more than 20 points.

    $ 5.25 for 6 years.

      • Zarny

        Just, saying he is more like Karlsson than Keith. With a stay a home partner he could jump up more often. Karlsson only had 26 points in his first season. Lets see where Schultz will be in five years.

        We need more scoring from the D, period.

        You might remember Coffey , he was that great on the backend either.

        Manya fans here on the board wanted Oilers to acquire OEL, well we have one in our backyard.

    • Tikkanese

      I hope he is Karlsson good someday but he is probably going to be more like Mike Green offensive numbers(in his healthy prime) minus the hitting.

      Whatever happened to Schultz’s “good stick defensively” that Stu “The Magnificent Bastard” Macgregor promised us? Probably went to the same place that Smid’s “big slapshot” went.