Yes but Calgary should of scored more so their season didn't ride on the refs
Nation Sites
The Nation Network
OilersNation has no direct affiliation to the Edmonton Oilers, Oilers Entertainment Group, NHL, or NHLPA
Nation Thoughts: Should Blake Coleman’s Goal Have Counted?
May 29, 2022, 18:00 EDTUpdated: May 30, 2022, 14:10 EDT
I am not sure how many of us would have predicted this but here we are. The Edmonton Oilers are in the Western Conference Finals and four wins away from returning to the Stanley Cup finals for the first time since 2006.
The dream became more realistic on Thursday night when Connor McDavid scored the overtime winner past Jacob Markstrom, giving the Oilers a 5-4 win on the night and a 4-1 series victory. That goal, however, was not the only talking point that came from that game.
Late in the third period, it looked as though @Blake Coleman had given the Flames their own 5-4. However, after a review, the goal was called back. The officials deemed that Coleman kicked the puck past Mike Smith. Whenever a decision like this is made, conversation springs from it from both sides. Should it have been a goal? Should it have not?
Now, this is where I open up the stage to you, Oilersnation. What did you think of the call?
Call on the play was a goal, refs looked at play long and hard and deemed that they clearly saw enough of a kicking motion to Overturn their original call. Refs don’t want to do that, so no goal is correct call.
I like this take from Ray. The officials were irrelevant the entire game. The whistles were away, and they wanted no affiliation to how the outcome on the ice finished.
Do I think he kicked it, yes. Should it have counted, also yes. If it had of been ruled no goal on the ice, I can see the call staying. I’m shocked it was overturned
I think the big takeaway here is the rule is dumb. We should turf it to take more of the game’s results out of ref and war room hands. I do worry that if kicking is more prevalent that it’s putting goalies and downed players in more danger, but I’m not sure how valid that is.
By definition of the rule, it was the right call but I’ve seen many similar or worse get called a goal that I’d legitimately be pissed if the flames were my team.
Better question...would it really have mattered?
Honestly I thought it should’ve counted , until I heard Coleman’s post game interview
It was a little strange to hear the comments from Coleman postgame. Basically, admitting that he kicked the puck, which should end this entire debate.
Reverse angle convinced me. Distinct kicking motion. Surprised they called it all the same.
I agree with Bruce.
My initial thought was no. I did not think there was enough to overturn the call on the ice.
Here’s the angle that Bruce refers to, and I would assume the one that changed the NHL’s decision. It looks like he kicks it.
However, there are a few different factors to consider from the other side of the argument.
- He was falling to the ice and skating on one leg.
- Did Cody Ceci force Coleman’s leg in that direction?
- What even is a distant kicking motion?
My initial reaction to the review was goaltender interference. When Coleman caught Mike Smith’s pad, I thought that the puck came loose. When they said he kicked in the puck, I was unsure what the call would be.
Honestly, I am still unsure of what the rule even is. We have seen goals that were kicked in.
It will be a debate for a long time. However, it’s not like it was a series-defining play. Calgary had plenty of time to score again in regulation and then overtime.
Then, as an Edmonton Oilers fan, we have been on the other side of a terrible call, Ryan Kesler, in 2017. It is much nicer to be on this side of the situation. The Oilers were the better team for four of the five games and deservedly are in the Western Conference Finals.
With that being said, bring on the Colorado Avalanche.
Breaking News
- Oilers Game Notes: Edmonton searches for first four-game win streak of season
- Former Oilers winger Evander Kane plays in 1,000th NHL game
- Pre-Scout: Oilers look to keep stacking performances against McMann-led Kraken
- Oilers injury update: Trent Frederic and Colton Dach are ‘very close’ to lineup return
- Friedman: Cassidy’s ‘frayed relationship’ with Golden Knights players began in Oilers’ playoff series