Ken Holland was a busy man in the 2021 offseason.
He had a wide array of holes to fill on the Oilers.
The team was looking for a new goaltender to move away from Mikko Koskinen and Mike Smith. He wanted to bring in a dynamic difference-maker in the top-six. He wanted to solidify the third line centre role and add more depth to the bottom-six, and the Oilers needed more depth on their backend, too.
He didn’t hesitate to kick things off early by re-signing Devin Shore to a two-year, $850,000 deal. This was to help address the bottom-six depth.
He didn’t get Duncan Keith for free, but gave up Caleb Jones and a conditional third-round pick to take on the full two-year, $5.5-million cap hit he had. This was to help solidify the left-side.
Advertisement
Ad
He bought out James Neal’s remaining years of his contract. This was to free up some cap space.
He re-signed Mike Smith to a two-year, $2.2-million deal. This was to solidify the goaltending spot.
Weeks later, he moved Ethan Bear for Warren Foegele on the opening day of free agency. This was to address bottom-six depth.
That same day and soon thereafter, Holland made a number of moves.
He signed Zach Hyman to a seven-year, $5.5-million deal. This was the top-six difference-maker.
He re-signed Tyson Barrie to a three-year, $4.5-million deal. This was to help provide depth on the backend.
He signed Cody Ceci to a four-year, $3.25-million deal. This was to help boost the second pair.
He signed Derek Ryan to a two-year, $1.25-million deal. This was to solidify the 3C role and add bottom-six depth.
Advertisement
Ad
He re-signed Slater Koekkoek to a two-year, $925,000 deal. This was to give even both backend depth.
On paper, this seemed to check many of the boxes that the Oilers had. They got themselves a Cup-winning, Norris-winning defenceman in Duncan Keith who was supposed to have not lost a step and add lots to the back-end, Holland said. Hyman was brought in to be a dynamic player who could play in all facets of the game and produce alongside Connor McDavid.
And despite moving out two young defencemen in Caleb Jones and Ethan Bear, the addition of Ceci and bringing back Barrie was supposed to sure up the backend. Nothing to worry about, we were told.
Early on everything looked good. Edmonton started the year 9-1 posting a +17 goal differential looking like an absolute wagon. Since then, the wheels have fallen off entirely. In the 16 games since, the Oilers have gone 7-9 and a -6 goal differential.
Advertisement
Ad
And on Saturday night, an indictment of Ken Holland’s work was laid out in the public eye.
During the first intermission of the Oilers’ loss to the Carolina Hurricanes Saturday night, Sportsnet’s Elliotte Friedman spoke about what he could see the team looking to address in a trade and speculated on three roster spots: goaltending, the left-side of their defence and the third-line centre spot.
The problem is that this is exactly what the Oilers felt they did in the offseason. They brought back Mike Smith, who had a solid 2020-21 season, they brought in Keith who was supposed to be a rock-solid vet, and Ryan was supposed to be a difference-maker in a bottom-six that has bled goals against for years.
But none of that has happened. Smith has been injured virtually all season, Keith has looked average at best (and I think that’s generous) while Ryan has look like nothing as advertised.
Advertisement
Ad
In fact, things are so bad that the Oilers goals rate at 5×5 away from Connor McDavid, Leon Draisaitl and Ryan Nugent-Hopkins is just 25 percent. That means with any of these three off the ice this year, the Oilers have scored just nine goals and allowed 27.
Here’s the Oilers 5×5 goals rate over the last number of years without 97, 29 or 93.
GF%
GF
GA
2016-17 – Chiarelli
54.4
37
31
2017-18 – Chiarelli
38.9
35
55
2018-19 – Chiarelli
36.6
26
45
2019-20 – Holland
38.2
34
55
2020-21 – Holland
37.5
24
40
2021-22 (so far) – Holland
25
9
27
Things have not improved in Edmonton in terms of the depth of their roster. Even the additions of Hyman, Foegele and Ryan, on top of the emergence of Jesse Puljujarvi, haven’t been able to fill the void that’s been the Oilers depth.
Some of this falls on the feet of Dave Tippett. He is, after all, the one tasked with not only deploying players in positions to succeed but getting the most out of them. I don’t know if he’s doing a great job of either.
Advertisement
Ad
But at the end of the day, the person tasked with providing those players for the coach is the general manager: Ken Holland. His shopping list hasn’t changed from last offseason but the main difference is that he has no where near the amount of cap space to work with.
There’s lots of season left in the Oilers season and they can surely turn things around. I still think they’re a playoff team. The early returns on Holland’s offseason moves, however, have not been great.

Zach Laing is the Nation Network’s news director and senior columnist. He can be followed on Twitter at @zjlaing, or reached by email at [email protected]