I think we should keep bringing in offensive power and keep dumping defenseman to make it work
Nation Sites
The Nation Network
OilersNation has no direct affiliation to the Edmonton Oilers, Oilers Entertainment Group, NHL, or NHLPA
Nation Thoughts: Should the Oilers Acquire Patrick Kane?
Photo credit: Stan Szeto-USA TODAY Sports
Sep 1, 2022, 09:00 EDTUpdated: Aug 31, 2022, 17:46 EDT
The hot topic around Oil Country the past few weeks revolves around a former Stanley Cup Champion. The Chicago Blackhawks are tearing the organization down to the studs, potentially resulting in Patrick Kane departing the team.
We all know the player that Kane is. He’s an elite scoring winger who would make any team better. Of course, Kane also comes with some off-the-ice baggage, which many of you mentioned in response to this week’s Nation Thoughts tweet.
On the ice, he’s one of the best and has proven that year after year. Kane has played over 1100 games in the NHL, all with Chicago, and has 1180 points and 430 goals. Last season, the former first overall pick hit the 90-point mark (92) for the first time since 2019. Kane did this on a Blackhawks team that didn’t have another player score at a point-per-game rate. Kane is now 33 years old with one year left on his contract at $10.5 million. A contract that almost every team in the NHL would struggle to acquire.
With those three things being considered, should the Edmonton Oilers acquire Patrick Kane?
No. #Letsgooilers need to prioritize getting McLeod signed and strengthening the D core. We already have one of the best top 6 in the league. Kane is a luxury we don't need. At the moment we're an injury away from a Broberg/Niemo 3rd pair and I like both but it's not ideal
No,for two simple reasons 1- money? Where do we find any money for him when we’re already over cap & needing to sign McLeod (which is more of a LONG TERM solution IMO) 2- we need to prioritize defence, we already have an explosive offence, so we need to worry about the back end
Oilers need a elite shut down defenseman first.
Many people in the comments spoke about the Oilers acquiring a new defender rather than trading for Kane. Those people aren’t wrong by any means. The Oilers blueline needs some serious help on the defensive side of things.
I am way more neutral on it than I though I would be. If it happens, awesome. There will be some unbelievable, mind-blowing offense this year. If it doesn't happen, cool let's focus on strengthening the d.
I believe the price for the season will be too much. Maybe go after him at the deadline. Be cheaper
Yes because he would make the offence unstoppable .
Window is open now. Do it
"Where there's smoke, there's fire!"
yea because they'd win the cup 100%
Yes, he’s the best US born player ever. 92 points on a horrible CHI team.
Feel free to check out the rest of the comments on my Twitter.
It was a reasonably even debate for this week’s Nation Thoughts, with the final decision split right down the middle. There are many pros and cons with Patrick Kane and what the Oilers look like with or without him.
There’s no denying the Oilers need another defenceman. Losing Duncan Keith is a more significant loss than people want to admit, and Ken Holland is yet to replace his 20 minutes a night. Adding Kane wouldn’t help stop the puck; however, maybe outscoring the opponent by two or three goals a night is the way Holland wants to go.
The acquisition cost is intriguing. Edmonton doesn’t have the cap space to add Kane for picks, so players with money value would have to return to Chicago. Could one of those players be Warren Foegele? He’s still a young promising player at 26 years old with a cap hit of $2.750 for two more years. By no means is Foegele enough, but he’s a way to add money to the deal. The rest would need to be retained by Chicago and possibly even a third team.
Holland will need to be creative if he wants to do this workout. Can he do that? Stay tuned for now.
I want the Oilers to acquire Kane. It won’t help the #1 need for a blueliner; however, the defenders in Edmonton are good enough to make them a top team in the Western Conference throughout the regular season. Then, when the trade deadline comes around, Holland can take a shot and get another defenseman as he did with Brett Kulak at the last deadline.
Plus, a team with Kane, Connor McDavid and Leon Draisaitl feels like something you’d see in a video game, not in the real NHL. When you add Evander Kane, Ryan Nugent-Hopkins and Zach Hyman to that group, who will outscore the Oilers?
Breaking News
- ‘It’s going to be a big hole’: Knoblauch hints at extended absence for Oilers’ Henrique after Game 1 injury
- Two-goal nights from Dickinson, Kapanen, lift Oilers to 4-3 Game 1 win over Ducks: Recap, Reaction and Highlights
- Oilers’ Leon Draisaitl activated off long-term injured reserve, will return for Game 1
- NHL Notebook: Playoff hockey is back in Buffalo, Dowd and Durzi at the centre of tensions between Golden Knights, Mammoth
- Consistent, league-average goaltending is what the Oilers need from Connor Ingram in the playoffs